IEEE P802.11 - TASK GROUP AI - MEETING UPDATE


Status of Project IEEE 802.11ai

 

Fast Initial Link Set-up

 

Task Group Chair: Hiroshi Mano (Allied Telesis R&D Center)

Task Group Vice Chair: Marc Emmelmann (Fraunhofer FOKUS)

Task Group Secretary: Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center)

Task Group Editor: Tom Siep (CSR)

 


Task Group Documents

TGai PAR & 5C

TGai Guideline for Submissions to TGai Template Slides

Use Case Reference List for TGai

TGai Requirements Document

Process for Creating TGai Draft

Use Case Document Definitions

TGai Evaluation Methodology

 


January 2012, Jacksonville, Florida

Achievements

·         Approve meeting minutes

Atlanta face-to-face meeting 11/1587r1

Teleconferences 11/1600r7

 

·         Submissions

·         12/0025r1: TGai Spec Development Discussion (Rolf de Vegt, Qualcomm)

·         11/1414r4: Real Air-time Occupation by Beacon and Probe (Katsuo Yunoki, KDDI R&D Laboratories)

·         12/0034r1: Performance Evaluation (Hitoshi Morioka, Allied Telesis R&D Center)

·         12/0032r1: Higher Layer Setup Proposal (Hitoshi Morioka, Allied Telesis R&D Center)

·         Text: 12/0033r1

·         12/0010r1: Proposal for Accelerated Link Setup Procedure (Lei Wang, InterDigital)

·         12/0027r1: IP configuration for fast initial link setup (Yongho Seok, LG)

·         12/0059r1: Selection of the AP for Scanning (Jae Seung Lee, ETRI)

·         Text: 12/0060r0

·         12/0061r1: Probe Response frame transmission interval (Jae Seung Lee, ETRI)

·         Text: 12/0062r1

·         12/0063r1: Selective Transmission of the Probe Response (Jae Seung Lee, ETRI)

·         Text: 12/0064r0

·         12/0036r1: Network Discover Consideration (Jing Rong Hsieh, HTC)

·         11/1628r1: Cooperative AP Discovery (ChauChun Wang, MediaTek)

·         12/0011r0: Coarse BSS Metric IE (Katsuo Yunoki, KDDI R&D Laboratories)

·         12/0013r0: Proposal of Fast AP Discovery (Katsuo Yunoki, KDDI R&D Laboratories)

·         11/1169r1: FILS Association (Jae-Hyung Song, LG)

·         Text: 12/0070r1

·         11/1523r4: Access Delay Reduction for FILS: Network Discovery & Access congestion Improvements (Santosh Abraham, Qualcomm)

·         12/0046r0: GAS Broadcast Request (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         12/0056r0: Scanning with FILS (Jarkko Kneckt, Nokia)

·         Text: 11/1619r1

·         12/0053r0: GAS Version Control including Normative Text (Phillip Barber, Huawei)

·         12/0080r0: AP Admission Control in TGai (Phillip Barber, Huawei)

·         11/1521r2: AP and Network Discovery Enhancements (Marc Emmelmann, Fraunhofer FOKUS)

·         12/0042r0: AP Discovery with FILS Beacon (Yunbo Li, Huawei)

·         11/1408r9: Some Notes and Thoughts on TGai Security Properties (Rene Struik, Struik Security Consultancy)

·         12/0052r2: Certificate-Based Authentication Protocol for IEEE802.11 TGai (Rene Struik, Struik Security Consultancy)

·         11/1429r2: A Protocol for FILS Authentication (Dan Harkins, Aruba Networks)

·         Text: 11/1488r1

·         12/0041r1: Performance Analysis of 802.11 authentication and authorization (Robert Sun, Huawei)

·         12/0039r3: TGai FILS Authentication Protocol (Robert Sun, Huawei)

·         11/1160r5: Fast Authentication in TGai (George Cherian, Qualcomm)

·         Text: 12/0123r0

·         12/0147r0: 802.11ai Spec Development Process Update Proposal (Rolf de Vegt, Qualcomm)

·         12/0151r0: Specification Framework for TGai (Tom Siep, CSR)

·         12/0151r1: Specification Framework for TGai (Tom Siep, CSR)

·         12/0155r0: TGai Spec Framework Updating Process Modification Proposal (Hitoshi Morioka, Allied Telesis R&D Center)

