SUO: Appeal of IEEE-SA BoG Directive
ATTN Lowell Johnson, Chair, CS Standards Activity Board:
1. Reference:
a. Message from Rona Gertz, Manager, IEEE-SA Governance, advising of
motion at IEEE-SA BoG November meeting (date not specified). (Attach 1)
b. Dorsey and Whitney Legal opinion, Nov 7, 2001. (Attach 2) (This
is a version I typed up from a paper copy, as I was never provided a digital
copy.)
c. Email message to Bob Spiller from Lyle Smith, 13 Sep 2001,
containing original message from Bob Spillers, Aug 13, 2001. (Attach 3)
d. Email message to James Schoening from Lyle Smith, Sep 14, 2001,
containing his original guidance, 13 Sep 2001. (Attach 4)
e. Legal opinion from Benedict O'Mahoney, Vice President,
Administration and Legal Affairs, Teknowledge Corp., Jan 15, 2002.
2. Background: The issue at hand is whether a vote by an IEEE Computer
Society working group should follow Robert's Rules of Order (as directed by
the CS Standards Activity Board P&Ps) or a higher level P&P, bylaw, or law,
as advised Lyle Smith, IEEE Parliamentarian, and endorsed by Dorsey and
Whitney legal opinion, and directed by IEEE-SA BoG directive. In Aug, 2001,
The SUO WG conducted a vote on whether to commence work on a starter
document (named SUMO). It passed 17-16, with 9 abstention. I, as Chair,
declare that the vote passed. Bob Spillers, a voting member, challenged the
vote on many issues and sent numerous questions to Lyle Smith. (See Attach
3). I also sent Mr. Smith some questions (See Attach 4). None of these
questions asked whether the way I had counted the votes was correct, though
Mr. Smith responded to me (Attach 4) that the vote had failed because of the
method of calculating a majority. Bob Spillers took this advice and pressed
this issue with various IEEE individuals (messages not available). The
issue finally made it's way to the IEEE-SA BOG meeting in November, which
passed the motion directing that the vote be retaken.
3. I appeal the directive of the IEEE-SA BoG for the following three
separate and distinct reasons, any one of which, I believe, will nullify
this directive and allow the vote to remain standing.
Basis #1: The Dorsey and Whitney legal opinion, upon which the
IEEE-SA BoG directive was based, failed to recognize a material fact, that
the Computer Society Standards Activities Board Policies and Procedures
directs working groups to follow Roberts Rules of Order (RRO). It states,
"The participants in our call also noted that no voting rules for Standards
working groups are specified in the IEEE Bylaws or the IEEE-SA Standards
Board Bylaws or Operations Manuals," which infers they believed no lower
level P&Ps addressed voting at the WG level. The SAB clearly cites RRO,
which covers voting quite clearly, and RRO are followed by CS WGs. As an
aside, one might argue that RRO is subordinate to higher policies and laws,
but this case was not made in the Dorsey and Whitney opinion.
Resolution: Appeal will be withdrawn if Chair is no longer required
to follow directive from IEEE-SA BoG.
Basis #2: The process used to arrive at the IEEE-SA BoG directive
violated the requirements of Openness and Due Process and amounted to an
informal appeals process. IEEE and the Computer Society have an appeals
process, but it was not followed for this matter. Lyle Smith offered
guidance (Attach 4) that the SUMO vote had not passed, and Bob Spillers
raised this issue with various individuals in IEEE. Mr. Spillers did not
submit an appeal, as he was advised he could. IEEE-SA BoG took up this
issue and acted upon it as if it were an appeal, directing that the vote be
retaken. The agenda item for this matter was not announced, and the meeting
of the IEEE-SA BOG was not open. Stakeholders, including myself, were not
given the opportunity to present their views.
Resolution: Appeal will be withdrawn if Chair is no longer required to
follow directive from IEEE-SA BoG.
Basis #3: The directive requires that a new vote be taken, but is
not clear on what constitutes a majority. The IEEE-SA BoG motion refers to
the Dorsey and Whitney opinion, which refers to Lyle Smith's email. (Attach
4). It is not clear which law or bylaw should be followed or how to compute
a majority.
It is clear abstentions would be counted, but are non-votes also
counted? In an email vote, is everyone considered present, since the ballot
was sent to everyone? For the SUMO vote, some non-voters did acknowledge
receipt of the ballot or were active on the listserv during this period, but
a few showed no sign of receipt.
IEEE Bylaws Section I-300, subsection 4 relating to Board of
Directors and Committee actions: "Unless otherwise provided in the
Certificate of Incorporation, the Constitution, these Bylaws, or the
Not-For-Profit Corporation Law of the State of New York, the vote of a
majority of the votes of the members present and entitled to vote, at the
time of the vote, provided a quorum is present, shall be the act of the
Board of Directors, any Committee thereof, or the Major Board, or any
committees of the forgoing."
Section 613 of the New York Not-for-Profit Corporation Law:
Sec. 613. Vote of members.
a) Except as otherwise required by
this chapter or by the certificate of incorporation or the by-laws as
permitted by this chapter, directors shall be elected by a plurality of
the votes cast at a meeting of members by the members entitled to vote in
the election.
b) Whenever any corporate action, other
than the election of directors, is to be taken under this chapter by vote of
the members, it shall, except as otherwise required by this chapter or by
the certificate of incorporation or by by-laws as permitted by this chapter,
be authorized by a majority of the votes cast at a meeting of members by the
members entitled to vote thereon.
c) Except as provided in paragraph (b),
any reference in this chapter to corporate action at a meeting of members by
"majority vote" or "two-thirds vote" shall require the action to be taken by
such proportion of the votes cast at such meeting, provided that the
affirmative votes cast in favor of any such action shall be at least equal
to the quorum. Blank votes or abstentions shall not be counted in the
number of votes cast.
The Dorsey and Whitney opinion stated: "Mr. Smith advised
Messrs. Spillers and Schoening that the motion failed because the
affirmative votes did not constitute a majority (i.e., 22) of the total
number of the ballots cast." [This would mean
non-votes are not counted. ]
I apologize for this confusion, but clear voting rules for an
email-based WG can't be derived from these documents. It is not possible to
conduct a vote without clear voting rules.
Resolution: Appeal will be withdrawn if either:
a. Chair is no longer required to follow directive from
IEEE-SA BoG.
b. Clear voting rule can be interpreted from the IEEE-SA BoG
directive and its referenced documents.
4. In the selection of the appeals board, it is requested that no
members be selected that are beholden to the IEEE-SA BoG.
Respectfully Submitted:
JAMES R. SCHOENING
Chair, IEEE P1600.1 Standard Upper Ontology Working Group
begin 600 Attach 1 - IEEE-SA BoG Directive.txt
M1G)O;3H@<BYG97)T>D!I965E+F]R9PT*4V5N=#H@36]N9&%Y+"!$96-E;6)E
M<B`Q,"P@,C`P,2`Q,CHP.2!030T*5&\Z(%-C:&]E;FEN9RP@2F%M97,@4B!#
M14-/32!$0U-#-$D-"D-C.B!*=61Y($=O<FUA;B`H12UM86EL*3L@)VPN9V%R
M9VEU;&]`:65E92YO<F<G#0I3=6)J96-T.B!293H@3F5E9"!R97-P;VYS92!4
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M:6]N#0IR96=A<F1I;F<@4#$V,#`N,3H-"@T*5&AE<F4@=V%S(&$@;6]T:6]N
M(&%N9"!S96-O;F0@8GD@1&5N;FES($)O9'-O;B!A;F0@1&]N($QO=6=H<GD@
M87,@9F]L;&]W<SH-"@T*5&AE($E%144M4T$@0D]'(&-O;G-I9&5R960@=&AE
M(&EN<75I<FEE<R!O9B!T:&4@245%12`Q-C`P+C$@=V]R:VEN9R!G<F]U<`T*
M86YD('1H92!O<&EN:6]N(&]F(#<@3F]V96UB97(@,C`P,2!O9F9E<F5D(&)Y
M($1O<G-E>2!A;F0@5VAI=&YE>2!A;F0-"F-O;F-U<G,@=VET:"!A;F0@<F5A
M9F9I<FUS('1H92!O<&EN:6]N('-T871E9"X@(%1H97)E9F]R92P@=&AE($E%
M144M4T$@0D]'#0ID:7)E8W1S('1H92!)145%+5-!(%-T86YD87)D<R!";V%R
M9"!T;R!I;F9O<FT@=&AE(%`Q-C`P+C$@=V]R:VEN9R!G<F]U<`T*=&AA="!I
M="!I<R!R97%U:7)E9"!T;R!R92UB86QL;W0@:71S(&EN:71I86P@9&5L:6)E
M<F%T:6]N+"!B87-E9"!O;B!T:&4-"G)E<75I<F5M96YT<R!O=71L:6YE9"!I
M;B!T:&4@869O<F5M96YT:6]N960@;&5T=&5R+@T*#0I&=7)T:&5R+"!T:&4@
M245%12U302!"3T<@96YC;W5R86=E<R!T:&4@245%12U302!3=&%N9&%R9',@
M0F]A<F0@=&\@:6YS=')U8W0-"G1H92!)145%(%`Q-C`P+C$@=V]R:VEN9R!G
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M144@4W1A;F1A<F1S($%C=&EV:71I97,-"G(N9V5R='I`:65E92YO<F<-"BLQ
M(#<S,B`U-C(@,S@P."`H<&AO;F4I.R`K,2`W,S(@-38R(#$U-S$@*&9A>"D-
M"DE%144@4W1A;F1A<F1S('=E8B!S:71E.FAT='`Z+R]S=&%N9&%R9',N:65E
M92YO<F<O#0H-"@T*("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(E-C:&]E;FEN9RP@2F%M97,@4B!#14-/32`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@($1#
M4T,T22(@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@5&\Z("`@("`B
M)VPN9V%R9VEU;&]`:65E92YO<F<G(B`\;"YG87)G:75L;T!I965E+F]R9SXL
M("`@(`T*("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`\2F%M97,N4V-H;V5N:6YG0&UA
M:6PQ+FUO;FUO=71H("`@("`@("`B2G5D>2!';W)M86X@*$4M;6%I;"DB(#QJ
M+F=O<FUA;D!I965E+F]R9SXL(")2;VYA($=E<G1Z("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@+F%R;7DN;6EL/B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@*$4M;6%I;"DB(#QR+F=E<G1Z0&EE964N;W)G/B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@8V,Z("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(`T*
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`Q,B\P-R\R,#`Q(#`Y.C,T($%-("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@(%-U8FIE8W0Z("`@("!.965D(')E<W!O;G-E(%1/1$%9
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(`T*#0H-"@T*
M#0I,:6YD82P@2G5D>2P@86YD(%)O;F$L#0H-"B`@("`@("`@("`@07,@=&AI
M<R!H87,@9')A9V=E9"!O;B!S:6YC92!!=6<L('!L96%S92!C;'5E(&UE(&EN
M(%1/1$%9(&]N#0IW:&%T)W,-"F=O:6YG(&]N+@T*#0I*:6T@4V-H;V5N:6YG
M#0H-"@T*#0HM+2TM+4]R:6=I;F%L($UE<W-A9V4M+2TM+0T*1G)O;3H@;"YG
M87)G:75L;T!I965E+F]R9R!;;6%I;'1O.FPN9V%R9VEU;&]`:65E92YO<F==
M#0I396YT.B!-;VYD87DL($1E8V5M8F5R(#`S+"`R,#`Q(#$P.C0U($%-#0I4
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M86YE+"!03R!";W@@,3,S,0T*4&ES8V%T87=A>2P@3DH@(#`X.#4U+3$S,S$@
M55-!#0HK,2`W,S(@-38R(#,X,#$@<&AO;F4-"BLQ(#<S,B`U-C(@,34W,2!F
M87@-"FAT='`Z+R]S=&%N9&%R9',N:65E92YO<F<O#0HM+2TM+2!&;W)W87)D
M960@8GD@3&EN9&$@1V%R9VEU;&\O4U1$4R]35$%&1B]54R])145%(&]N(#$R
M+S`S+S`Q(#$Q.C`S($%-#0HM+2TM+0T*#0H-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@2G5D:71H($=O<FUA;@T*#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(%1O.B`@("`@3&EN9&$-"D=A<F=I=6QO+U-41%,O
M4U1!1D8O55,O245%14!)145%#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(#$R+S`S
M+S`Q(#`Y.C`V("`@("`@(&-C.@T*#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@($%-
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(%-U8FIE8W0Z#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*
M4&QE87-E(&=E="!T:&ES('1O($II;2!38VAO96YI;F<N(%1H86YK<RX-"DIU
M9'D-"BTM+2TM($9O<G=A<F1E9"!B>2!*=61I=&@@1V]R;6%N+U-41%,O4U1!
