IEEE P1532 Meeting - May 1-2, 2000 - Xilinx

Back to Minutes page
Back to IEEE P1532 home page


Attendees

The following individuals attended the meeting:

   Neil Jacobson - Xilinx
   Ken Parker - Agilent
   Dennis Lia - GenRad
   Howard Tang - Lattice
   Dave Bonnett - Asset Intertech
   Ray Dellecker - JTAG
   Brad Ishihara - Altera
   Al Hermann - Altera
   Mark Moyer - Lattice

Minutes

   Meeting: IEEE P1532
   Date:  5 / 1 & 2 / 2000
   Location: Altera -  San Jose
   Purpose: P1532 Draft wrap-up: BSDL extension, Flow and Data Format

Agenda:

  1. Quick Review of Re-Ballot Draft and Process
  2. Continued Discussion of BSDL Extension, Flow and Data Format

Minutes:

Date: 5-1-00 Monday
Time: 9:00 AM

Discussion: Amend the Minutes of the last meeting:

Motion: Approve last meeting minutes as amended.
Motion: Alan
Second: Ken
Vote: 8-0-0

Discussion: Review of Re-Ballot Draft and Process

Discussion: Comments on Draft 1.9

Motion: Proceed to re-circulation with draft 1.9 as amended by comments from working group email comments and meeting oral comments

Motion: Mark
Second: Brad
Vote: 8-0-0

Action: Find a way with IEEE to get by with no change bars.
Who: Neil

Discussion: CRC Summary of comments to date.

Time: 10:30 AM
Break:

Time: 10:45 AM

Motion: The 1532 data format will support only the CRC method, and not the classical outdated JEDEC 3C data checksum.

Motion: Dennis
Second: Ken
Vote: 7-0-1

Discussion: P1532 printed 2/15/2000 4:42 PM Unapproved Draft 2.1 - Data and Flow: Pages 93 to 105 of 133

Time: 12:00 PM
Lunch: The working group thanks Altera for its' hospitality for hosting the meeting and providing lunches.

Time: 1:00 PM

Discussion: P1532 printed 2/15/2000 4:42 PM Unapproved Draft 2.1(continued) - Data and Flow: Pages 106 to 119 of 133

Motion: Delete Figure 27 and remove CRCI. Use one CRC key word referring to capture operations only.

Motion: Brad
Second: Mark
Vote: 5-1-1

Motion: Define an "action CRC" that is the result of the XOR of the each of the "flow CRCs". Recommend that flow CRCs not be put in optional or recommended flows. Recommend that action CRCs be included in Read and Verify actions.

Motion: Alan
Second: Brad
Vote: 7-1-0

Time: 2:15
Break

Time: 2:30

Discussion: P1532 printed 2/15/2000 4:42 PM Unapproved Draft 2.1(continued) - Data and Flow: Pages 106 to 119 of 133(continued):

Time: 5:00 PM
Break for Day

Time: 6:00 PM to 9:00 PM
Dinner:
The working group would like to thank Altera for dinner.

Date: 5-2-2000
Time: 9:00 AM

Discussion:
Split into 2 Subgroups:

Actions:
Issues to address:

  1. Should we change the flow structure to allow multiple repeat loop sections?
  2. How to reference an attribute value defined in the BSDL in the flow. For example: IDCODE?
  3. How to get data from the external data source?

Discussion:

Time: 12:30 PM
Lunch Break

Time: 1:30 PM

Created an example data file for the XC9356.
Discussion:

Action:
Vendors to create vendor specific BSDL files and sent to Neil for posting on the reflect.

Open issues:

Time: 3:30 PM
Adjourn meeting

Next Meetings:
June 26-27 Agilent, Loveland CO - 2nd Ballot Resolution
August 17-18 GenRad, Westford MA

Secretary: Dennis Lia


Back to Minutes page
Back to IEEE P1532 home page