·         12/0156r0: Motherhood and Apple Pie (Dan Harkins, Aruba Networks)

·         11/1628r4: Cooperative AP Discovery (ChaoChun Wang, MediaTek)

·         12/0153r2: Active Scanning related requirements for Specification Frame Work Document (Jarkko, Kneckt, Nokia)

·         11/1160r6: Fast Authentication in TGai (George Cherian, Qualcomm)

·         12/0046r1: GAS Broadcast Request (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         12/0157r1: Security Inputs to IEEE802.11 TGai (Rene Struik, Struik Security Consultancy)

·         12/0158r1: Proposed Additions to SFD (Phillip Barber, Huawei)

·         12/0153r4: Active Scanning related requirements for Specification Frame Work Document (Jarkko, Kneckt, Nokia)

·         12/0162r0: Change in Scanning Procedure (Marc Emmelmann, Fraunhofer FOKUS)

 

Motions

·         Move to modify the agenda of Wednesday PM2, and to add the topic of changing procedure of TGai creating draft as the first of business.

·         Result (Y/N/A): 22/12/1       Pass

·         The group agrees to adopt the process as outlined on slide 15 of 11-12/0147r0. The agenda is modified so that work can begin on the spec framework immediately following this motion

·         Result (Y/N/A): 28/5/3         Pass

·         Motion move to accept the empty spec framework documentation 11-12/0151r2 as the initial TGai spec framework documentation rev.0.

·         Result (Y/N/A): 25/0/7         Pass

·         The group agrees to adopt the process as outlined on slide 3 of 11-12/0155r1.

·         Result (Y/N/A): 23/0/9         Pass

·         Motion move to modify the agenda of Thursday  AM2, and to remove the  topic “Vote to motion of submissions for the framework“.

·         Result (Y/N/A): 18/2/4         Pass

·         Approve the following schedule of weekly teleconferences.
Tuesdays 17:00 ET continue from 31 Jan to 6th Mar.

Duration 1 hour
Using Web-Ex that will be provided by Task Group Chair

·         Unanimously Approved

 

Teleconferences

·         Weekly teleconferences on Tuesdays 17:00 ET (NY Time) continue from 31st Jan.
Duration 1 hour

 

March 2012 goals

            Spec text for specification framework documentation

 


November 2011, Atlanta, Georgia

Achievements

·         Approve meeting minutes

Okinawa face-to-face meeting 11/1350r1

Teleconferences 11/1389r2

 

·         Submissions

·         11/1413r1: Real Air-time Occupation by Beacon and Probe (Katsuo Yunoki, KDDI R&D Laboratory)

·         11/1414r2: Probe Request and Response in TGai (Katsuo Yunoki, KDDI R&D Laboratory)

·         11/1415r0: AP Status Broadcast (Katsuo Yunoki, KDDI R&D Laboratory)

·         11/1436r1: Security Requirements for TGai (Robert Sun, Huawei)

·         11/1429r0: A Protocol for FILS authentication (Dan Harkins, Aruba Networks)

·         11/1160r3: Fast Authentication in TGai (George Cherian, Qualcomm)

·         11/1426r0: Fast Security Setup (Dezhi Zhang, ZTE)

·         11/1047r5: Using Upper Layer IE in TGai (Ping Fang, Huawei)

·         11/977r6: TGai Upper Layer Setup Proposal (Hitoshi Morioka, Allied Telesis R&D Center)

·         11/1548r0: TGai Discovery Proposal (Paul Lambert, Marvell)

·         11/1525r2: IP Address Assignment Indication (George Cherian, Qualcomm)

·         11/1565r0: AP Status Broadcast (Katsuo Yunoki, KDDI R&D Laboratory)

·         11/1523r2: Access Enhancements for FILS: Network Discovery & Access Congestion Improvements (Santosh Abraham, Qualcomm)

·         11/1498r1: GAS Version Control in 11ai (Phillip Barber, Huawei)

·         11/1499r0: GAS Query Optimization in TGai (Phillip Barber, Huawei)

·         11/1500r0: Broadcast Probe Response (Phillip Barber, Huawei)

·         11/1559r0: Scanning Goals and Challenges (Jarkko Kneckt, Nokia)

·         11/1521r0: AP and Network Discovery Enhancements (Marc Emmelmann, Fraunhofer FOKUS)

·         11/1572r0: Security Properties Straw Polls (Dan Harkins, Aruba Networks)

·         11/1576r0: Scanning Enhancements for FILS – Normative Text (Marc Emmelmann, Fraunhofer FOKUS)

·         11/1014r2: IP address configuration during association (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         11/1575r0: Editors recommendation for submission (Tom Siep, CSR)

 

Motions

·         Move to adopt 11-1576r2  and instruct editor to create draft 0.1 incorporates  the contribution to the TGai draft.