M1D8O55,O245%12!O;B`Q,B\P,R\P,2`P.3HP-B!!30T*+2TM+2T-"@T*1&5L
M:79E<GD@1F%I;'5R92!297!O<G0-"@T*(%EO=7(-"B!D;V-U;65N=#H-"@T*
M('=A<R!N;W0@("`@($IA;65S+E-C:&]E;FEN9T!M86EL,2YM;VYM;W5T:`T*
M(&1E;&EV97)E9`T*('1O.@T*#0H@8F5C875S93H@("`@-34P($AO<W0@=6YK
M;F]W;@T*#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*5VAA="!S:&]U;&0@>6]U(&1O/PT*#0H@("!9
M;W4@8V%N(')E<V5N9"!T:&4@=6YD96QI=F5R86)L92!D;V-U;65N="!T;R!T
M:&4@<F5C:7!I96YT<R!L:7-T960@86)O=F4-"B`@(&)Y(&-H;V]S:6YG('1H
M92!297-E;F0@8G5T=&]N(&]R('1H92!297-E;F0@8V]M;6%N9"!O;B!T:&4@
M06-T:6]N<R!M96YU+@T*#0H@("!/;F-E('EO=2!H879E(')E<V5N="!T:&4@
M9&]C=6UE;G0@>6]U(&UA>2!D96QE=&4@=&AI<R!$96QI=F5R>2!&86EL=7)E
M#0H@("!297!O<G0N#0H-"B`@($EF(')E<V5N9&EN9R!T:&4@9&]C=6UE;G0@
M:7,@;F]T('-U8V-E<W-F=6P@>6]U('=I;&P@<F5C96EV92!A(&YE=PT*("`@
M9F%I;'5R92!R97!O<G0N#0H-"B`@(%5N;&5S<R!Y;W4@<F5C96EV92!O=&AE
M<B!$96QI=F5R>2!&86EL=7)E(%)E<&]R=',L('1H92!D;V-U;65N="!W87,-
M"B`@('-U8V-E<W-F=6QL>2!D96QI=F5R960@=&\@86QL(&]T:&5R(')E8VEP
M:65N=',N#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*("`@0G5Z>B]54R])145%#0H-"@T*#0H-"B`@
M?"`@("`@5&\Z("!*86UE<RY38VAO96YI;F=`;6%I;#$N;6]N;6]U=&@-"@T*
M#0H-"B`@?"`@("`@8V,Z#0H-"@T*#0H@("`@("!$871E.B`@,#@Z-#@Z,#8@
M04T@5&]D87D-"@T*#0H-"@T*("`@4W5B:F5C=#H-"@T*#0H-"@T*#0I$96%R
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M8V]M;75N8V%T:6]N+@T*0F5S="!R96=A<F1S+`T*2G5D>0T*#0H-"@T*#0H-
%"@T*#0H=
`
end
begin 600 Attach 2 - Dorsey & Whitney Opinion.txt
M5&AE(&9O;&QO=VEN9R!I<R!A('1Y<&5D+75P('9E<G-I;VX@;V8@82!P87!E
M<B!C;W!Y(&]F('1H92!$;W)S97D@86YD(`T*5VAI=&YE>2!L96=A;"!O<&EN
M:6]N+@T*(`T*2F%M97,@4V-H;V5N:6YG#0I#:&%I<BP@245%12!0,38P,"XQ
M(%-53R!71PT*#0H]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]
M/3T]/3T]/3T]#0H-"@T*1$]24T59("8@5TA)5$Y%62!,3%`-"C(U,"!087)K
M($%V96YU90T*3F5W(%EO<FLL($Y9(#$P,3<W#0I496QE<&AO;F4Z("@R,3(I
M-#$U+3DR,#`-"D9A>#H@*#(Q,BD@.34S+3<R,#$-"G=W=RYD;W)S97EL87<N
M8V]M#0H-"E)/0D525"!*+B!$5UE%4B!*4BX-"B@R,3(I(#0Q-2TY,C$X#0ID
M=WEE<BYR;V)E<G1`9&]R<V5Y;&%W+F-O;0T*#0I.;W9E;6)E<B`W+"`R,#`Q
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M144@=&\@365S<W)S+B!2;V)E<G0@4W!I;&QE<G,@86YD(`T*2F%M97,@4V-H
M;V5N:6YG(&EN(&-O;FYE8W1I;VX@=VET:"!A;B!E+6UA:6P@8F%L;&]T(&-O
M;F1U8W1E9"!B>2!T:&4@#0I0,38P,"XQ(%-T86YD87)D(%5P<&5R($]N=&]L
M;V=Y(%=O<FMI;F<@1W)O=7`@*'1H92`B5V]R:VEN9R!'<F]U<"(I('1O(`T*
M9&5T97)M:6YE('=H971H97(@82!D;V-U;65N="!S:&]U;&0@8F5C;VUE(&$@
M8F%S92!D;V-U;65N="X@(`T*4W!E8VEF:6-A;&QY+"!W92!U;F1E<G-T86YD
M('1H870@-#(@92UM86EL(&)A;&QO=',@=V5R92!R96-E:79E9"`-"FEN8VQU
M9&EN9R`Y(&%B<W1E;G1I;VYS+"`Q-R!A9F9I<FUA=&EV92!V;W1E<R!A;F0@
M,38@;F5G871I=F4@=F]T97,N("`-"DUR+B!3;6ET:"!A9'9I<V5D($UE<W-R
M<RX@4W!I;&QE<G,@86YD(%-C:&]E;FEN9R!T:&%T('1H92!M;W1I;VX@9F%I
M;&5D(`T*8F5C875S92!T:&4@869F:7)M871I=F4@=F]T97,@9&ED(&YO="!C
M;VYS=&ET=71E(&$@;6%J;W)I='D@*&DN92XL(#(R*2`-"F]F('1H92!T;W1A
M;"!N=6UB97(@;V8@=&AE(&)A;&QO=',@8V%S="X@(%1H97)E('=A<R!N;R!N
M965D('1O(&1E=&5R;6EN92`-"G=H971H97(@82!Q=6]R=6T@=V%S('!R97-E
M;G0@<VEN8V4@=&AE(&UO=&EO;B!F86EL960N(`T*#0H)4F5C96YT;'DL($D@
M<&%R=&EC:7!A=&5D('=I=&@@>6]U(&EN(&$@=&5L97!H;VYE(&-O;F9E<F5N
M8V4@=VAI8V@@#0II;F-L=61E9"!-<BX@4VUI=&@L($5R:6,@2&5R>B`H1&ER
M96-T;W(@16UE<FET=7,@;V8@245%12!A;F0@<&%S="`-"E!A<FQI86UE;G1A
M<FEA;B!O9B!)145%*2P@5&AO;6%S(%=E='1A8V@@*'!A<G1N97(@:6X@=&AE
M(&9I<FT@;V8@0V]H96X@)B`-"D=R:7-B97DL('=H:6-H(&%C="!A<R!S<&5C
M:6%L(&-O=6YS96P@=&\@=&AE($E%144@4W1A;F1A<F1S(`T*07-S;V-I871I
M;VXI+"!-87)C;R!-:6=L:6%R;R`H,C`P,2!0<F5S:61E;G0L($E%144@4W1A
M;F1A<F1S(`T*07-S;V-I871I;VXI(&%N9"!O=&AE<B!M96UB97)S(&]F('1H
M92!)145%(%-T86YD87)D<R!!8W1I=FET:65S('-T869F+B`@#0I);B!R979I
M97=I;F<@=&AI<R!M871T97(L('1H92!P87)T:6-I<&%N=',@:6X@=&AE('1E
M;&5P:&]N92!C;VYF97)E;F-E(`T*=6YA;FEM;W5S;'D@8V]N8VQU9&4@=&AA
M="!T:&4@861V:6-E(&=I=F5N(&)Y($UR+B!3;6ET:"!T;R!-97-S<G,N(`T*
M4V-H;V5N:6YG(&%N9"!3<&EL;&5R<R!W87,@8V]R<F5C="X-"@T*"51H92!P
M87)T:6-I<&%N=',@:6X@=&AE('1E;&5P:&]N92!C;VYF97)E;F-E(')E=FEE
M=V5D(%-E8W1I;VX@-S`X(`T*;V8@=&AE($YE=R!9;W)K($YO="UF;W(M4')O
M9FET($-O<G!O<F%T:6]N($QA=R!R96=A<F1I;F<@86-T:6]N<R!B>2!T:&4@
M#0IB;V%R9"!O9B!D:7)E8W1O<G,[($E%144@0GEL87<@22TS,#$N-R!R96=A
M<F1I;F<@=&AE(&UA;FYE<B!I;B!W:&EC:"`-"F%C=&EO;B!M87D@8F4@=&%K
M96X@8GD@=&AE($E%144@0F]A<F0@;V8@1&ER96-T;W)S(&%N9"!C;VUM:71T
M965S.R!)145%(`T*0GEL87<@22TS,#$N,3$@<F5G87)D:6YG('1H92!U<V4@
M;V8@4F]B97)T)W,@4G5L97,@;V8@3W)D97(@8GD@=&AE(`T*=F%R:6]U<R!O
M<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!U;FET<R!O9B!T:&4@245%12!I;B!T:&4@86)S96YC
M92!O9B!O=&AE<B`-"F%P<&QI8V%B;&4@<G5L97,@;V8@<')O8V5D=7)E.R!A
M;F0@4F]B97)T)W,@4G5L97,@;V8@3W)D97(@<F5G87)D:6YG(`T*8F%S97,@
M9F]R(&1E=&5R;6EN:6YG(&$@=F]T:6YG(')E<W5L="X@(%1H92!P87)T:6-I
M<&%N=',@:6X@;W5R(&-A;&P@#0IA;'-O(&YO=&5D('1H870@;F\@=F]T:6YG
M(')U;&5S(&9O<B!3=&%N9&%R9',@=V]R:VEN9R!G<F]U<',@87)E(`T*<W!E
M8VEF:65D(&EN('1H92!)145%($)Y;&%W<R!O<B!T:&4@245%12U302!3=&%N
M9&%R9',@0F]A<F0@0GEL87=S(&]R(`T*3W!E<F%T:6]N<R!-86YU86QS+@T*
M#0H)5&AE(&1E=&5R;6EN871I;VX@8V]M;75N:6-A=&5D('1O($UE<W-R<RX@
M4V-H;V5N:6YG(&%N9"!3<&EL;&5R<R`-"G=A<R!M861E(&9O<B!S979E<F%L
M(')E87-O;G,N("!&:7)S="P@=&AE($-O<G!O<F%T92!';W9E<FYA;F-E($]F
M9FEC92!O9B`-"DE%144@:&%S(&-O;G-I<W1E;G1L>2!A9'9I<V5D(&]R9V%N
M:7IA=&EO;F%L('5N:71S(&]F($E%144@=&AA="P@:6X@#0IO<F1E<B!T;R!T
M86ME(&%C=&EO;B!O;B!A(&UA='1E<BP@82!Q=6]R=6T@;75S="!B92!P<F5S
M96YT(&%N9"!T:&4@#0IA9F9I<FUA=&EV92!V;W1E(&]F(&$@;6%J;W)I='D@
