Re: [P1619-3] OASIS KMIP Links

[Scott Kipp <skipp@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

Matt,

 

Thanks for coordinating this. 

 

Can Bob post the comparison document to 1619.3?  Then 1619.3 can approve this document (with any changes) and we can submit the next draft to OASIS KMIP.  1619.3 should be able to modify 1619.3 documents as we see fit regardless of OASIS membership.

 

I hope this is correct,

Scott 

---

From: Matt Ball [mailto:Matthew.Ball@xxxxxxx]
Sent: Tuesday, May 26, 2009 4:19 PM
To: P1619-3@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: Re: [P1619-3] OASIS KMIP Links

Hi Folks,

The OASIS KMIP technical committee has requested feedback on the P1619.3 comparison that Bob Lockhart produced (see links below).

If we have time in tomorrow's meeting, I'm hoping that we can incorporate some of this feedback into the spreadsheet.  As the P1619.3 liaison into KMIP, I can present this feedback to KMIP.

However, if you contribute feedback to this document, you need to either:

1. be a member of OASIS KMIP already, or
2. agree to and sign the OASIS Feedback License (see http://www.oasis-open.org/who/intellectualproperty.php#appendixa)

OASIS KMIP operates under the "RF on RAND Terms" (see 10.2.2 of the OASIS IP rules: http://www.oasis-open.org/who/intellectualproperty.php#licensing_req), so you have to agree to these terms before presenting information to the OASIS KMIP TC.

Thanks!
-Matt

Hubis, Walt wrote:

Here are the links to the OASIS KMIP documents that describe the differences between the P1619.3 architecture and the KMIP architecture. Please review these in preparation for the decision to use the KMIP protocol for the P1619.3 binary transport.

KMIP to P1619.3 Mappings: This spreadsheet shows potential mapping between KMIP version 0.98 and P1619.3 Draft 6 specifications. This is in Microsoft Excel format. (If you can not read this format, please let me know and I will provide an Acrobat document.)

http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/download.php/32337/KMIP-Mapping_to_P1619_3-v001.xls

KMIP mapping to P1619.3 overview and initial findings: This is a presentation on the KMIP-P1619.3 mapping effort. 

http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/download.php/32339/P1619.3andKMIPmappings.pdf

Regards,
Walt Hubis

--

Walt Hubis
Software Architect
Engenio Storage Group

LSI Corporation
5400 Airport Blvd Ste 100
Boulder, CO 80301 USA
Phone: (303) 381-4332
Mobile: (303) 641-8528
walt.hubis@xxxxxxx
http://www.lsi.com