·         Result (Y/N/A): 4/7/8           Fail

·         Move to approve the following schedule of weekly teleconferences
Mondays 23:59 EST (NY Time) continue from 21st Nov.

Duration 1 hour
Using Web-Ex that will be provided by Task Group Chair

·         8/2/4                                      Pass

 

Teleconferences

·         Weekly teleconferences on Mondays 23:59 EST (NY Time) continue from 21st Nov.
Duration 1 hour

 

January 2012 goals

            Close call for submission

            Drafting draft 0.1

 


September 2011, Okinawa, Japan

Achievements

·         Approve meeting minutes

San Francisco face-to-face meeting 11/1097r0

Teleconferences 11/1110r6

 

·         Submissions

·         11/977r2: TGai Upper Layer Setup Proposal (Hitoshi Morioka, ROOT)

·         11/1167r0: Upper Layer Data IE (Hiroki Nakano, Trans New Technology)

·         11/1108r1: Providing IP address config param to the STA during auth (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         11/1264r0: IP address configuration BCP (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         11/1047r3: Using Upper Layer Message IE in TGai (Ping Fang, Huawei)

·         11/1015r2: Optimized Network Selection (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         11/1232r3: Active Scanning Improvements (Marc Emmelmann, Fraunhofer FOKUS)

·         11/1233r3: Passive Scanning Improvements (Marc Emmelmann, Fraunhofer FOKUS)

·         11/1183r0: IP over Congested WLAN (Masataka Ohta, Tokyo Institute of Technology)

·         11/1169r0: FILS association (Jihyun Lee, LG)

·         11/1160r3: Fast Authentication in TGai (Hemanth Sampath, Qualcomm)

·         11/1278r0: Editor’s Report (Tom Siep, CSR)

·         11/1014r2: IP address configuration during association (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         11/1306r0: Security Discussion (Robert Moskowitz, Verizon Business)

·         11/1326r1: Early Key Generation by ECDH and PKC (Hiroki Nakano, Trans New Technology)

·         11/1109r0: Amendment Creation Process (Tom Siep, CSR)

 

Motions

·         Move the TGai chair to request a joint session with IEEE802.11 REG SC in November to discuss regulatory issues involved in enabling active scanning in DFS bands in 5GHz.

·         Result (Y/N/A): 12/0/10       Pass

·         Move to approve document 11-11/1014r2 and request to editor to incorporate to TGai draft 0.1.

·         Result (Y/N/A): 7/3/2           Fail

·         Move to approve the following schedule of weekly teleconferences
Tuesdays 10:00 EDT (NY Time) continue from 4th Oct.

Duration 1 hour
Using Web-Ex that will be provided by Task Group Chair

·         10/0/4                                    Pass

 

Teleconferences

·         Weekly teleconferences on Tuesdays 10:00 EDT (NY Time) continue from 4th Oct.
Duration 1 hour

 

November 2011 goals

            Approve minutes of Okinawa session and teleconferences.

Submission of technical contributions

            General submissions

            Review timeline

            Plan for January

 

 


July 2011, San Francisco, California

Achievements

·         Approve meeting minutes

Palm Springs face-to-face meeting 11/832r0

Teleconferences 11/837r7

 

·         Submissions

·         11/811r7: TGai Evaluation Methodology (Marc Emmelmann, Fraunhofer FOKUS)

·         11/976r3: TGai Authentication Protocol Proposal (Hitoshi Morioka, ROOT)

·         11/977r1: TGai Upper Layer Setup Proposal (Hitoshi Morioka, ROOT)

·         11/1015r1: Optimized Network Selection (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         11/1012r0: IP config during association (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         11/1014r0: IP config during association (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         11/1000r1: TGai FILS Proposal (Jihyun Lee, LG)

·         11/1003r2: Upper Layer Data on Management Frames (Hiroki Nakano, Trans New Technology)

·         11/1047r1: Using Upper Layer Message IE in TGai (Ping Fang, Huawei)

·         11/1031r0: Air-time Consumption by Beacon and Probe (Hitoshi Morioka, ROOT)

·         11/1056r0: IETF relation works (Tom Siep, CSR)

·         11/1066r2: Fast Security Setup (Robert Moskowitz, Verizon Business)

·         11/1040r0: Editor’s Report (Tom Siep, CSR)

 

Motions

·         Approve TGai evaluation methodology (11/811r7).