M;V8@=&AE(&UE;6)E<G,@;V8@=&AE(')U;&EN9R!B;V1Y('!R97-E;G0@#0IA
M="!T:&4@=&EM92!O9B!T:&4@=F]T92!M=7-T(&)E(&]B=&%I;F5D+B`@4V5C
M;VYD+"!T:&4@0V]R<&]R871E(`T*1V]V97)N86YC92!/9F9I8V4@:&%S(&-O
M;G-I<W1E;G1L>2!A9'9I<V5D('1H92!O<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!U;FET<R!O
M9B`-"DE%144@=&AA="`B8F5S="!C;W)P;W)A=&4@<')A8W1I8V5S(B!S=6=G
M97-T(&9O;&QO=VEN9R!T:&4@=F]T:6YG(&%N9"`-"F]T:&5R(')U;&5S(&]F
M('!R;V-E9'5R92!A<'!L:6-A8FQE('1O('1H92!)145%($)O87)D(&]F($1I
M<F5C=&]R<R!W:&5N(`T*;W1H97(@<G5L97,@;V8@<')O8V5D=7)E(&%R92!N
M;W0@<W!E8VEF:65D+B`@5&AI<F0L(&EF(&$@;6%J;W)I='D@;V8@=&AE(`T*
M8F%L;&]T<R!R96-E:79E9"!W97)E(&YO="!R97%U:7)E9"!I;B!O<F1E<B!F
M;W(@86-T:6]N('1O(&)E('1A:V5N(&)Y(`T*=&AE(%=O<FMI;F<@1W)O=7`L
M(&%N(&%B<W5R9"!R97-U;'0@;6EG:'0@8F4@;V)T86EN960N("!&;W(@97AA
M;7!L92P@#0IA<W-U;64@-#(@8F%L;&]T<R!W97)E(')E8V5I=F5D('=I=&@@
M-#$@86)S=&5N=&EO;G,@86YD(&]N;'D@,2`-"F%F9FER;6%T:79E('9O=&4N
M("!)9B!O;FQY(&$@;6%J;W)I='D@;V8@=&AE(&)A;&QO=',@86-T=6%L;'D@
M8V%S="`-"BAE>&-L=61I;F<@86)S=&5N=&EO;G,I('=E<F4@8V]U;G1E9"P@
M=&AE(&1O8W5M96YT(&EN('%U97-T:6]N('=O=6QD(`T*:&%V92!B96-O;64@
M82!B87-E(&1O8W5M96YT('=I=&@@;VYL>2!A('-I;F=L92!V;W1E(&-A<W0@
M:6X@:71S(&9A=F]R+B`@#0I&:6YA;&QY+"!I9B!V;W1I;F<@<')O8V5D=7)E
M<R!D:69F97)E;G0@9G)O;2!T:&]S92!R96-O;6UE;F1E9"!A<F4@=&\@8F4@
M#0IU<V5D(&)Y('1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P("AO<B!O=&AE<B!W;W)K:6YG
M(&=R;W5P<R!W:71H:6X@=&AE(%-T86YD87)D<R`-"D%S<V]C:6%T:6]N*2P@
M=&AE($E%144@0F]A<F0@;V8@1&ER96-T;W)S('-H;W5L9"!T86ME(&%C=&EO
M;B!T;R`-"FEN=&5R<')E="!T:&4@;&%W(&%N9"!T:&4@245%12!">6QA=W,@
M<V\@87,@=&\@<&5R;6ET('1H92!U<V4@;V8@<W5C:"`-"F1I9F9E<F5N="!V
M;W1I;F<@<')O8V5D=7)E<RX-"@T*"4EN('-H;W)T+"!W92!B96QI979E('1H
M870@=&AE($E%144@0F]A<F0@;V8@1&ER96-T;W)S('5L=&EM871E;'D@#0IM
M=7-T(&%P<')O=F4@=VAE=&AE<B!A;B!E>&-E<'1I;VX@<VAO=6QD(&)E(&UA
M9&4@=&\@=&AE(')U;&5S(&]F(`T*<')O8V5D=7)E<R!W:&EC:"!H879E(&)E
M96X@8V]N<VES=&5N=&QY(')E8V]M;65N9&5D('1O('1H92`-"F]R9V%N:7IA
M=&EO;F%L('5N:71S(&]F($E%144N("!!9F9E8W1E9"!P87)T:65S(&%R92P@
M;V8@8V]U<G-E+"!F<F5E('1O(`T*87!P96%L('1H92!R=6QI;F<@;V8@=&AE
M($-O<G!O<F%T92!';W9E<FYA;F-E($]F9FEC92!O9B!)145%('1O('1H92!)
M145%(`T*0F]A<F0@;V8@1&ER96-T;W)S+@T*#0H)1FEN86QL>2P@>6]U(&%L
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M97,@86YD(&%D9')E<W-E<R`-"F]F(&ET<R!C;VYT<FEB=71O<G,@=VAO(&=I
M=F4@;6]R92!T:&%N(&$@<W!E8VEF:6,@86UO=6YT(&EN(&ET<R!A;FYU86P@
M#0II;F9O<FUA=&EO;B!R971U<FXL('-U8V@@:6YF;W)M871I;VX@:7,@;F]T
M(&%V86EL86)L92!T;R!T:&4@9V5N97)A;"`-"G!U8FQI8RX-"@T*"4D@=')U
M<W0@=&AA="!T:&ES(&ES(')E<W!O;G-I=F4@=&\@>6]U<B!R97%U97-T<RX-
M"@T*"0D)"0E697)Y(%1R=6QY('EO=7)S+`T*#0H)"0D)"5)O8F5R="!*+B!$
C=WEE<B!*<BX@#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*+B`-"@T*#0H-"@T*#0H=
`
end
begin 600 Attach 3 - Msg from Lyle Smith to Bob Spillers.txt
M1G)O;3H@;"YM+G-M:71H0&EE964N;W)G#0I396YT.B!4:'5R<V1A>2P@4V5P
M=&5M8F5R(#$S+"`R,#`Q(#DZ-#`@04T-"E1O.B!S:WED;V=`<&]S=&]F9FEC
M92YP86-B96QL+FYE=`T*0V,Z(%-C:&]E;FEN9RP@2F%M97,@4B!#14-/32!$
M0U-#-$D[(&HN9V]R;6%N0&EE964N;W)G.PT*<RYT871I;F5R0&EE964N;W)G
M.R!E+FAE<GI`:65E92YO<F<[(&1W>65R+G)O8F5R=$!D;W)S97EL87<N8V]M
M#0I3=6)J96-T.B!1=65S=&EO;G,@<F5G87)D:6YG(%)O8F5R=',@4G5L97,@
M;V8@3W)D97(-"@T*#0I-<BX@4W!I;&QE<G,L#0H-"EEO=7(@<75E<W1I;VYS
M(&AA=F4@8F5E;B!R979I97=E9"!B>2!T:&4@0F]A<F0@4&%R;&EA;65N=&%R
M:6%N+"!,96=A;`T*0V]U;G-E;"!A;F0@1&ER96-T;W(@16UE<FET=7,@=VAO
M(&%C="!A<R!A('1E86T@86YY(&%N<W=E<B!Q=65S=&EO;G,@;V8-"G1H:7,@
M;F%T=7)E(&%S('=E;&P@87,@=&AO<V4@<F5L871E9"!T;R!A;&P@1V]V97)N
M86YC92!)<W-U97,@;VX@8F5H86QF(&]F#0IT:&4@0F]A<F0N#0H-"E)O8F5R
M="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F($]R9&5R("`@87)E('-P96-I9FEE9"!I;B!T:&4@245%
M12!">6QA=W,@=&\@8F4@=7-E9"!B>0T*(BXN+BYO<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!U
M;FET<R!O9B!)145%('5N;&5S<R!O=&AE<B!R=6QE<R!O9B!P<F]C961U<F4@
M<W!E8VEF:65D#0IB>2!.62!.;W0M#0IF;W(M4')O9FET($-O<G!O<F%T:6]N
M($QA=RXN+BXN971C+B(@5&AU<RP@4F]B97)T)W,@4G5L97,@87)E('-U8F]R
M9&EN871E9`T*:6X@=&AE(&AI97)A<F-H>0T*;V8@<G5L97,@=&\@3ED@;&%W
M+"!)145%($-E<G1I9FEC871E(&]F($EN8V]R<&]R871I;VXL($-O;G-T:71U
M=&EO;BP-"D)Y;&%W<RP@4F5S;VQU=&EO;G,@;V8@=&AE#0I";V%R9"!O9B!$
M:7)E8W1O<G,L(%!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!0<F]C961U<F5S+"!A;F0@4')A8W1I
M8V5S+B`@5&AE<F4@=V%S('-O;64-"F1I<V-U<W-I;VX@<F5G87)D:6YG('5S
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M8FQE#0IF;W(@<F5V:65W+@T*#0H@($9R;VTZ("`@(%)O8F5R="!'<F%Y<V]N
M(%-P:6QL97)S(#QS:WED;V=`<&]S=&]F9FEC92YP86-B96QL+FYE=#X-"CX@
M("`@("`@("`@(%1O.B`@("`@($QY;&4@4VUI=&@@/&QY;&4N<VUI=&A`:65E
M92YO<F<^#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!3=6)J96-T.B!1=65S=&EO;G,@<F5G87)D
M:6YG(%)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F($]R9&5R#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!$871E
M.B`@("!-;VXL(#$S($%U9R`R,#`Q(#`T.C,R.C(T("TP-#`P#0H^#0H^("`@
M("`@("`@("!,>6QE+`T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@22!H879E('1R:65D('1O(&ES
M;VQA=&4@=&AE<V4@<75E<W1I;VYS('1O(&ES<W5E<R!O9@T*/B`@("`@("`@
M("`@<&%R;&EA;65N=&%R>0T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@<')O8V5D=7)E(&)A<V5D
M(&]N('1H92!L871E<W0@=F5R<VEO;B!O9B!2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9@T*
M3W)D97(-"CX@("`@("`@("`@("A2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<B!.
