Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Voting for classification method




Detection Ad Hoc,

You can count my support to option 2.

Regards,
Amir Lehr

> -----Original Message-----
> From:	Stewart, Donald S (Don) [SMTP:dsstewart@avaya.com]
> Sent:	ה, מרץ 29, 2001 7:19 AM
> To:	IEEE Detection Ad Hoc (E-mail)
> Cc:	Stewart, Donald S (Don)
> Subject:	Beginning to summarize the viable candidates for detection
> with classification
> 
> Detection Ad Hoc,  
> 
> Before we take any multi-votes or votes on possibilities for detection
> with classification, I want to give people a chance to tune-up the list we
> use. Please see the list below. Any comments are welcomed, but
> particularly if a category is missing or if I am seeing this differently
> than many of you are. I realize I have included some candidates that have
> been unpopular. But I see no harm in including them in voting.
> 
> Thanks 
> Don 
> ____________________ 
> 
> Candidate approaches to detection with classification 
> 
> 1) PD: exhibits 25 K ohm slope for 2.8 to 10 volts and exhibits one of a
> few constant current levels  for ~12 to 30v 
>    PSE: detects slope with equivalent of two mesurements and constant
> current with at least one measurement 
> 
> 2) PD: exhibits 25 K ohm slope for 2.8 to 10 volts and exhibits one of a
> few different resistance slopes for ~12 to 30v 
> 
>    PSE: detects first slope with equivalent of two mesurements and second
> slope with equivalent of  two measurements 
> 
> (3) Have PD exhibit maximum current draw shortly after detection (infinite
> power classes) 
> 
> (4) Combination of 1, 2. [Similar to one we voted on in Hilton Head. I
> propose we not vote on something as vague as this. Could someone propose a
> specific behavior they champion if they really want this voted?]
> 
> (5) Do it with the PHY 
> 
> (6) Any others? 
> 
> 
> 
> _________________________________________________ 
> Donald (Don) S. Stewart                  Phone:  732-817-5495 
> Avaya Inc.                                      FAX:  732-817-4666 
> Cross_Product Architecture 
> 101 Crawfords Corner Road 
> Holmdel, NJ 
>