·         15/0/0                        Pass

·         Move to approve the following schedule of weekly teleconferences
Tuesdays 10:00 EDT (NY Time) continue from 2nd Aug.

Duration 1 hour
Using Web-Ex that will be provided by Task Group Chair

·         16/0/6                        Pass

 

Teleconferences

·         Weekly teleconferences on Tuesdays 10:00 EDT (NY Time) continue from 2nd Aug.
Duration 1 hour

 

September 2011 goals

            Submission of technical contributions

            General submissions

 

 


May 2011, Palm Springs, California

Achievements

·         Approve meeting minutes

Singapore face-to-face meeting 11/477r0

Teleconferences 11/490r5

 

·         Submissions

·         11/619r0: Use Case: Network Mobility (Jihyun Lee, LG)

·         11/238r19: Use Case Reference List for TGai (Tom Siep, CSR)

·         11/746r0: Discussion – How Many APs to Cover (Dwight Smith, Motorola Mobility)

·         11/739r0: HIP DEX for Fast Initial Authentication in 802.11 (Robert Moskowitz, Verizon Business)

·         11/756r0: IP address assignment in FIA (Robert Moskowitz, Verizon Business)

·         11/745r5: TGai Functional Requirements (Marc Emmelmann, fraunhofer FOKUS)

·         11/748r3: Process for Creating TGai Draft (Tom Siep, CSR)

·         11/797r0: Use Case: Mobile Hotspot (Jihyun Lee, LG)

 

Motions

·         Approve TGai use case reference list 11-11/0238r18.

·         12/0/4                        Pass

·         Approve to add “mobile hotspot” to TGai use case reference list (11-11/0238r18).

·         15/0/5                        Pass

·         Approve TGai functional requirement document 11-11/0745r5.

·         10/0/1                        Pass

·         Approve process for creating TGai draft 11-11/0748r3.

·         6/1/2              Pass

·         Move to approve the following schedule of weekly teleconferences
Tuesdays 09:00 EDT (NY Time) continue from 17th May.

Duration 1 hour
Using Web-Ex that will be provided by Task Group Chair

·         7/0/0              Pass

 

Teleconferences

·         Weekly teleconferences on Tuesdays 09:00 EDT (NY Time) continue from 17th May.
Duration 1 hour

 

July 2011 goals

            Submission of initial technical contributions

            Discuss and approve evaluation methodology

            General submissions

 

 


March 2011, Singapore, Singapore

Achievements

·         Approve meeting minutes

Los Angeles face-to-face meeting 11/115r1

Teleconferences 11/213r6

 

·         Submissions

·         11/357r0: A focused path forwards TGai D1.0 (Marc Emmelmann, FOKUS)

·         11/334r0: TGai Scope Discussion (Akira Yamada, NTT DOCOMO)

·         11/326r0: Use_Case_Ref_List_Doc Discussion (Tom Siep, CSR)

·         11/148r6: Use Cases for TGai (Lee Armstrong, US DoT)

·         11/281r0: Proposed Dynamic Mobility Use Cases for TGai (Carl Kain, Noblis)

·         11/333r1: TGai Possible Use Cases (Akira Yamada, NTT DOCOMO)

·         11/337r0: Discussion points on portal locations (Dwight Smith, Motorola Mobility)

·         11/356r0: Selection Procedure for TGai (Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric)

·         11/343r0: Pedestrian Model (Hitoshi Morioka, ROOT)

·         11/435r1: Definitions and Terminology from 802.11.2 (Marc Emmelmann, FOKUS)

·         11/408r1: Use Case Characteristics Discussion (Tom Siep, CSR)

·         11/441r0: Self-Growing Use Cases requiring Fase Initial Link Setup (Marc Emmelmann, FOKUS)

·         11/238r5: Use Case Reference List for TGai (Tom Siep, CSR)

 

Motions

·         Approve the term and definitions in 11-11/0408r2 as official TGai terminology.

·         14/0/1                        Pass

·         Approve the values of high/medium/low given for each definition as in the 11-11/0408r2.