M97=L>2!2979I<V5D(#$P=&@@161I=&EO;B!P=6)L:7-H960-"F)Y#0H^("`@
M("`@("`@("!097)S975S#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!0=6)L:7-H:6YG($-A;6)R
M:61G92P@36%S<RX@3V-T;V)E<B`R,#`P*2X-"CX-"CX@("`@("`@("`@("@Q
M*2`@36%Y('1H92!C:&%I<B!M86ME(&$@;6]T:6]N/PT*/B`@("`@("`@("`@
M06YS=V5R/B!.;W0@=VAI;&4@<VET=&EN9R!I;B!T:&4@0VAA:7(N($AE(&UA
M>2!R96QI;G%U:7-H('1H90T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@0VAA:7(L(&%N9"!T:&5N
M(&UA:V4@82!M;W1I;VXN#0H^#0H^("`@("`@("`@("`H,BD@($UA>2!T:&4@
M8VAA:7(@<&%R=&EC:7!A=&4@:6X@9&5B871E/PT*/B`@("`@("`@("`@06YS
M=V5R+B!.;W0@=VAI;&4@<VET=&EN9R!I;B!T:&4@0VAA:7(N(%-E92!A;G-W
M97(@=&\@,2D-"CX-"CX@("`@("`@("`@("@S*2`@268@=&AE(&-H86ER(&1O
M97,@;6%K92!A(&UO=&EO;B!M=7-T(&AE('-T97`@87-I9&4@87,-"F-H86ER
M#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!A;F0-"CX@("`@("`@("`@('!A<W,@=&AE(&=A=F5L
M('1O(&%N(&%C=&EN9R!C:&%I<C\-"CX@("`@("`@("`@($%N<W=E<BX@665S
M+"!S964@,2D@86YD(#(I(&%B;W9E#0H^#0H^("`@("`@("`@("`H-"D@($UA
M>2!T:&4@8VAA:7(@*'=H:6QE(&%C=&EN9R!A<R!C:&%I<BD@=F]T90T*/B`@
M("`@("`@("`@06YS=V5R+B!4:&4@0VAA:7(@;6%Y('9O=&4@:6X@8V5R=&%I
M;B!C:7)C=6US=&%N8V5S+B!);B!T:&4-"CX@("`@("`@("`@(&%B<V5N8V4@
M;V8@:&EG:&5R(&QE=F5L(')U;&5S+"!S=6-H(&%S(&)Y;&%W<RP@<&]L:6-I
M97,L(&]R#0IE=F5N('!R86-T:6-E<RP@=&AE($-H86ER#0H^("`@("`@;6%Y
M('9O=&4@=VAE;F5V97(@:&ES('9O=&4@8V%N(&%F9F5C="!T:&4@;W5T8V]M
M92TM+71H870@:7,L('1O#0IM86ME+"!B<F5A:RP-"CX@("`@("!O<B!C875S
M92!A('1I92!V;W1E+@T*#0H^("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@*&$I(&]N(&$@
M;6]T:6]N#0H^("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("AB*2!T;R!B<F5A:R!A('1I
M90T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("AC*2!T;R!C<F5A=&4@82!T:64-"B`@
M("`@("`@("`@(%1H92!)145%($-O;G-T:71U=&EO;B!S<&5C:69I97,@0VAA
M:7(@=F]T97,@9F]R('1H92!#:&%I<B!O9@T*=&AE($)O87)D(&]F($1I<F5C
M=&]R<R!A;F0@=&AE($-H86ER#0H@("`@("`@("`@("!O9B!T:&4@07-S96UB
M;'DL(&)U="!N;W0@:6X@9V5N97)A;"P@86YD('1H97)E9F]R92!2;V)E<G1S
M#0I2=6QE<R!W;VQD(&%P<&QY+"!A<R!E>'!L86EN960@86)O=F4N#0H^#0H^
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("AD*2!T;R!B<F5A:R!A('1I92!A9G1E<B!V
M;W1I;F<@=&\@8W)E871E(&$@=&EE#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!!;G-W97(N(%1H
M92!#:&%I<B!C86YN;W0@=F]T92!T=VEC92P@=&AA="!I<R!T;R!C<F5A=&4@
M82!T:64L#0IA;F0-"CX@("`@("`@("`@('1H96X@82!S96-O;F0@=&EM92!T
M;R!B<F5A:R!A('1I90T*/@T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@*#4I("!-87D@=&AE('!E
M<G-O;B!A8W1I;F<@87,@8VAA:7(@=F]T92!O;B!A(&UO=&EO;B!W:&EL90T*
M86-T:6YG#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!A<PT*/B`@("`@("`@("`@8VAA:7(_#0H^
M("`@("`@("`@("!!;G-W97(N(%1H:7,@;&]O:W,@;&EK92!Q=65S=&EO;B`T
M*&$I+B!)<R!T:&ES('%U97-T:6]N(&UE86YT#0IT;PT*/B`@("`@("`@("`@
M8F4@9&EF9F5R96YT/PT*/@T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@*#8I("!7:&%T(&ES('1H
M92!S:7IE("AP97)C96YT*2!O9B!A('%U;W)U;2`H87-S=6UI;F<@;F\-"CX@
M("`@("`@("`@('!A<FQI86UE;G1A<GD-"CX@("`@("`@("`@('!R;V-E9'5R
M97,@+2!E+F<N(&)Y;&%W<R`M(&]T:&5R('1H86X@4E)/*0T*/B`@("`@("`@
M("`@06YS=V5R+B!!(&UA:F]R:71Y(&]F('9O=&EN9R!M96UB97)S+"`H4W!E
M8VEF:65D(&EN($YY(%-T871U=&4-"F%N9"!)145%($)Y;&%W<RDN#0H^#0H^
M("`@("`@("`@("`@($ES(&$@<75O<G5M(')E<75I<F5D('1O('!A<W,@82!M
M;W1I;VX_#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!!;G-W97(N(%EE<RP@=6YL97-S(&$@<75O
M<G5M(&AA9"!B965N(&5S=&%B;&ES:&5D+"!S;VUE(&UE;6)E<G,-"CX@("`@
M("`@("`@(&AA=F4@;&5F="P@86YD(&YO8F]D>2!H87,@<75E<W1I;VYE9"!W
M:&5T:&5R(&$@<75O<G5M('-T:6QL#0IE>&ES=',@270-"CX@("`@("`@("`@
M:7,@=&AE;B!P<F5S=6UE9"!T;R!E>&ES="X-"CX-"CX@("`@("`@("`@("@X
M*2`@36%Y('1H92!C:&%I<B!D96-L87)E('1H870@82!Q=6]R=6T@:7,@=6YN
M96-E<W-A<GD_#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!!;G-W97(N($Y/#0H^#0H^("`@("`@
M("`@("`Y*2`@36%Y('1H92!R=6QE<R!O;B!V;W1I;F<@;W(@<75O<G5M<R!B
M92!C:&%N9V5D('=I=&AO=70-"CX-"CX@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@*&$I
M(&$@=F]T90T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`H8BD@82!Q=6]R=6T-"CX@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@*&,I(&$@='=O('1H:7)D<R!V;W1E(&EN(&9A
M=F]R(&]F('1H92!C:&%N9V4H<RD-"CX@("`@("`@("`@($%N<W=E<BX@3F\L
M(&YO+"!A;F0@;F\N($$@<75O<G5M(&ES(&5S=&%B;&ES:&5D(&)Y(&QA=RP@
M;W(@8GD-"CX@("`@("`@("`@($-E<G1I9FEC871E(&]F($EN8V]R<&]R871I
M;VXL#0H^("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(&]R(&EN('1H92!)145%($)Y
M;&%W<PT*/@T*/B`@("`@("!)<R!A(&UO=&EO;B!P97)M:71T960@*&EN(&]R
M9&5R/RD@=&AA="!C;VYT86EN<R!W:71H:6X@:71S96QF#0H^("`@("`@("`@
M("!C:&%N9V5S('1O('1H92!E>&ES=&EN9R!P<F]C961U<F5S(&]N('=H870@
M:7,@<F5Q=6ER960@9F]R('1H90T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@;6]T:6]N('1O#0H^
M("`@("`@("`@("!P87-S("T@92YG+B!D96-L87)E(&$@<75O<G5M('5N;F5C
M97-S87)Y/PT*/B`@("`@("`@("`@06YS=V5R+B!.;RP@82!Q=6]R=6T@:7,@
M86QW87ES(&YE961E9"X-"CX-"CX@("`@("`@("`@(%1H86YK('EO=2X-"CX-
M"CX@("`@("`@("`@($)O8B!3<&EL;&5R<PT*#0I,>6QE($TN(%-M:71H#0I3
M=&%F9B!$:7)E8W1O<B`M($-O<G!O<F%T92!!8W1I=FET:65S#0HW,S(@.3@Q
)+3,T-#<-"@T*
`
end
begin 600 Attach 4 - Msg from Lyle Smith to James Schoening.txt
M1G)O;3H@;"YM+G-M:71H0&EE964N;W)G#0I396YT.B!&<FED87DL(%-E<'1E
M;6)E<B`Q-"P@,C`P,2`Y.C`U(%!-#0I4;SH@4V-H;V5N:6YG+"!*86UE<R!2
M($-%0T]-($1#4T,T20T*0V,Z(&1W>65R+G)O8F5R=$!D;W)S97EL87<N8V]M
M.R!E+FAE<GI`:65E92YO<F<[(&HN9V]R;6%N0&EE964N;W)G.PT*<RYT871I
M;F5R0&EE964N;W)G#0I3=6)J96-T.B!213H@4F5Q=65S="!F;W(@4G5L97,@
M861V:6-E+@T*#0H-"DII;2P-"@T*3V8@8V]U<G-E('1H97D@9&ED+B`@5V4@
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M('1H92!S86UE(&-O;G-I<W1E;G0@=V%Y+B`@5&AE($E%144@0F]A<F0@86YD
M(&ET<R!#;VUM:71T965S(&%L<V\-"FUU<W0@9F]L;&]W('1H97-E(&%N9"!E
M=F5N(&UO<F4@<F5S=')I8W1I=F4@<G5L97,N("!792!H879E('!R;W9I9&5D
M#0IA9&1I=&EO;F%L(&9L97AI8FEL:71Y(&9O<B!T:&4@4W1A;F1A<F1S(%=O
M<FMI;F<@1W)O=7!S+B!)(&%M('1R>6EN9R!T;PT*:V5E<"!T:&%T(&%D9&5D
M(&9L97AI8FEL:71Y(&EN('1A8W0@<V\@=V4@9&\@;F]T('=I;F0@=7`@:6X@
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M92!Q=65S=&EO;G,@:&%V92!B965N(&%N<W=E<F5D+B`@268-"G1H:7,@9V]E
M<R!B97EO;F<@82!S:6UP;&4@<F5S<&]N<V4@=&\@=F5R:69Y(&%G<F5E;65N
M="!T:&5N(&9U<G1H97(-"F-O;G-I9&5R871I;VX@;75S="!B92!G:79E;BX-
M"@T*#0H-"DQY;&4@32X@4VUI=&@-"E-T869F($1I<F5C=&]R("T@0V]R<&]R
M871E($%C=&EV:71I97,-"C<S,B`Y.#$M,S0T-PT*#0H-"B`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(E-C:&]E;FEN9RP@
M2F%M97,@4B!#14-/32`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@1$-30S1)(B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@5&\Z("`@("`B)VPN;2YS;6ET:$!I965E+F]R9R<B(#QL+FTN<VUI
M=&A`:65E92YO<F<^("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@/$IA;65S+E-C
M:&]E;FEN9T!M86EL,2YM;VYM;W5T:"`@("`@("`@8V,Z("`@("`B4W5S86X@
M5&%T:6YE<B`H12UM86EL*2(@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@+F%R;7DN;6EL/B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@/',N=&%T:6YE<D!I965E+F]R9SX@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@4W5B:F5C=#H@("`@
M(%)%.B!297%U97-T(&9O<B!2=6QE<R!A9'9I8V4N("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@,#DO,30O,C`P,2`P-CHU,R!032`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-
M"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"@T*#0H-"@T*3'EL92P-"@T*("`@
M("`@("`@("!0;&5A<V4@86-K;F]W;&5D9V4@<F5C96EP="!O9B!T:&ES(&UE
M<W-A9V4N#0H-"B`@("`@("`@("`@4F5G87)D:6YG('EO=7(@<F5S<&]N<V4@
M;VX@=&AE("=M86IO<FET>2<@:7-S=64L($D@:&%V92!N;R!D;W5B=`T*>6]U
M#0IT86QK960@=&\@37(N($AE<GH@86YD($UR+B!$=WEE<BP@8G5T(&1I9"!T
M:&5Y(&%C='5A;&QY(&-O;F-U<B!W:71H('EO=7(-"G)U;&EN9RP@86YD('=A
M<R!T:&ES('9E<F)A;&QY(&]R(&EN('=R:71I;F<O96UA:6PN($D@:&%V92!W
M<FET=&5N('1O('1H96T-"F)U="!H879E(&YO="!R96-E:79E9"!A(')E<W!O
M;G-E+B`@1&ED(&%N>6]N92!F<F]M('1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@1&5P87)T;65N
M=`T*8V]N8W5R+B!))V0@;&EK92!T;R!T86QK('1O('1H96T@86QS;RX-"@T*
M("`@("`@("`@("!9;W4@:&%V92!T;VQD(&UE(&%B;W5T('1H:7,@3ED@;&%W
M+B`@0V]U;&0@>6]U('%U;W1E(&UE('1H90T*86-T=6%L#0IP87-S86=E+B`@
M0V%N('EO=2!E>'!L86EN('=H>2!T:&ES(&%P<&QI97,@=&\@245%12=S(#@P
M,"L@<W1A;F1A<F1S('=O<FMI;F<-"F=R;W5P<S\-"@T*("`@("`@("`@("!)
M<VXG="!T:&5R92!A(&QE9V%L('!R:6YC:7!L92!T:&%T('-A>7,@=&AA="!I
M9B!E=F5R>6]N92!F;VQL;W=S#0IA#0IG:79E;B!L87<@86YD(&EG;F]R97,@
M86YO=&AE<BP@:70G<R!/2R!T;R!C;VYT:6YU92!T;R!I9VYO<F4@:70_("!)
