P1394b S800 Long-Haul PMD Meeting, Fort Lauderdale Marriott North, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, December 2, 1997 Chairman: Colin Whitby-Strevens (colinws@bristol.st.com) Secretary: Richard Churchill (richard.churchill@compaq.com) Reflector: p1394b@zayante.com Web Site: http://www.zayante.com/p1394b/ FTP Site: ftp://ftp.zayante.com/p1394b/ (for MS IE users) ftp://ftp.zayante.com/ftp/pub/p1394b/ (for Netscape users) 1. Welcome and Introductions 2. Approval of Agenda 3. Approval of Minutes of Last Meeting 4. Report from S100 PMD Task Group 5. Optical connector proposal summary presentations 5.1 Fibrejack 5.2 Direct 5.3 VF-45 5.4 LC 5.5 Mini-MT 6. Connector Selection 7. Transceiver parameters 8. Future Plans and Schedule 9. AOB 10. Adjourn Meeting came to order at 8:35 AM 1. Welcome and Introductions Introductions were made, as usual 2. Approval of Agenda The proposed agenda was tendered. Questions were raised regarding the possible presentation of long-haul transceiver information, and as to the place in the order of things of the S800 Long-Haul PMD group. The action item for Del Hanson and others to address Transceiver issues was referenced, and 3. Approval of Minutes of Last Meeting Due to a lack of linkage of the minutes via the web site, they cannot be considered as having been distributed, despite timely publication. Therefore, approval of those minutes is deferred to a later meeting, after all have had time to review them. 4. Report from S100 PMD Task Group Report of S100 POF/HPCF PMD sub Task Group p1394b, December 2, 1997 chair: Shuntaro Yamazaki (NEC) Report ... November 10 @ NEC HQ, hosted by NEC, 15 attendees Connection scenarios between S100 and S800 (NEC) Voting for Working Document ver. 0.02 "The sub TG will move WD ver. 0.02 into the 1394b draft document, leaving connector section as TBD. An unique connector optimized for POF/HPCF is to be selected as a p1394b specification." There were 10 votes for, 4 against, and 1 abstention, and motion carried. Report ... November 26 @TFT hosted by Mitsubishi Rayon, 28 attendees Study report of worst case link loss for GI-HPCF (Sumitomo Electric) Connector loss 1.3 dB, Fiber loss 2.8 dB Amendment approved Connector selection criteria for POF/HPCF link was discussed and approved. S100 POF PMD sub TG transfers this selection process to 1394b committee. Selection process wil follow the decision of 1394b committee. [Proposed Motion for P1394b: p1394b committee specifies an unique connector optimized for POF/HPCF link. This connector specification is to be added to the section of POF/HPCF link in P1394b draft 0.06 or later version of the P1394b Draft.] >> Connection scenarios between S100 and S800 12/2/1997 P1394b, S100 POF/HPCF PMD sub TG NEC, Shuntaro Yamazaki 5. Optical connector proposal summary presentations Optical connector selection ... - We're governed by Roberts Rules of Order - not well adapted to multiple choice decisions - Propose - A series of ... Elimination straw poll voting chart ... Motion (proposed for the full p1394b committee) The p1394b S800 Task Group recommends that the p1394b specification for an optical connector for the multimode fibre be based on a reference to the -- connector - proposed - seconded - for: - against: - abstain: 5.1 Fibrejack Wienecek Panduit Why Fiber Jack? - Designed for fiber to the wall - meets all 1349b selection criteria - Accepts all fiber media - ... ... Designed for fiber to teh wall - RJ45 Style - Jack and Plug - No adapter! - Flush Mounting - Robust Interface - Compatible to existing