·         10/0/3                        Pass

·         Move to approve the following schedule of weekly teleconferences
Tuesdays 08:00 EST (NY Time) continue until 29th Mar.

Tuesdays 09:00 EST (NY Time) start from 5th Apr.

Duration 1 hour
Using Web-Ex that will be provided by Task Group Chair

·         14/0/3                        Pass

 

Teleconferences

·         Weekly teleconferences on Tuesdays 08:00 EST (NY Time) continue until 29th Mar.
and on Tuesdays 09:00 EST (NY Time) start from 5th Apr.
Duration 1 hour

 

May 2011 goals

            Finish use case scenario, functional requirements and technical requirements

 

 


January 2011, Los Angeles, California

Achievements

·         Approve meeting minutes as FIA SG.

Dallas face-to-face meeting 10/1312r0

All telephone conferences were canceled or did not take place due to lack of participation. No minutes were taken.

 

·         Officer elections

Chair:                    Hiroshi Mano (ROOT INC.)

Vice Chair:            Marc Emmelmann (Fraunhofer FOKUS)

Secretary:              Hitoshi Morioka (ROOT INC.)

Editor:                   Tom Siep (CSR)

 

·         Submissions

·         11/119r0: Requirements for FILS Submissions coming from PAR & 5C (M. Emmelmann)

·         TGai Operation Manual (11-11/139r0  & 11/11-140r0)

·         10/1106r01: PAR & 5C Transition from FIA to Fast Initial Link Set-Up (M. Emmelmann)

·         11/0122r0:  3G <--> WLAN handover (Gabor Bajko, Nokia)

·         11/0023r1: Use Case Scenario for TGai (H. Morioka, ROOT Inc)

·         11/0148r0: Use Cases Requiring Fast Initialization (Lee Armstrong, US DoT)

·         11/0191r0 Use Case Discussion (Tom Siep, CSR)

·         11/0148r1: Use Cases Requiring Fast Initialization (Lee Armstrong, US DoT)

 

Motions

·         Move to create new operation manual documentation for TGai and incorporate table on slide 6 in the document.

·         12/0/4            Pass

·         Move to accept TGai operation manual in the document 11-11/139r1 and 11-11/140r0.

·         8/0/2              Pass

·         Move to approve 11/11-0191r0 and instruct the editor to add use case template to 11/11-0139

·         11/0/3            Pass

·         Move to create a TGai Use Cases Document and derive from agreed use cases a TGai Functional Requirement Document and a TGai document containing evaluation criteria.

·         11/0/0            Pass

·         Move to approve the following schedule of weekly teleconferences on
Tuesdays 08:00 EST (NY Time)
Duration 1 hour
Using Web-Ex that will be provided by TG Chair

·         9/0/3              Pass

 

Teleconferences

·         Weekly teleconferences on Tuesdays 08:00 EST (NY Time)
Duration 1 hour

 

March 2011 goals

            Finish Use Cases Document and Functional Requirements

 

 


FIA SG - MEETING UPDATE


Status of FIA Study Group

Fast Initial Authentication

Hiroshi Mano, Chair

Marc Emmelmann, Secretary


November 2010, Dallas, Texas

Achievements

·         Approve Waikoloa and Teleconference  meeting minutes

Waikoloa face-to-face meeting 10/1160r0

Teleconference September to November 10/1219r1

 

·         Response to comments to PAR & 5C

·         No comments regarding technical contents are received by deadline.

·         One formatting issue is identified by deadline.

 

Motions

·         SG Extension

·         FIA SG:        13/0/0              Pass

·         802.11WG:   68/0/4              Pass

·         PAR update (11-10/1152r1)

·         FIA SG:        17/0/0              Pass

·         802.11WG:   70/0/4              Pass

 

Time line

·         November 2010

·         PAR approved by EC

·         December 2010

·         PAR approved by NesCom

·         January 2011

·         Chair election

·         Presentation about use case, requirements and all of related topics.

 

Teleconferences

·         Dec. 1st,  1:00am EST, Duration 1 hour.

·         Dec. 15th,  11:30am EST, Duration 1 hour.

·         Jan. 5th,  1:00am EST, Duration 1 hour.

·         Jan. 12th,  11:30am EST, Duration 1 hour.

