Re: [STDS-P1619] P1619.2 BALLOT
PGP Corporation
Hal Finney
No
I don't think the document is quite ready - second the comments made
by Matt Ball in his email of August 22:
http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/1619/email-2/msg00102.html
On Thu, Aug 7, 2008 at 12:19 AM, Fabio Maino <fmaino@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> IEEE P1619.2 E-MOTION 2008-01: Approve P1619.2/D7 to advance to IEEE Sponsor
> Ballot.
> Votes MUST be sent by email to the group secretary: Fabio Maino [ fmaino at
> cisco.com].
> Also, please CC the mailing list stds-p1619 at IEEE.ORG as well.
>
> Please format your e-mail vote as follows:
>
> <COMPANY NAME>
> <Name of voting WG member>
> <Vote: Yes/No/Abstain>
> <COMMENTS>
>
> To simplify processing, the subject of the mail should be "P1619.2 BALLOT".
> Comments may be received in any format, such as adobe comment file (.fdf) or
> as comments in an excel spreadsheet (attached). Adobe comment file is the
> preferred format.
>
> E-MOTION 2008-01: Approve P1619.2/D7 to advance to IEEE Sponsor Ballot
>
> The IEEE Security in Storage Working Group authorizes the IEEE P1619.2
> editor to submit draft D7 with approved changes for sponsor ballot. This
> motion allows for editorial changes and minor corrections to be made to the
> draft before ballot without a re-vote in the working group. If after
> approval of this motion, major changes to P1619.2 are deemed necessary by
> the working group, this vote shall be voided and a new vote shall be
> required for the working group to submit the draft standard to sponsor
> ballot.
>
> Timeline:
>
> E-Voting opens: August 7th, 2008, 5 pm PDT
> E-Voting closes: September 6th, 2008, 5 pm PDT
>
> Eligible E-voters:
>
> Brocade
> Cisco
> Dell
> Emulex
> Hitachi Data Systems
> Hitachi GST
> Hifn
> HP
> IBM
> Lexar Media
> LSI Logic
> Microsoft
> nCipher
> NetApp
> Optica
> PGP Corporation
> PMC Sierra
> Quantum Corp.
> RSA Security/EMC
> SafeNet
> Seagate
> SrongAuth
> Sun Microsystems
> Symantec
> Voltage Security
> Vormetric
> Wave Systems
> WinMagic
>
>
> The voting is "per company", as it has been always the case in the P1619.2
> workgroup.
>
> Tabulation of votes:
>
> For the motion to pass, we must have:
> - at least 14 votes (a quorum of members of the group)
> - more than 1/2 of all votes cast must be YES.
>
> The following paragraph is a quote from the "Operating Procedures for P1619"
> document:
>
> When conducting a Working Group ballot on a draft document, each voting
> Working Group member shall vote one of the following positions:
>
> Affirmative (with or without comments)
> Do Not Approve
> (Negative With Comments - the reasons for a negative vote shall be given and
> shall include specific wording or actions that, if implemented, would
> resolve the objection)
> Abstain
>
> Please use adobe comment files (.fdf, preferred format) or the attached
> spreadsheet when preparing comments.
>
> P1619.2/D7 is available at:
> https://siswg.net/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=134&Itemid=41
>
>
> --
> Thanks!
>
> Fabio Maino
> Cisco Systems
> 425 East Tasman Drive
> San Jose, CA 95134
> Work: 4088537530
>
>