mounting means - MiniCom, Keystone Safety/Mechanical - All four fibers within the fiber Jack are proof tested beyond 15 pounds - Note: Jacks will be placed within open panels and outlets ... - ... Meets 1394b Specification Criteria - Addition to matrix - .... Fiber jack Performance <<< table >>> - test results IEEE Patent License Assurance Statement ... Accepts ALL Fiber Media - 50 and 62.5 um Multi Mode GOF - ... ... Accepts All Fiber Media - Technology always changing - WDM on POF demo (8 wavelengths) - Offset Launch on MM GOF (threefold increase in bandwidth) - Gigabit ethernet length DOWNGRADED - Will 4 Gbit demand single mode? - Consumer Accptance of GOF unknown Open to all Technologies - FJ is an Interface only! - Uses SC Ferrules today - Pre-polished Connectors - Easy termination, simple tool kits - Polymer Ferrules - Choose the technology now and what other new opportunities will be lost? R = RJ-45 styling <<< two pictures >>> Optical Fiber Interconnection options TR41.8.1, November 17-29, 1997 Duplex Connector Geometry Impacts on Transceiver Component Packaging Standard Duplex TO-18 can geometries <<< diagram >>> Optical Fiber Interconnection option TR41.8.8 ... Open to All Technologies - The FJ can accept the D.I.R.E.C.T. design ... Proven Customer Acceptance, 12 months of sales - Motorola - Sprint - Abbott Labs - Indiana State University - Gateway 2000 - ... ... Why we Recommend the Fiber jack Interface - Designed for Fiber to the Wall - Meets all 1394b Selection Criteria - Accepts all Fiber Media - Open to all Technologies - - The Fiber Jack - The best Future Proof Selection - and - The best choice for IEEE 1304b 5.2 DIRECT Bob Scharf, Stewart Connector Systems Have agreements with others, and are throwing our support behind the Stewart Fiber Jack solution. We are not proposing anything different. 5.3 VF-45 VF-45 Duplex Fiber Optic Interconnect Proposal, IEEE P1394b Meeting, Ft. Lauderdale, FL, December 2 and 3, 1997. Juan Pulido, 3M Company VF-45 Low Cost Deplex Fiber Optic Connector - 1394b <<< four diagrams >>> VF-45 Low cost duplex Fiber Optic Connector - 1394b - meets 1394b driteria: - Low cost, simple installation, low loss (TIA compliant) - Suitable for home wiring with 20 year lifetime - Standards activity ongoing - low to zero maintenance - duplex, asummetric, differentiated keying - Supports speeds from 125 MBaud up to 4 GBaud - Suitable for equipment, dongles and wallplates - Supports standard multimode GLASS Optical Fiber - 50 micron and 62.5 micron - Small size (e.g. RJ-45 aperature compatible) - EYE SAFE - Current design does not support 1000 micron POF Assembly of VF-45 ... <<< diagram >>> Silica Clad Fiber in 3M VF-45 ... <<< diagram >>> ... What's important for home applications? - (PRICE) low cost, low cost, low cost - Safety - performance - Availability - VF-45 Design Meets this Criteria VF-45 Duplex Fiber Optic Connector - V-Groove Technology - Cost Reductions due to: - No Ferrules Used - No Field Adhesives and Corresponding accessories - No Couplings of adapters required - low cost tooling - Reduced labor installation - enables amateur installation - Injection molded design - transferable technologies Transceiver Package V-Groove Fiber Alignment - cost reduced E/O device into single package - improves density VF-45 Duplex Fiber Optic Connector - Safety - slide door on plug (integral) - Spring loaded dorr on socket and transceiver - recessed fibers on plug and socket - minimal bare fiber handling during installation - tooling design scores and captures bare fibers - transceiver