PatCom Commenting Tool
 

 
 

 

The following tool must be used for the submission of comments on the PatCom Drafting Committee output. Use of the tool, including providing a rational for each change requested, is required in order for your comments to be considered, in a systematic manner. For this reason edited copies of the documents will not be considered.


Ballot Tool download and set-up instructions:

  1. Download the full PatCom Ballot Tool zip file. Approx size 2MB.
  2. Unzip the PatCom Ballot Tool to an empty folder. Do not move any component from that folder.
  3. Double-click on PatComBallotTool.exe
  4. Fill in your user information and begin commenting.


Comment entry instructions:

  1. Click in the Document field and select the document (e.g. Tutorial, Guidelines, FAQ) to which the comment applies.

  2. Tab or click to the Clause/Question field. Select the Question number in the case of the Tutorial (e.g. 6).There are also the options 'All' for a global comment on the whole document or 'Other' for a Clause not currently in the draft, or for a document with no Clause/Question numbers.

  3. Tab or click to the Page and Line fields and enter the page number and line number associated with the comment. If the comment spans multiple pages or lines, enter the page and/or line number associated with the first occurrence. Enter the page and/or line number of the other occurrences in the comment field.

  4. Tab or click to the Comment field and fill in your comment. This should give a rationale for the change.

  5. Click one of the "Comment Type" radio buttons.
    Substantive(S): Commenter is suggesting a substantive change to the draft.
    The Task Force can resolve the comment as they see fit.
    Editorial(E): Commenter is suggesting an editorial change to the draft.
    The Task Force can resolve the comment as they see fit

  6. Tab or click to the Suggested Remedy, and put in the proposed text to remedy the comment.

  7. Click on one of the 3 buttons on the bottom of the form.
    The "Enter Another Comment" button will open a new blank comment form.
    The "Help Page ?" button will return to this page.
    The "Finish" button will go to the exit page.

You may review your comments before you press the "Finish" button by using the page selection tool in the upper left hand corner.

Note - Comments are automatically given a comment number. This comment number is for reference within your own comment set and will not coincide with the comment numbering in the comment database.

Feedback on the comment tool can be emailed to

 
   

http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/pp-dialog
updated May 19, 2006
Contact Webmaster

This site and all contents are Copyright © 2006
Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.
All rights reserved.