Comments to Larry Morgan
Minuites for IEEE1346
10/3/94
Denver
Submitted By: Larry Morgan
P1346 Secretary
11/29/94
Guide or Recommended Practice ???
Discussion.....
Guide 1st....leading to a Practice...Aproval time the same ....
A way to do it ... or This is the way it should be done....
Guides are better where controversity exist...
Larry Conrad....Montion to change the PAR to a “Recommended practice”
Passed by a majority present... Intention is to give more “clout” to the work .
Change the title...??
Suggestion --- Electric Power System Compatability with Electronic Process Equipment
Passed majority of those present....( changed Industrial to Electronic to broaden group)
Van will revise the PAR to change the name of the group and the type of document under development.
Is this a subcommitte or working group.....????
To be discussed on WED at the SC 22 Meeting..
Cordination with other groups...Informal leasion...
p1159 valid ballot was obtained .... did not pass...recommended practice title is an issue..
Quanitative definitions table..Values are to be demonstative not definitive...
Gil Hensley has officially been charged by sc22 to set the IEEE Power Quality Definitions
C84 ...definitions still very loose Larry Conrad
Cordination liasions :
p1250..Dave Vanoy
p1100..Chris Melhorn
519....and 519 applications ... Chris Melhorn
EMC .. Murry for Tony StJohn
CBEMA ...Tom Key
Cbema is votinging on reviseing the CBEMA curve.
Pannel Session....Set and going for Thur Morning
Other Discussion...Detroit Edision is including a POWER QUALITY clause ..to GM , Ford, Mazda as part of an exclusive provider contractor... Detroit Edision to pay $10k to $350k....per event for events exceeding CBEMA curve and some “base line quanity of events”...
Lively Discusion followed....
Recomended Practice ... with the .. explaination parts to follow.
Compatability List...Where to from here ... one page ,Quote Includable. Graph that compairs Downtime cost with Sag Probabilities
List the “things to watch out for” as the first part of the ...
Goal .. Short “one pager purchase quote includable”
Recommended Practice Outline and ASSIGNMENTS:
Overview... Van Wagner.
Compatability Cost vs Probability Larry Morgan Larry Conrad
graph (Fig 9)
Check List .... Larry Morgan
Appendix
Down Time Cost.... Lynn Sanders & Ron Smith
Power System Performance.... Joe Groesch & Larry Conrad
Equipment Sensitivity .... Bob Kretschmann
Classification systems .... Steve Rossiter
References (later)
Definitions from the SC22 assignment... Gil Hensely & Larry Morgan
Drafts of each section should be submitted to the chairman no later than Feb 15, 1995.
The composite Recommended Practice will be distributed to the group prior to the May meeting.
:: Next Meeting IC&PS SanAntonia 1st Week of May.
Comments to Larry Morgan