meets class 1 laser safety VF-45 Duplex Fiber Optic Connector - Performance: - One cabling system for all applications - data/video/voice - No need to recable as electronics change - telecommuting (productivity with in the home) - Compliant with all mechanical and environmental conditions as specified by TIA 47500AB Detail Specification - Availability of Detail Specification - TIA PN 4122 to be TIA 47500AC - Intermatability standard TIA PN 3968, 604-7, FOCIS 7, Type SG - Compliance to 11801/568-A VF-45 Duplex Fiber Optic Connector - Availability: - Licensing per ANSI Requirements - Injection Molded Plastic Parts - Transferable Technologies - Affordable for Deployment at: - Home Depot - Radio Shack - ACE Hardware - Distributor Counters <<<< Coffee Break, 10:17, to resume discussion at 10:35. (10:39 real)>>>> 5.4 LC LC Connector The High density standard for premises networks Masood Shariff Lucent Technologies IEEE P1394b December 2, 1997 IEEE 1394b Criteria Outline - Availability of Detailed specifications - Patent Letter to ANSI/IEEE - Low system complexity - performance complies to TIA 568 - Size ... IEEE licensing letter draft ... TIA/ANSI letters ... LC Connector Availability of detailed specifications - Detailed specification available - FOCIS-10 LC Intermatability submitted to TIA 6.3.4 working group - LC product and data sheet eneral availability since 8/97 LC Connector Low Complexity Lower sytem somplexity is key - no cost shifting - no special fiber required - no special cable required LC Connector Low Complexity ONE connector for all segments: Commercial, Residential, Public Network and Equipment Interface LC Connector Low Complexity Simplified components - 80% less ferrule material than 2.5 mm ferrules - 55% less machining than 2.5 mm ferrules - alternate material ferrules under development - simple injection molded plastic housing and adapter - 60% less material in minicord LC Connector Low Complexity Simple field termination for both outlet and BTW - Polishing time reduced 80 % due to smaller tip area - Familiar process - reduced craft training, greater acceptance - Less opportunity for installtion failures and downtime LC Connector Size - 51% small than SC - Adapts to copper modular jack openings LC Connector Duplex with polarity - Duplex adapter labels meet TIA 568 polarity labeling requirements - behind the wall plugs reversible to easily correct for polarity problems LC not limited to hard duplex -- supports more applications: - Simplex needed for video surveillance - triplex required for RGB video LC Connector Improvement over SC <<< table >>> LC Connector Multimode Performance Unmatched performance - 0.1 dB avg. Insertion Loss - MM and SM Gigabit applications require low loss links. - loss budgets will shrink by up to 80% - 33 dB Return loss - MM Gigabit appliations can use improved performance LC Optical performance Multimode - Insertion Loss <<< diagram >>> LC Optical Performance Multimode - Return Loss <<< diagram >>> LC Environmental Performance Multimode <<< diagram >>> LC Mechanical Perfomrance Mating Durability <<< diagram >>> LC Connector Performance Data Performance comparison <<< table >>> LC Connector Ergonomics True RJ-45 Style - User friendly - familiar copper style thumb latch - intuitively obvious engagement - audible click assures full insertion - improved anti-snag latch - no tools required LC Connector Solution Dust Protection Effective Cleaning crucial to performance - easy to wipe endface - easy to clean coupling adapter - craft familiar with cleaning process - dust caps for adapters and connectors - no pins to collect debris - no exposed fibers to break during cleaning LC - Suitable as an equipment connector Transceivers in Development - Lucent Microelectronics - Working with others ... Unlabeled <<< image >>> LC Connector Evolution and Development ... LC Connector Summary ... IEEE licensing letter ... 