[P1619-2] Draft Minutes
Agenda:
1. Introductions, roll call
Jim Hughes, Sun
Matt Ball, Independent
Landon Curt Noll, Cisco
Fabio Maino, Cisco
Hal Finney, PGP
Shai Halevi, IBM
Eric Hibbard, HDS
2. Approval of the agenda
3. IEEE patent slideset
<http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.pdf>
4. Approval of previous minutes
https://siswg.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=115
Motion to approve, Fabio, 2nd Jim, Motion passed.
5. Review of past action items
AI 24 - (Hal Finney, David McGrew): cross check test vectors for XCB
and EME-2 with independent implementation. – In progress. "Soon".
Fabio to follow up with Gladman and VoltageInc. Carry over.
AI 26 (Fabio): migrate content of 1619.2 old site to new site (table)
– (Need to migrate Comparison Table over to SISWG.NET) – Done
AI 28 Hal Finney – Give EME2 implementation to Charlie Martin to post
on Source Forge. Add Matt. Carry over.
https://sourceforge.net/projects/crypto1619/
AI 29 David McGrew – Give XCB implementation to Charlie Martin to post
on Source Forge. Carry over.
AI 30 David and Fabio: Implement changes recommended by Hal Finney and
group to the XCB proposal. Done.
AI 31 Fabio: Publish P1619.2/D1. Done.
6. Technical Discussion
EME2
AI 32 Shai: Provide text and update diagram.
AI 33 Matt: Report back on Copyright discussions.
XCB
AI 34 Fabio: Update text for next meeting. (by end of April)
Discussion about GF2^n bit / byte / word ordering. From email
http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/1619/email/msg01515.html
XTS is his method 3. Hal: proposal is method 3 for EME2 and method 1
for XCB. Colin's email is at
http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/1619/email/msg01433.html
AI 35 Fabio: Provide a method recommendation for XCB.
Agreed that section 7 be removed, and the description of the input key
be described as a series of bytes in each of the EME2 and XCB sections.
Other modes?
None at this time. We will drop this section in the future. The
consensus is that these 2 modes are adequate.
Draft Review
AI 36 Hal: Recommend changed words to section 6.2.
Draft of 1619.2 will be consistent with P1619 in both text and
references. .2 will reference 1619.
Review complete. New draft of both EME2 and XCB will be available next
meeting.
7. Review of new action items
Completed.
8. Schedule next meeting
Tuesday May 6, 11am 3 hours at Cisco in San Jose. Lunch will be
provided. Webex and call in also.
Motion to adjourn Landon, Eric. Passed.