 

 


September 2010, Waikoloa, Hawaii

Achievements

·         Approve San Diego and Teleconference  meeting minutes

San Diego face-to-face meeting 10/0925r1

Teleconference July to September 10/1103r0

 

·         Technical presentation

·         Potential Performance Improvements with Fast Initial Link Set-Up by Marc Emmelmann (Fraunhofer FOKUS) 10/0965r1

·         PAR & 5C Transition from FIA to Fast Initial Link Set-Up by Marc Emmelmann (Fraunhofer FOKUS) 10/1106r1

·         How does the (new) Fast Initial Link Set-Up PAR address risen concern by Marc Emmelmann (Fraunhofer FOKUS) 10/1125r1

·         Feasible exchange by Robert Moskowitz (ISCAlabs/Verizon Business) 10/1146r0

 

·         Reviewed and Edited  the 802.11 FIA PAR and 5C

Drafted and uploaded 10/0583r17

Final PAR:          10/1152r0

Final 5C:             10/1153r0

 

Motions

·         PAR

·         FIA SG:        26/0/2              Pass

·         802.11WG:   44/0/3              Pass

·         5C

·         FIA SG:        27/0/2              Pass

·         802.11WG:   42/0/4              Pass

 

Time line

·         Forward PAR and 5C to EC by October 8th

·         Forward PAR and 5C to NesCom by October 18th

 

Teleconferences

Selected weekly teleconference as,

·         Wednesday, Start Time 01:00 EDT, Duration 1Hour

·         Starting 22nd September Wednesday 01:00 EDT

·         Using WEB-EX that will be provided by Study Group Chair

 

 


July 2010, San Diego, California

Achievements

·         Approve the  Beijing and Teleconference  meeting minutes

Beijing face-to-face meeting 10/0615r0

Teleconference 2nd July to 12th July 10/0798r1

 

·         Web Secretary

Hitoshi Morioka (Root Inc.) volunteer to the web secretary

 

·         Technical presentation

·         Feasibility Study of FIA by Hitoshi Morioka (ROOT) 10/0836r1

·         Effectiveness of Reduction of Message Exchanges by Hiroki Nakano (Trans New Technology, Inc.) 10/0873r0

·         Some Concerns about FIA by Emily Qi (Intel Corporation) 10/0853r0

 

·         Reviewed and Edited  the 802.11 FIA PAR and 5C

Drafted and uploaded 10/0583r8

 

Time line

·         Finalize PAR and 5C by , September

·         Approve PAR and 5C by WB, September

·         Forward PAR and 5C to EC , September

·         Approve PAR and 5C on ExCom calendar, November

 

Teleconferences

Selected weekly teleconference as,

·         Wednesday ,  Start Time 01:00 EDT , Duration 1Hour

·         Starting 4th Aug Wednesday 01:00 EDT

·         Using WEB-EX that will be provided by Study Group Chair

 

 


May 2010, Beijing, PRC

Achievements

·         Hiroshi Mano was elected as chair of FIA-SG

·         Marc Emellman was elected as secretary of FIA-SG

·         Reviewed and Edited  the 802.11 FIA PAR and 5C

Finish and upload as  11-10-0583-05-0fia-fia-par-and-5c.doc

 

 

Teleconferences

Selected weekly teleconference as,

·         Starting dates: Wednesday 2nd June 2010,  Start Time 11:00 am and alternative 11:00 pm EST, Duration 1Hour

·         Using WEB-EX that will be provided by Study Group Chair

 

Straw poll at Ad hoc on PM2 Thursday

·         Do you believe the PAR&5C contained in 11-10-0583-r5 meet IEEE-SA guidelines, and are you in favor bring in the following text as individual motion to the IEEE802.11WG during Friday closing plenary?

Motion:

Request that the PAR contained in 11-10-0583-r5  and the Five Criteria contained in 11-10-0583-r5 be posted to the IEEE 802 Executive Committee (EC) agenda for WG 802 preview and EC approval to submit to NesCom.

 

Yes: 7, No:0, Abstain: 0

 

Individual motion in 802.11WG closing plenary

Yes: 13, No: 10, Abstain: 3

motion fails

 


This page is maintained by Stephen McCann. Comments are welcome.

Copyright (c) 2010, the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. (IEEE).
All rights reserved.
This website may contain names, logos, designs, titles, words, or phrases that may
constitute trademarks, service marks, or tradenames of the IEEE or other entities
which may be registered in certain jurisdictions.