5.5 Mini-MT The inning team with the winning technology AMP, HP, NTT, USconec, Siecor, Fujikura The issues ranked by IEEE 1394b 1. low complexity 2. Perfomrance 3. size 4. low loss 5. low maintenance 6. ... ... ??? ANSI/TIA/EAI TR41.8.1 Update - Mini-MT was the only proposed duplex fiber optic connector ... ... Low Complexity: What does this mean? - Ease of Installation - Reduced number of Precision Parts - Easy Integration ... ... Low Complexity: Ease of Field Installtion of MT-RJ - No-Polish - No epoxy Means: - reduced number of tools - no special tooling - Little training required - ease of transition - Little or no set-up required - reduced time/outfitting - ... ... Low Complexity Interface Reduction of complex parts: TIA ... ... Low Complexity Reduced number of complex parts Manufacturer: - one ferrule vs. two ferrules - no alignment ... ... Low complexity Easy integration into cabling system: - reduced length connector fits short outlet boxes - No excess ... ... Low complexity easy integration into system: Commercially available fiber cable -- to hub -- on board -- commerically available fiber cable <<< multiple images >>> Low complexity The universal outlet and patch panel Problem: - No standard cutout for 8 ... ... ... Mini-MT Technology Enables connector manufacturers ... Low Complexity Ease of Use by technicians and users. We listened to the customer - The modified mini-mpo The MT-RJ - Same field-proven ferrule and alignment mechanisms ... Size MT-RJ Plug/Jack - Drop in replacement ... ... <<< two diagrams >>> Overall Complexity of the system: ... Proven Field Record MT Production Vollue (000) <<< chart >>> Performance - Ferrule Technology - over 10 year proven reliability - Mechanical splice - over 15 year proven reliability - not open to the environment - ... MT-RJ Easy Feld-Termination Pre-polished, epoxyless Jack - can be terminated with gel-filled mechanical splice ... ... [jacks and tools shown via overhead (as "profiles")] [simple demonstration of the installation process] Performance: <<< table >>> Performance: <<< diagram >>> Performance: <<< chart >>> Patent/Licensing Statement ... Mini-MT Team Statement of Direction ... ... Intermateability specs. ... ... Polarity .... Ergonomics ... Equipment connector ... Outside plant use ... Mini-MT The Reason to Change - Designed as a True End-to-End system ... ... 6. Connector Selection There are 52 voters present. First round voting -- which do we eliminate first? fibrejack - 7 vf-45 - 17 lc - 11 mini-mt - 8 7. Transceiver parameters 8. Future Plans and Schedule 9. AOB 10. Adjourn ============================================================================= Attendance List Richard Churchill 281-514-6984 richard.churchill@compaq.com Masood Shariff 732-957-5479 mshariff@lucent.com Robert Campbell 732-957-2669 rrcampbell@lucent.com Phil Young +44 1908 837247 youngp@euk.nec.co.uk Dao-Long Chen 970-223-5100 x9461 dao-long.chen@symbios.com John Fuller 425-703-3863 jfuller@microsoft.com Farrukh Latif 610-712-7546 flatif@lucent.com Peng Zhang 972-480-3109 pzhang@ti.com John Smolka 972-480-1049 jsmolka@ti.com Dave Instone +44 1705 486363 dinstone@uk.xyratex.com Ju-Ching Tang 510-623-8300 x5189 jctang@corp.cirrus.com