M(')E<75E<W0-"F$@;&5G86P@;W!I;FEO;B!O;B!T:&%T+@T*#0H@("`@("`@
M("`@($%L<V\L($D@86T@;F]T('%U:6-K('1O(&-O;7!L86EN+"!B=70@22!N
M965D(&UU8V@@9F%S=&5R#0IR97-P;VYS90T*=&EM92X-"@T*2FEM(%-C:&]E
M;FEN9PT*0VAA:7(L(%`Q-C`P+C$@4U5/(%='#0H-"@T*#0H-"BTM+2TM3W)I
M9VEN86P@365S<V%G92TM+2TM#0I&<F]M.B!L+FTN<VUI=&A`:65E92YO<F<@
M6VUA:6QT;SIL+FTN<VUI=&A`:65E92YO<F==#0I396YT.B!4:'5R<V1A>2P@
M4V5P=&5M8F5R(#$S+"`R,#`Q(#DZ,SD@04T-"E1O.B!*86UE<RY38VAO96YI
M;F=`;6%I;#$N;6]N;6]U=&@N87)M>2YM:6P-"D-C.B!S:WED;V=`<&]S=&]F
M9FEC92YP86-B96QL+FYE=#L@:BYG;W)M86Y`:65E92YO<F<[#0IS+G1A=&EN
M97)`:65E92YO<F<[(&4N:&5R>D!I965E+F]R9SL@9'=Y97(N<F]B97)T0&1O
M<G-E>6QA=RYC;VT-"E-U8FIE8W0Z(%)E<75E<W0@9F]R(%)U;&5S(&%D=FEC
M92X-"@T*#0I-<BX@(%-C:&]E;FEN9RP-"@T*#0H-"@T*#0I)(&AA=F4@<F5V
M:65W960@>6]U<B!Q=65S=&EO;G,@=VET:"!)145%($QE9V%L(&-O=6YS96P@
M4F]B97)T($1W>65R(&]F#0I$;W)S97D@)B!7:&ET;F5Y+"!A;F0@1&ER96-T
M;W(@16UE<FET=7,@17)I8R!(97)Z('=H;R!I<R!C;VUM:7-S:6]N960@8GD-
M"G1H92!)145%(%!R97-I9&5N="!T;R!B92!T:&4@;&EA<V]N('=I=&@@9V]V
M97)N86YC92!A;F0@;&5G86P@:7-S=65S+@T*1F]L;&]W:6YG(&EN8VQU9&5D
M(&EN('EO=7(@;W)I9VEN86P@=&5X="!I;B!R960@87)E(&]U<B!A;G-W97)S
M+@T*#0H-"DEN(&%D9&ET:6]N+"!R96=A<F1I;F<@>6]U<B!R=6QI;F<@=&AA
M="!T:&4@=V]R:VEN9R!G<F]U<"!I<R!A;B!A<W-E;6)L>2P-"G=E(&9I;F0@
M=&AA="!U;F1E<B!.97<@66]R:R!,87<@86X@07-S96UB;'D@:7,@82!M965T
M:6YG(&]F('1H92!M96UB97)S#0IC86QL960@9F]R('-P96-I9FEC(')E87-O
M;G,L(&%N9"!M=7-T(&)E(&-O;7!R:7-E9"!O9B!M96UB97)S+B`@4VEN8V4-
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M"@T*#0I,>6QE(%-M:71H#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*/B!,>6QE+`T*/@T*/B`@("`@
M("!)('5N9&5R<W1A;F0@>6]U(&-A;B!H96QP(&UE('=I=&@@<V]M92!R=6QE
M<RX@($D@8VAA:7(@4#$V,#`N,0T*/B!3=&%N9&%R9"!5<'!E<B!/;G1O;&]G
M>2`H4U5/*2!71RP@:'1T<#HO+W-U;RYI965E+F]R9RX@($AE<F4@87)E('1H
M90T*<V%L:65N=`T*/B!F86-T<R!A;F0@<&]S=&EN9W,N#0H^#0H^("`@(&$N
M(%-53R!71R!C;VYD=6-T960@86X@96UA:6P@8F%L;&]T(&]F('=H971H97(@
M82!D;V-U;65N="!S:&]U;&0-"F)E8V]M92!A#0H^(&)A<V4@9&]C=6UE;G0N
M("!4:&4@8F%L;&]T('=A<R!O<&5N(&9O<B`S+7=E96MS+B!)="!P87-S960@
M,3<M,38L('=I=&@@.0T*/B!!0E-404E.4RX-"@T*#0I!;G-W97(Z("!.97<@
M66]R:R!.;W0M9F]R+5!R;V9I="!,87<@86YD('1H92!)145%($)Y;&%W<R!S
M=&%T92!T:&%T('1O('!A<W,-"F$@;6]T:6]N#0IR97%U:7)E<R!A(&UA:F]R
M:71Y(&]F('1H;W-E('!R97-E;G0L(&%N9"!N;W0@82!M86IO<FET>2!O9B!T
M:&]S92!P<F5S96YT#0IA;F0@=F]T:6YG+B`@268@-#(@=F]T:6YG(&UE;6)E
M<G,@=V5R92!I;G9O;'9E9"P@=&AE;B!A(&UA:F]R:71Y(&]F(#(R+B!W87,-
M"@T*<F5Q=6ER960@9F]R('!A<W-A9V4@;V8@=&AE(&UO=&EO;BP@86YD('1H
M97)E9F]R92!T:&4@;6]T:6]N(&9A:6QE9"X-"CX-"CX@("`@8BX@22!A;FYO
M=6YC960@=&AE(')E<W5L=',@;VX@075G(#$V=&@L('1H96X@='=O('!E;W!L
M92`H=VAO(&AA9"!V;W1E9`T*#0IT;PT*/B!!0E-404E.*2!S86ED('1H97D@
M=V%N=&5D('1O(&-H86YG92!T:&5I<B!V;W1E<R!T;R!.3RX-"@T*#0I!;G-W
M97(Z(%EO=2!D;R!N;W0@<V%Y(&5X86-T;'D@=VAA="!W87,@86YN;W5N8V5D
M+"!B=70@:70@<VAO=6QD(&AA=F4@8F5E;@T*=&AA="!T:&4-"G9O=&4@9F%I
M;&5D+"!D=64@=&\@82!L86-K(&]F(&$@;6%J;W)I='DN#0H^#0H^("`@(&,N
M($)O8B!3<&EL;&5R<RP@82!354\@=F]T:6YG(&UE;6)E<BP@;6%D92!A(&UO
M=&EO;B!T;R!R96-O;G-I9&5R+B`@270-"@T*/B!A<G)I=F5D(&%T(#$R.C`W
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M12!";V%R9"!O9@T*1&ER96-T;W)S('-H;W5L9`T*8VQA<FEF>2!W:&%T('1H
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M(%)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S+`T*#0IW92!B96QI979E('1H870@82!C97)T86EN
M(&%M;W5N="!O9B!F;&5X:6)I;&ET>2!S:&]U;&0@8F4@=7-E9"!I;B!A;B!E
M9F9O<G0-"@T*=&\@86-H:79E(&%N(&5Q=6%T:6)L92!R97-U;'0N/@T*#0H-
M"CX@("`@9"X@0F]B(%-P:6QL97)S(&]R:6=I;F%L;'D@=F]T960@3D\N("!)
M<R!H92!P97)M:71T960@=&\@;6%K92!A(&UO=&EO;@T*#0IT;PT*/B!R96-O
M;G-I9&5R/R`@268@;F]T+"!D;V5S('1H:7,@<V5T=&QE<R!T:&4@;6%T=&5R
M/R`@2&4@8VQA:6US(&AE(&-A;B!I9@T*4U5/#0H^(&ES(&-O;G-I9&5R960@
M82`G4W1A;F1I;F<@0V]M;6ET=&5E+"<@8G5T(&EN9&EC871E<R!H92!C86XG
M="!I9B!354\@:7,@86X-"@T*/B!!<W-E;6)L>2X@(%=H96X@22!F;W5N9"!H
M:7,@;6]T:6]N(&]U="!O9B!O<F1E<BP@22!A<W-E<G1E9"!354\@=V%S(&%N
M#0H^($%S<V5M8FQY+@T*#0H-"D%N<W=E<CH@665S+"!S:6YC92!H92!W87,@
M86-T=6%L;'D@82!M96UB97(@;V8@=&AE('!R979A:6QI;F<L(&]R(&EN('1H
M:7,-"F-A<V4@=&AE#0IL;W-I;F<@<VED92X-"CX-"CX@("`@(&8N($AE('1H
M96X@87!P96%L960@;7D@<G5L:6YG('1O('1H92!354\@;65M8F5R<VAI<"!A
M;F0@:70@=V%S#0IS96-O;F1E9`T*/B!B>2!,964@075S<&ET>BX@0V%N(&AE
M(&%P<&5A;"!S;VUE=&AI;F<@;&EK92!T:&ES/PT*#0H-"D%N<W=E<CH@665S
M+"!A;GD@;65M8F5R(&]F(&$@8V]M;6ET=&5E(&UA>2!A<'!E86P@82!R=6QI
M;F<@;V8@=&AE($-H86ER+@T*#0H-"@T*#0H-"CX@66]U<B!T:6UE;'D@9W5I
M9&%N8V4@=V]U;&0@8F4@;6]S="!A<'!R96-I871E9"X-"CX-"CX@2FEM(%-C
M:&]E;FEN9PT*/B`W,S(M-3,R+34X,3(-"CX-"@T*#0H-"@T*#0I,>6QE($TN
M(%-M:71H#0I3=&%F9B!$:7)E8W1O<B`M($-O<G!O<F%T92!!8W1I=FET:65S
6#0HW,S(@.3@Q+3,T-#<-"@T*#0H-"@==
`
end
begin 600 Attach 5 - Teknowledge Legal Opinion.txt
M#0H-"@T*#0I*86YU87)Y(#$U+"`R,#`R#0H-"@T*#0I!9&%M(%!E87-E#0I4
M96MN;W=L961G92!#;W)P;W)A=&EO;@T*,3@Q,"!%;6)A<F-A9&5R;R!2;V%D
M#0I086QO($%L=&\L($-!("`Y-#,P,PT*#0I213H@($UE;6]R86YD=6T@;VX@
M245%12!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(%9O=&4-"@T*1&5A<B!!9&%M.@T*#0I4:&4@
M<75E<W1I;VX@<')E<V5N=&5D(&ES('=H971H97(@82!V;W1E('1A:V5N(&EN
M(&-O;FYE8W1I;VX@=VET:"!A;B!E+6UA:6P@8F%L;&]T(`T*8V]N9'5C=&5D
M(&)Y('1H92!0,38P,"XQ(%-T86YD87)D(%5P<&5R($]N=&]L;V=Y(%=O<FMI
M;F<@1W)O=7`@*'1H92`B5V]R:VEN9R`-"D=R;W5P(BD@=&\@9&5T97)M:6YE
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M<"!F<F]M('1H92`-"G-U<&5R:6]R(&5N=&ET:65S('=I=&AI;B!T:&4@245%
M12!A;F0@=6QT:6UA=&5L>2!T:&4@4W1A=&4@;V8@3F5W(%EO<FLN("`-"@T*
M0F]T=&]M(%5P#0H-"E1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(')E<&]R=',@=&\@0V]M
M<'5T97(@4V]C:65T>2`O(%-T86YD87)D<R!#;V]R9&EN871I;F<@0V]M;6ET
M=&5E(`T**'1H92`B4W!O;G-O<B(I+B`@5&AE(%-P;VYS;W(@<F5P;W)T<R!T
M;R!T:&4@4W1A;F1A<F1S($%C=&EV:71Y($)O87)D(&]F('1H92!)145%(`T*
M0V]M<'5T97(@4V]C:65T>2`H=&AE(")-:6YO<B!";V%R9"(I+B`@5&AE($UI
M;F]R($)O87)D(')E<&]R=',@=&\@=&AE($-O;7!U=&5R(`T*4V]C:65T>2!"
