From: owner-stds-1450-4@majordomo.ieee.org on behalf of Don Organ [don.organ@inovys.com]
Sent: Friday, May 17, 2002 11:10 AM
To: STIL. 4
Subject: stds-1450.4: STIL.4 teleconference meeting minutes 5/17/2002
Daniel Fan
Jim O'Reilly
Dave Dowding
Don Organ
Ernie Wahl
Tom Micek
Jose Santiago
 
 
Agenda
-----------
Action Items from previous meeting
Don's Flow Control Object Model
 
 
Action Items
------------------
Flow Control Object Model
--------------------------------------
We are ready to start making decisions? Yes!
 
1. Are we agreed on the general concept of a FSM/FlowChart/declarative approach?
Yes. We'll defer specifics for the future.
 
2. Are we agreed on supporting hierarchy? (SubFlows)
Yes. Ernie prefers to call them TestFlows. Jose - is the nesting limited? No - but from a partical point, implementations may have limits. Jim - subflows can be used for grouping, and also for parallel flows at the same level in the hierarchy. Jose/Jim/Ernie - subflows could be used for different cores.
 
3. What are the basic boxes in the Flow? Something for a TestMethod call, the SubFlow, some decision/branch/loop point, a bin. Are these extensible (such as to include the Plot in the 3/8/99 document)?
FlowNode=Vertex (in graph theory). Also, consider adding a non-branch action (such as closing the relay on a loadboard). We had some discussion as to what this point means (is the FlowNode a test? or a pointer to a test? we tried to defer this issue). Ernie thinks the binning might be an attribute of a test (or of a flow) - would like to ensure that removing a test that is associated with a bin to also remove that bin. Ernie thinks of the test and the test method as one thing (with pre-action, body, and post-action) - so he sees binning as an exit action. Ernie's emphasis is to encourage a maintainable program structure.
We didn't close on this issue. We seem to have good agreement on all aspects other than the binning, and we might be close on the binning as well. We'll pick up here next time.
 
 
 
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Don Organ                      Inovys Corporation
(925) 924-9110 x122
-----------------------------------------------------------------