Reza Moattar 714-508-8731 reza.moattar@tsc.tdk.com John Ta 714-573-6957 john.ta@tus.ssil.com Paul Levy 602-752-6382 paul.levy@vlsi.com Eric Deliot +44 117 922 9539 ed@hplb.hpl.hp.com Alistair Coles +44 117 922 8750 anc@hplb.hpl.hp.com Keith W. Heilmann 914-892-2413 kheilman@us.ibm.com David K. Johnson 972-480-3632 dkjohnson@ti.com Vilas Bhade 408-777-4723 vilas@wipro.com Susumu Morikura +81 6 906 4896 morikura@isl.mei.co.jp Akihiro Miyachi +81 462 65 2327 morikura@molex.com Bill Pherigo 970-229-3586 wlp@fc.hp.com Martin Sodos 408-969-4683 msodos@issiusa.com Robert Liu 408-765-6549 robert_liu@ccm.intel.com Todd Hudson 704-327-5815 todd_hudson@siecor.com Norm Harris 408-957-2230 nharris@corp.adaptec.com Ken Hall 717-986-3841 khall@amp.com Charles Brill 717-592-6198 cebrill@amp.com Bob Atkinson 717-592-4274 rdatkins@amp.com Terry L. Bittner 908-704-3301 tlbittne@amp.com John Hill 717-592-6375 jhill@amp.com Oleg Awsienko 602-554-9666 oleg_awsienko@ccm.intel.com James T. Doyle 602-554-2051 jdoyle@sedona.intel.com Takatoshi Mizoguchi +81 7456 5 1161 mizoguti@shijo.sharp.co.jp Toru Ueda +81 74265 4529 ueda@slab.thr.sharp.co.jp Dick Scheel 408-982-5834 dicks@lsi.sel.sony.com Ken Taylor 508-347-3309 ktaylor@bostonoptical.com David Cook 512-984-3699 ddcook@mmm.com Juan Pulido 512-984-5188 jmpulido@mmm.com David Bean 607-974-4779 beandm@corning.com Bob Scharf 407-254-7315 rscharf@pcore.com Jack Merrow 425-486-2222 jmerrow@leviton-telcom.com Karl Bergstrom 800-888-0211 x4563 mpeg007@aol.com Ed Butler 602-554-0751 ebutler@ccm.intel.com Sushant Verman 416-620-7400 sushant@lsil.com Barry Colella 978-635-6380 bcolella@neccsd.com Won Yoon 610-712-2503 wjy@aluxpo.lucent.com Max Bassler 630-527-4490 mbassler@molex.com Eric Hannah 408-765-4441 ehannah@mipos2.sc.intel.com Del Hanson 408-435-6246 del_hanson@hp.com Farrokh Mottahedin 408-324-7934 fmottahe@qntm.com James Piccione 408-895-5136 james.piccione@smi.siemens.com Prashant Kanhere 510-668-1773 prashant@macrodesigns.com Ozay Octay 714-856-7180 ozay_oktay@cissc.canon.com Firooz Farhoomand 408-653-4059 firoozf@ix.netcom.com Yoshiro Nieda +81 3 3245 8750 nieda@pluto.dti.ne.jp Kenji Watanabe +81 3 5448 5362 nabeken@sslab.sony.co.jp Steve Bard 503-264-2923 steve_bard@mail.intel.com Ron Soderstrom 507-253-6290 rons@vnet.ibm.com Shuntaro Yamazaki +81 44 856 2082 yamazaki@ccm.cl.nec.co.jp Tomoki Saito +81 44 856 2082 saito@ccm.cl.nec.co.jp Takayuki Nyu +81 44 856 2082 new@ccm.cl.nec.co.jp Tatsuo Inoue +81 3 5545 7813 inoue@ba2.so-nel.or.jp Kazuki Nakamura +81 8275 2 4151 kazuki-n@mars.dtinet.or.jp Colin Whitby-Strevens +44 1454 611500 colinws@bristol.st.com David Wooten 281-514-7231 david.wooten@compaq.com Stephen Finch 714-573-6808 steve.finch@tus.ssi1.com Dave Gampell 408-435-6680 dave_gampell@hp.com Marcus Kellerman 714-932-5000 marcus.c.kellerman@wdc.com Bill Prouty 916-785-4631 bprouty@hp.com Al Kelley 904-829-5600 akelley@tensolite.com Palanisamy Mohanraj 602-554-4243 palanisamy_mohanraj@ccm.intel.com Jerry Hauck 408-765-5528 jerry_hauck@ccm.intel.com Michael Borgman 708-532-1800 mjbo@panduit.com Don Wiencek 708-532-1800 dcw@panduit.com Jack Hollins 408-957-2309 jack_hollins@eng.adaptec.com Tatsuya Arai 805-522-7958 tatsuyaa@hiroseusa.com Francesco Liburdi 607-748-0025 liburdif@hollingsworth.com Dan Colegrove 408-765-1978 colegrove@us.ibm.com Dave LaFollette 408-765-2587 dlafolle@mipos2.sc.intel.com Oleg Awsienko 602-554-9666 oleg_awsienko@ccm.ch.intel.com Toru Ueda +81 743 65 4529 ueda@slab.thr.sharp.co.jp Takatoshi Mizoguchi +81 745 65 1161 mizoguti@shinjo.sharp.co.jp