M;V%R9"!O9B!';W9E<FYO<G,@*'1H92`B4V]C:65T>2(I+B`@5&AE(%-O8VEE
M='D@<F5P;W)T<R!T;R!T:&4@4W1A;F1A<F1S(`T*07-S;V-I871I;VX@*'1H
M92`B36%J;W(@0F]A<F0B*2X@(%1H92!-86IO<B!";V%R9"!R97!O<G1S('1O
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M97,L('=H:6-H(`T*<')O=FED97,@82!P<F]V:7-I;VX@<')E8V5D96YC92!O
M9B!D;V-U;65N=',@=&\@=7-E9"!I;B!T:&4@:6YT97)P<F5T871I;VX@;V8@
M<')O=FES:6]N<R`-"F%N9"!T:&4@<F5S;VQU=&EO;B!O9B!C;VYF;&EC=',@
M8F5T=V5E;B!I;F-O;G-I<W1E;G0@<')O=FES:6]N<RX@(%1H92!P<F5C961E
M;F-E(&]F(`T*9&]C=6UE;G1S('=I;&P@<')O=FED92!T:&4@<F]A9&UA<"!F
M;W(@=&AE(')E=FEE=R!A="!H86YD+@T*#0I3<&5C:69I8V%L;'DL('1H92!3
M=&%N9&%R9',@06-T:79I=&EE<R!";V%R9"!0;VQI8VEE<R!A;F0@4')O8V5D
M=7)E<RP@4V5C=&EO;B`R('!R;W9I9&5S.B`-"DEN('1H92!E=F5N="!O9B!I
M;F-O;G-I<W1E;F-I97,@8F5T=V5E;B!T=V\@;W(@;6]R92!O9B!T:&4@86)O
M=F4@9&]C=6UE;G1S+"!T:&4@#0ID;V-U;65N="`H:6YD:6-A=&5D(&)Y(&5A
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M4')O8V5D=7)E<R!-86YU86PL(%-E8W1I;VX@.`T*-BX)245%12!";V%R9"!O
M9B!$:7)E8W1O<G,@4F5S;VQU=&EO;G,-"C<N"4E%144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S
M($)O87)D(&]F($]P97)A=&EO;G,@36%N=6%L#0HX+@E)145%($-3($-O;G-T
M:71U=&EO;B!A;F0@0GEL87=S#0HY+@E)145%($-3(%!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!0
M<F]C961U<F5S+"!396-T:6]N(#$Q#0HQ,"X)245%12!";V%R9"!O9B!';W9E
M<FYO<G,@4F5S;VQU=&EO;G,-"C$Q+@E)145%($-3(%-!0B!0)E`-"C$R+@E2
M;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<@T*,3,N"5-P;VYS;W(@4&]L:6-I97,@
M86YD(%!R;V-E9'5R97,-"C$T+@E7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(&]R(%-T=61Y($=R
M;W5P(%!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!0<F]C961U<F5S#0H-"DEN('1H92!I;G-T86YT
M('-I='5A=&EO;BP@<V5V97)A;"!A9&1I=&EO;F%L(&ET96US(&%R92!A<'!L
M:6-A8FQE('1H870@87)E(&YO="!L:7-T960L(&%N9"`-"G-E=F5R86P@;&ES
M=&5D(&ET96US(&%R92!I;F%P<&QI8V%B;&4N("`@1F]R(&EN<W1A;F-E+"!T
M:&4@245%12!">6QA=W,@<F5C96EV92!T:&5I<B`-"F%U=&AO<FET>2!F<F]M
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M<R!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R`H:71E;2`-"C$S*2!I;B!T:&ES(&-A<V4@<F5F
M97)S('1O($-O;7!U=&5R(%-O8VEE='D@4&]L:6-I97,@86YD(%!R;V-E9'5R
M97,L(&%N9"!T;R!T:&4@97AT96YT('1H870@#0IT:&5Y(')E9F5R96YC92!3
M96-T:6]N(#$Q+"!A<F4@<F5D=6YD86YT('=I=&@@:71E;2`Y+B`@0V]N<V5Q
M=65N=&QY+"!S:6YC92!T:&ES(&%N86QY<VES(`T*;VYL>2!R969E<G,@=&\@
M=&AE(')E;&5V86YT(%-E8W1I;VX@,3$L(&ET96T@,3,@=VEL;"!B92!D96QE
M=&5D(&%N9"!I=&5M(#D@=VEL;"!R971A:6X@:71S(`T*;W)D97(@;V8@<')E
M8V5D96YC92X@($%D9&ET:6]N86QL>2P@;F\@245%12!";V%R9"!O9B!';W9E
M<FYO<G,@4F5S;VQU=&EO;G,@;W(@245%12`-"D)O87)D(&]F($1I<F5C=&]R
M<R!297-O;'5T:6]N<R!P97)T86EN('1O('1H92!I<W-U92!A="!H86YD+"!A
M;F0@8V]N<V5Q=65N=&QY('=I;&P@;F]T(&)E(`T*:6YC;'5D960@:6X@=&AI
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M,"X)245%12!#4R!0;VQI8VEE<R!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<RP@4V5C=&EO;B`Q
M,0T*,3$N"4E%144@0U,@4T%"(%`F4`T*,3(N"5)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F
M($]R9&5R#0H-"E-O+"!W;W)K:6YG(&9R;VT@=&AE(&)O='1O;2!U<"P@=V4@
M;&]O:R!A="!2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<BX@(%)O8F5R="=S(%)U
M;&5S(&]F(`T*3W)D97(@8V]N=&%I;G,@<')O=FES:6]N<R!T:&%T(&1E=&5R
M;6EN92!H;W<@=&\@9&5T97)M:6YE('=H870@8V]N<W1I='5T97,@82!M86IO
M<FET>2`-"G9O=&4N("!#;VYS97%U96YT;'DL(&)Y('1H92!A=71H;W)I='D@
M9W)A;G1E9"!I;B!T:&4@245%12!#4R!304(@4"90+"!T:&ES('!R;W9I<VEO
M;B`-"G=O=6QD('!R979A:6PN#0H-"DYE>'0L('=E(&QO;VL@870@=&AE($E%
M144@0U,@4T%"(%`F4"!T;R!D971E<FUI;F4@:68@=&AE<F4@:7,@86YY=&AI
M;F<@8V]N=')A9&EC=&]R>2X-"E-E8W1I;VX@,2XQ('-T871E<R!T:&4@<'5R
M<&]S92!O9B!T:&4@4T%".@T*(E-T86YD87)D<R!D979E;&]P;65N="!A8W1I
M=FET:65S(&EN('1H92!)145%($-3(&%R92!T:&4@<F5S<&]N<VEB:6QI='D@
M;V8@=&AE(`T*4T%"(&%N9"!C;VUP;'D@=VET:"!T:&4@<&]L:6-I97,@86YD
M('!R;V-E9'5R97,@;V8@=&AE(&1O8W5M96YT<R!L:7-T960@8F5L;W<N("`-
M"D%D9&ET:6]N86P@<&]L:6-I97,@86YD('!R;V-E9'5R97,L('=H96X@;F5C
M97-S87)Y+"!A<F4@9&5F:6YE9"!I;B!T:&ES(`T*9&]C=6UE;G0N(@T*#0I#
M;VYS97%U96YT;'DL(&)Y('1H92!A=71H;W)I='D@;V8@=&AE($-O;7!U=&5R
M(%-O8VEE='DL('1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@06-T:79I='D@0F]A<F0@:7,@#0IC
M:&%R9V5D('=I=&@@=&AE(')E<W!O;G-I8FEL:71Y(&]F(&5N<W5R:6YG('1H
M870@=&AE(%=O<FMI;F<@1W)O=7`@9F]L;&]W<RP@86UO;F<@;W1H97(@#0II
M=&5M<RP@86YD(&YO='=I=&AS=&%N9&EN9R!A;GD@9&ER96-T:6]N('1O('1H
M92!C;VYT<F%R>2!I;B!A(&1O8W5M96YT(&]F(&AI9VAE<B`-"G!R96-E9&5N
M8V4L(%)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F($]R9&5R(&EN(&ET<R!D979E;&]P;65N
M="!O9B!T:&4@9')A9G0@<W1A;F1A<F0N#0H-"E1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@0V]M
M;6ET=&5E($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R!A<F4@;W5T;&EN
M960@:6X@4V5C=&EO;B`T(&%S(`T*9F]L;&]W<SH-"C0N,"!#4R!3=&%N9&%R
M9',@0V]M;6ET=&5E($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<PT*-"XQ
M($]V97)V:65W#0I4:&4@245%12!S=&%N9&%R9',@9&5V96QO<&UE;G0@<')O
M8V5S<R!I;F-L=61E<R!T=V\@=F]L=6YT965R(&=R;W5P<SH@(`T*82!3<&]N
M<V]R+"!W:&\@<W5P97)V:7-E<R!A;&P@<&AA<V5S(&]F('1H92!D979E;&]P
M;65N="!A;F0@;6%I;G1E;F%N8V4@#0IO9B!A('-T86YD87)D+"!A;F0@82!S
M=&%N9&%R9',@9&5V96QO<&EN9R!C;VUM:71T964@<W5C:"!A<R!A(%='(&]R
M(%-'+"`-"G=H:6-H(&ES(')E<W!O;G-I8FQE('1O('1H92!3<&]N<V]R+"!A
M;F0@=VAI8V@@9&5V96QO<',@=&AE(&1R869T(`T*<W1A;F1A<F0N("!!(&1R
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M97)S:&EP+@T*#0I4:&5R969O<F4L('5N9&5R('1H92!)145%(%-!0B!0)E`L
M('1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(&%N9"!T:&4@4W!O;G-O<B!A<F4@9&ER96-T
M960@=&\@#0IF;VQL;W<@4F]B97)T)W,@4G5L97,@;V8@3W)D97(L('=I=&@@
M=&AE('!R;W9I<V\@=&AA="!A('%U;W)U;2!S:&%L;"!C;VYS:7-T(&]F(&]N
M92UH86QF(`T*;V8@=&AE('9O=&EN9R!M96UB97)S:&EP+@T*#0I4:&4@4W1A
M;F1A<F1S($%C=&EV:71I97,@0F]A<F0@<F5F97)E;F-E<R!I=',@875T:&]R
M:71Y('1O('-O(&1I<F5C="!I;B!396-T:6]N(#4@;V8@=&AE(`T*245%12!3
M04(@4"90.@T*-2XR("!297-P;VYS:6)I;&ET:65S(&]F('1H92!304(-"D%S
M(&5S=&%B;&ES:&5D(&EN(%-E8W1I;VX@,2!O9B!!<G1I8VQE(%A)(&]F('1H
M92!)145%($-3($-O;G-T:71U=&EO;B!A;F0@#0I">6QA=W,@6U)E9BX@-ETL
M('1H92!304(@:7,@<F5S<&]N<VEB;&4@9F]R.B`@<F5C;VUM96YD:6YG('1O
M('1H92!#4R`-"D)O87)D(&]F($=O=F5R;F]R<R!A;&P@<&]L:6-I97,@86YD
M('!R86-T:6-E<R!W:71H(')E<W!E8W0@=&\@<W1A;F1A<F1S.R`-"F]V97)S
M:6=H="!R97-P;VYS:6)I;&ET>2!F;W(@86QL('-T86YD87)D<R!A8W1I=FET
M:65S('1O(&%S<W5R92!C;VYF;W)M86YC92`-"G1O(&%P<')O=F5D('!O;&EC
M:65S(&%N9"!P<F]C961U<F5S.R!A;F0@=&\@<')O=FED92!G=6ED86YC92!A
M;F0@#0IR97-O;'5T:6]N(&]F(&ES<W5E<R!I;B!A<F5A<R!N;W0@<W!E8VEF
M:6-A;&QY(&-O=F5R960@8GD@=&AE('!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"`-"G!R;V-E9'5R
M97,N("`-"@T*4W!E8VEF:6-A;&QY+"!W:71H(')E9V%R9"!T;R!3<&]N<V]R
M<SH-"C8N,2`@4W!O;G-O<B!38V]P90T*16%C:"!3<&]N<V]R('-H86QL(&AA
M=F4@82!S8V]P92!A<'!R;W9E9"!B>2!T:&4@4T%"+@T*-BXR(%-T86YD87)D
M<R!$979E;&]P;65N="!0<F]C97-S(%M);F9O<FUA=&EV95T-"E1H92!3=&%N
M9&%R9',@1&5V96QO<&UE;G0@4')O8V5S<R!S:&]U;&0@;F]R;6%L;'D@8V]N
M<VES="!O9CH@(&]P=&EO;F%L(`T*4T<@;W!E<F%T:6]N(&YO="!T;R!E>&-E
M960@<VEX("@V*2!M;VYT:',[(%!!4B!A<'!R;W9A;"!B>2!T:&4@4W!O;G-O
M<CL@#0I005(@87!P<F]V86P@8GD@=&AE($E%15-".R!71R!D979E;&]P;65N
M="!O9B!A(&1R869T('-T86YD87)D.R`-"F%P<')O=F%L('1O(&)A;&QO="!B
M>2!T:&4@4W!O;G-O<CL@<F5C:7)C=6QA=&EO;B]N96=A=&EV92!B86QL;W0@
M<F5S;VQU=&EO;B`-"F)Y('1H92!71R!A<R!N96-E<W-A<GD[(%)E=D-O;2!S
M=6)M:7-S:6]N(&%P<')O=F%L(&)Y('1H92!3<&]N<V]R.R`-"F%N9"!S=&%N
M9&%R9"!A<'!R;W9A;"!B>2!T:&4@245%15-"+@T*#0I4:&4@;VYL>2!D:7)E
M8W0@<F5F97)E;F-E('1O(%=O<FMI;F<@1W)O=7`@4')O8V5D=7)E<R!A<F4@
M9F]U;F0@:6X@4V5C=&EO;B`W+"!A;F0@;VYL>2`-"G!E<G1A:6X@=&\@=&AE
M(&9A8W0@=&AA="!T:&4@0VAA:7(L(&%N9"!6:6-E+4-H86ER(&]F(%=O<FMI
M;F<@1W)O=7!S('-H86QL(&)E($E%144@;W(@#0I#4RUA9F9I;&EA=&4@;65M
M8F5R<RX-"@T*26X@9F]L;&]W:6YG('1H92!R;V%D;6%P(&QA:60@;W5T(&EN
M('1H92!)145%($-3(%-!0B!0)E`L('=E(&YE>'0@;&]O:R!A="!396-T:6]N
M(#$Q(`T*;V8@=&AE($E%144@0U,@4&]L:6-I97,@86YD(%!R;V-E9'5R97,N
M("!4:&ES('-E8W1I;VX@;W5T;&EN97,@=&AE('!R;V-E9'5R97,@8GD@=VAI
M8V@@#0ID<F%F="!S=&%N9&%R9',@9&5V96QO<&5D('=I=&AI;B!T:&4@0V]M
M<'5T97(@4V]C:65T>2!A<F4@<W5B;6ET=&5D('1O('1H92!)145%(`T*4W1A
M;F1A<F1S($)O87)D+"!I;B!O<F1E<B!T;R!B92!A<'!R;W9E9"P@861O<'1E
M9"!A;F0@<'5B;&ES:&5D(&%S($E%144@4W1A;F1A<F1S+B`@#0I4:&ES(%-E
M8W1I;VX@9G5R=&AE<B!S=&%T97,@=&AA="!A<R!F87(@87,@=&AE(')E;&%T
M:6]N<VAI<"!O9B!T:&4@0V]M<'5T97(@4V]C:65T>2!T;R!)145%(`T*4W1A
M;F1A<F1S($)O87)D(&ES(&-O;F-E<FYE9"P@=&AE('!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!P
M<F]C961U<F5S(&]F(%-E8W1I;VX@,3$@87,@97-T86)L:7-H960@8GD@#0IT
M:&4@4T%"(&]P97)A=&4@=VET:&EN('1H92!S8V]P92!O9B!T:&4@245%12!"
M>6QA=W,N#0H-"E1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@06-T:79I=&EE<R!";V%R9"!C;&%I
M;2!O9B!A=71H;W)I='D@:6X@4V5C=&EO;B`U(&]F('1H92!)145%(%-!0B!0
M)E`@:7,@#0IC;VYF:7)M960@:6X@07)T:6-L92!8(&]F('1H92!#;VUP=71E
M<B!3;V-I971Y($)Y;&%W<R!W:&EC:"!T:&%T.@T*(E1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@
M06-T:79I=&EE<R!";V%R9"!S:&%L;"!F;W)M=6QA=&4@=&AE('!O;&EC:65S
M(&%N9"!P<F%C=&EC97,@=VET:"`-"G)E<W!E8W0@=&\@<W1A;F1A<F1S+"!A
M;F0@;6]N:71O<B!A;&P@<W1A;F1A<F1S(&%C=&EV:71I97,@=&\@87-S=7)E
M(&-O;F9O<FUA;F-E('1O(`T*87!P<F]V960@<&]L:6-I97,@86YD('!R86-T
M:6-E<RXB#0H-"E1H92!#;VUP=71E<B!3;V-I971Y(&ET<V5L9B!I<R!O<F=A
M;FEZ960@=VET:&EN('1H92!)145%+"!A;F0@:7,@;V)L:6=A=&5D('5N9&5R
M($%R=&EC;&4@#0I)22P@4V5C=&EO;B!O9B!T:&4@0V]M<'5T97(@4V]C:65T
M>2!#;VYS=&ET=71I;VX@=&\@;W!E<F%T92!W:71H:6X@=&AE($E%144@8V]N
M<W1I='5T:6]N(`T*86YD(&)Y;&%W<R!A;F0@=VET:&EN('-U8V@@;W1H97(@
M<&]L:6-I97,@86YD('!R;V-E9'5R97,@=&AA="!A<F4@875T:&]R:7IE9"!U
M;F1E<B!T:&5S92`-"F1O8W5M96YT<RX-"@T*2&%V:6YG(&5S=&%B;&ES:&5D
M('1H92!O<&5R871I;F<@<')O=&]C;VQS(&%T('1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P
M+"!3<&]N<V]R+"!-:6YO<B!";V%R9"`-"F%N9"!3;V-I971Y(&QE=F5L<RP@
M=V4@;6]V92!U<"!T;R!T:&4@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0@;&5V96PL('=H;W-E(&-O
M;G1R;VQL:6YG(&1O8W5M96YT<R`-"F%R92!T:&4@245%12!3=&%N9&%R9',@
M07-S;V-I871I;VX@0GEL87=S+"!)145%(%-T86YD87)D<R!!<W-O8VEA=&EO
M;B!/<&5R871I;VYS(`T*36%N=6%L+"!)145%+5-!(%-T86YD87)D<R!";V%R
M9"!">6QA=W,L(&%N9"!)145%+5-!(%-T86YD87)D<R!";V%R9"!O9B`-"D]P
M97)A=&EO;G,@36%N=6%L+B`@5V4@=VEL;"!A;'-O('1A:V4@82!B<FEE9B!D
M971O=7(@=&\@=&AE(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!L979E;"!W:71H($E%144@#0I0
M;VQI8VEE<R!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R!-86YU86PL(%-E8W1I;VX@.`T*#0I)
M145%+5-!(%-T86YD87)D<R!";V%R9"!O9B!/<&5R871I;VYS($UA;G5A;"!S
M=&%T97,@:6X@4V5C=&EO;B`Q+C(@=&AA="!T:&4@#0IO<F=A;FEZ871I;VX@
M86YD(&)A<VEC('!R;V-E9'5R97,@;V8@=&AE($E%144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S
M($)O87)D(&%R92!C;W9E<F5D(&)Y('1H92`-"DE%144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S
M($)O87)D($)Y;&%W<RP@86YD('1H870@=&AE('!R;W9I<VEO;G,@;V8@=&AE
M($E%144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S(`T*0F]A<F0@;V8@3W!E<F%T:6]N<R!-86YU
M86P@<W5P<&QE;65N="!T:&4@<')O=FES:6]N<R!O9B!T:&4@245%12U302!3
M=&%N9&%R9',@0F]A<F0@#0I">6QA=W,L('=H:6-H('-H86QL(&)E('1H92!P
M<F5V86EL:6YG(&1O8W5M96YT(&EN('1H92!E=F5N="!O9B!C;VYF;&EC="X@
M($QI:V4@=&AE(`T*4V]C:65T>2P@36EN;W(@0F]A<F0L(%-P;VYS;W(L(&%N
M9"!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(&)E;&]W(&ET+"!T:&4@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0@:7,@
M#0ID:7)E8W1E9"!T;R!C;VYD=6-T(&)U<VEN97-S(&EN(&%C8V]R9&%N8V4@
M=VET:"!2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<BX@(`T*#0I396-T:6]N(#4@
M;V8@=&AE($E%144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S($)O87)D(&]F($]P97)A=&EO;G,@
M36%N=6%L(&1I<F5C=',@=&AE(%-P;VYS;W(@=&\@#0IO<&5R871E(&EN(&%C
M8V]R9&%N8V4@=VET:"!A('=R:71T96X@<V5T(&]F('!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!P
M<F]C961U<F5S('=H:6-H(&1O(&YO="!C;VYF;&EC="`-"G=I=&@@=&AE($E%
M144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S($)O87)D($]P97)A=&EO;G,@36%N=6%L+B`@26X@
M=&AE(&-A<V4@;V8@82!3<&]N<V]R('1H870@:7,@82`-"F-O;6UI='1E92!O
M9B!A;B!)145%(%-O8VEE='DL('1H92!3;V-I971Y(&UA>2!D979E;&]P(&$@
M8V]M;6]N('-E="!O9B!0("8@4"!F;W(@#0IS=&%N9&%R9',@9&5V96QO<&UE
M;G0@=&AA="!I<R!A<'!L:6-A8FQE('1O(&%L;"!3<&]N<V]R<R!I;B!T:&%T
M(%-O8VEE='DN("!);B!T:&4@:6YS=&%N="`-"F-A<V4L('1H92!3<&]N<V]R
M(&ES('1H92!#;VUP=71E<B!3;V-I971Y("\@4W1A;F1A<F1S($-O;W)D:6YA
M=&EN9R!#;VUM:71T964@;W!E<F%T:6YG(`T*=6YD97(@=&AE($UI;F]R($)O
M87)D(&%N9"!3;V-I971Y(%!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!0<F]C961U<F5S+@T*#0I"
M969O<F4@;6]V:6YG(&]N('1O('1H92!R96UA:6YI;F<@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0@
M9&]C=6UE;G1S+"!W92!A<F4@9&ER96-T960@8GD@=&AE(`T*<')E8V5D96YC
M92!O9B!D;V-U;65N=',@=&\@<F5V:65W(&%N($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!D;V-U
M;65N="P@<W!E8VEF:6-A;&QY(%-E8W1I;VX@."!O9B`-"G1H92!)145%(%!O
M;&EC>2!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R!-86YU86PN("!4:&ES('!R;W9I<VEO;B!P
M<F]V:61E<R!T:&%T(')E<W!O;G-I8FEL:71Y(&9O<B`-"G1H92!S=&%N9&%R
M9&EZ871I;VX@86-T:79I=&EE<R!O9B!)145%(&ES(&%S<VEG;F5D(&)Y('1H
M92!";V%R9"!O9B!$:7)E8W1O<G,@=&\@=&AE(`T*4W1A;F1A<F1S($%S<V]C
M:6%T:6]N+"!O<B!W:&%T('=E(&%R92!R969E<G)I;F<@=&\@87,@=&AE($UA
M:F]R($)O87)D+B`@4W!E8VEF:6-A;&QY+"!T:&4@#0I3=&%N9&%R9',@07-S
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M=&EO;G,@;6%N=6%L<R!O9B!I=',@<W5B<VED:6%R>2!B;V%R9',@86YD(`T*
M8V]M;6ET=&5E<RXB#0H-"D1E=&%I;&5D('!R;V-E9'5R97,@87)E(&9U<G1H
M97(@;W5T;&EN960@:6X@4V5C=&EO;B`X+C0Z#0HB1&5T86EL960@<')O8V5D
M=7)E<R!A;F0@<F5Q=6ER96UE;G1S(&9O<B!S=&%N9&%R9',@86-T:79I=&EE
M<R!W:71H:6X@=&AE($E%144@#0IA<F4@<V5T(&9O<G1H(&EN('1H92!)145%
M(%-T86YD87)D<R!!<W-O8VEA=&EO;B!B>6QA=W,@86YD(&]P97)A=&EO;G,@
M;6%N=6%L<R`-"F%N9"!T:&4@8GEL87=S(&%N9"!O<&5R871I;VYS(&UA;G5A
M;',@;V8@:71S('-U8G-I9&EA<GD@8F]A<F1S(&%N9"`-"F-O;6UI='1E97.%
M(@T*#0I2971U<FYI;F<@=&\@=&AE($UA:F]R($)O87)D(&1O8W5M96YT<RP@
M=&AE(%-!(%-T86YD87)D<R!";V%R9"!">6QA=W,@9&]N)W0@<')O=FED92`-
M"F%N>2!P87)T:6-U;&%R(&1I<F5C=&EO;B!T;R!T:&4@:7-S=64@870@:&%N
M9"P@;W1H97(@=&AA;B!C;&%I;6EN9R!T:&5I<B!A=71H;W)I='D@=6YD97(@
M#0IS96-T:6]N(%,M-#`Q(&]F('1H92!)145%($)Y;&%W<RX-"@T*5&AE(%-T
M86YD87)D<R!!<W-O8VEA=&EO;B!/<&5R871I;VYS($UA;G5A;"!A<W-E<G1S
M('1H870@=&AE(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!A;F0@8F%S:6,@#0IP;VQI8VEE<R!O
M9B!T:&4@245%12!3=&%N9&%R9',@07-S;V-I871I;VX@87)E(&-O=F5R960@
M8GD@=&AE($E%144@4W1A;F1A<F1S(`T*07-S;V-I871I;VX@0GEL87=S+"!A
M;F0@=&AA="!T:&4@4W1A;F1A<F1S($%S<V]C:6%T:6]N($]P97)A=&EO;G,@
M36%N=6%L('-U<'!L96UE;G1S(`T*=&AE('!R;W9I<VEO;G,@;V8@=&AE($E%
M144@4W1A;F1A<F1S($%S<V]C:6%T:6]N($)Y;&%W<RP@=VAI8V@@:7,@=&AE
M(&=O=F5R;FEN9R`-"F1O8W5M96YT(&EN('1H92!E=F5N="!O9B!C;VYF;&EC
M="X@($QI:V4@=&AE(%-O8VEE='DL($UI;F]R($)O87)D+"!3<&]N<V]R+"!A
M;F0@5V]R:VEN9R`-"D=R;W5P(&)E;&]W(&ET+"!T:&4@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0@
M:7,@86=A:6X@9&ER96-T960@=&\@8V]N9'5C="!B=7-I;F5S<R!I;B!A8V-O
M<F1A;F-E('=I=&@@#0I2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<B!U;F1E<B!3
M96-T:6]N(#0N,RX@(`T*#0I4:&4@9FEN86P@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0@9&]C=6UE
M;G0L('1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@07-S;V-I871I;VX@0GEL87=S+"!C;&%I;7,@
M:71S(&%U=&AO<FET>2`-"F9R;VT@245%12!">6QA=R!)+3,P-"XV(&%N9"!E
M<W1A8FQI<VAE<R!T:&%T('1H92!)145%(%-T86YD87)D<R!!<W-O8VEA=&EO
M;B!S:&%L;"!B92`-"F1I<F5C=&5D(&)Y(&$@0F]A<F0@;V8@1V]V97)N;W)S
M+"!W:&\@<VAA;&P@8F4@<F5S<&]N<VEB;&4@9F]R(&5S=&%B;&ES:&EN9R!P
M;VQI8WD@86YD(`T*8V]N9'5C="!S=&%N9&%R9',M<F5L871E9"!A8W1I=FET
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M:6]N($DM,3`W(&1E9FEN97,@86X@#0I)145%(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;F%L('5N
M:70@:7,@82!S=6)S970@;V8@=&AE(&5N=&ER92!)145%(&UE;6)E<G-H:7`@
M=&AA="!H87,@8F5E;B!F;W)M960@#0IT;R!C87)R>2!O=70@<&%R=&EC=6QA
M<B!E9'5C871I;VYA;"P@9V5O9W)A<&AI8RP@<')O9F5S<VEO;F%L+"!T96-H
M;FEC86PL(&]R(&]T:&5R(`T*87!P<F]P<FEA=&4@86-T:79I=&EE<R!O9B!I
M;G1E<F5S="!A;F0@<V5R=FEC92!T;R!T:&]S92!W:&\@87)E(&UE;6)E<G,@
M;V8@=&AA="`-"F]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;F%L('5N:70@87,@<&5R;6ET=&5D(&)Y
M(&QA=RX-"@T*4V5C=&EO;B!)+3,P,"P@<W5B<V5C=&EO;B`S(&]F('1H92!)
M145%($)Y;&%W<R!C;W9E<FEN9R!';W9E<FYA;F-E(&%N9"!087)L:6%M96YT
M87)Y(`T*4')O8V5D=7)E<R!S=&%T97,@=&AA=#H@(`T*(DEM<&QE;65N=&%T
M:6]N(&]F('1H92!C;VYS=&ET=71I;VYA;"!P<F]V:7-I;VYS(&)Y('-P96-I
M9FEC(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;F%L('5N:71S(`T*86YD('1H96ER('!O;&EC:65S
M+"!I<R!C;VYT86EN960@:6X@=&AE<V4@245%12!">6QA=W,L('=H:6-H(&%R
M92!A<'!R;W9E9"!A;F0@#0IA;65N9&5D(&)Y('1H92!)145%($)O87)D(&]F
M($1I<F5C=&]R<RX@(%1H92!)145%(%!O;&EC>2!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R`-
M"DUA;G5A;"!C;VYT86EN<R!M;W)E(&1E=&%I;&5D('-T871E;65N=',@;V8@
M<W!E8VEF:6,@<&]L:6-I97,L(&]B:F5C=&EV97,@86YD(`T*<')O8V5D=7)E
M<R!W:&EC:"!M87D@8F4@87!P<F]V960@;VYL>2!B>2!T:&4@245%12!";V%R
M9"!O9B!$:7)E8W1O<G,N#0H-"E)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F($]R9&5R("AL
M871E<W0@<F5V:7-I;VXI('-H86QL(&)E('5S960@=&\@8V]N9'5C="!B=7-I
M;F5S<R!A="`-"FUE971I;F=S(&]F('1H92!)145%($)O87)D(&]F($1I<F5C
M=&]R<RP@17AE8W5T:79E($-O;6UI='1E92P@36%J;W(@0F]A<F1S+"`-"E-T
M86YD:6YG($-O;6UI='1E97,@86YD(&]T:&5R(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;F%L('5N
M:71S(&]F('1H92!)145%('5N;&5S<R!O=&AE<B`-"G)U;&5S(&]F('!R;V-E
M9'5R92!A<F4@<W!E8VEF:65D(&EN('1H92!.;W0M1F]R+5!R;V9I="!#;W)P
M;W)A=&EO;B!,87<@;V8@=&AE(`T*4W1A=&4@;V8@3F5W(%EO<FLL('1H92!)
M145%($-E<G1I9FEC871E(&]F($EN8V]R<&]R871I;VXL('1H92!)145%($-O
M;G-T:71U=&EO;BP@#0IT:&5S92!">6QA=W,L('1H92!)145%(%!O;&EC>2!A
M;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R!-86YU86PL(')E<V]L=71I;VYS(&]F('1H92!)145%
M(`T*0F]A<F0@;V8@1&ER96-T;W)S+"!O<B!T:&4@87!P;&EC86)L92!G;W9E
M<FYI;F<@9&]C=6UE;G1S(&]F('1H;W-E(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;F%L(`T*=6YI
M=',@<')O=FED960@<W5C:"!O<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!D;V-U;65N=',@87)E
M(&YO="!I;B!C;VYF;&EC="!W:71H(&%N>2!O9B!T:&4@#0IF;W)E9V]I;F<N
M(@T*#0I!9G1E<B!H879I;F<@<W=A;2!U<'-T<F5A;2!T:')O=6=H('1H92!-
M:6YO<B!";V%R9"P@4V]C:65T>2P@86YD($UA:F]R($)O87)D(`T*9&]C=6UE
M;G1S+"!W92!H879E(')E86-H960@82!P<F]V:7-I;VX@=&AA="!S<&5C:69I
M97,@=VAE;B!T:&4@=7-E(&]F(%)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F(`T*3W)D97(@
M<VAA;&P@;F]T(&)E('5S960@=&\@8V]N9'5C="!B=7-I;F5S<R!A="!A;B!O
M<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!U;FET(&]F('1H92!)145%+"!T:&%T(`T*8F5I;F<@
M=VAE;B!O=&AE<B!R=6QE<R!O9B!P<F]C961U<F4@87)E('-P96-I9FEE9"!I
M;B!T:&4@9&]C=6UE;G1S(')E9F5R96YC960@:6X@=&AE(`T*<')E8V5D96YC
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M:7,@4V5C=&EO;B!)+3,P,"P@<W5B<V5C=&EO;B`T(')E9V%R9&EN9R!T:&4@
M86-T:6]N(&]F(`T*=&AE($)O87)D(&]F($1I<F5C=&]R<R!A;F0@0V]M;6ET
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M;V8@=&AE(&UE;6)E<G,@<')E<V5N="`-"F%N9"!E;G1I=&QE9"!T;R!V;W1E
M+"!A="!T:&4@=&EM92!O9B!T:&4@=F]T92P@<')O=FED960@82!Q=6]R=6T@
M:7,@<')E<V5N="P@<VAA;&P@#0IB92!T:&4@86-T(&]F('1H92!";V%R9"!O
M9B!$:7)E8W1O<G,L(&%N>2!#;VUM:71T964@=&AE<F5O9BP@;W(@=&AE($UA
M:F]R(`T*0F]A<F0L(&]R(&%N>2!C;VUM:71T965S(&]F('1H92!F;W)G;VEN
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M=&EO;B!O<B!.97<@66]R:R!.;W0M9F]R+5!R;V9I="!#;W)P;W)A=&EO;B`-
M"DQA=RX-"@T*5&AE(')E;6%I;FEN9R!/<F=A;FEZ871I;VX@9&]C=6UE;G0L
M('1H92!)145%($-O;G-T:71U=&EO;BP@:6X@07)T:6-L92!)+"!396,N(#,L
M('-T871E<R`-"G1H870@=&AE($E%144@<VAA;&P@8V%R<GD@;W5T(&ET<R!G
M96YE<F%L(&%D;6EN:7-T<F%T:79E(&9U;F-T:6]N<R!I;B!A8V-O<F1A;F-E
M('=I=&@@=&AE(`T*3F5W(%EO<FL@3F]T+49O<BU0<F]F:70@0V]R<&]R871I
M;VX@3&%W+"!A;F0@:6X@07)T:6-L92!)22P@4V5C=&EO;B`Q(&5S=&%B;&ES
M:&5S('1H870@#0IT:&4@245%12!">6QA=W,@<VAA;&P@8F4@97-T86)L:7-H
M960@9F]R('1H92!P=7)P;W-E<R!O9B!G;W9E<FYI;F<@=&AE(&]P97)A=&EO
M;G,@86YD(`T*861M:6YI<W1R871I;VX@;V8@=&AE($E%144N#0H-"E1H:7,@
M8G)I;F=S('5S('1O(&$@<F5V:65W(&]F('1H92!R96QE=F%N="!396-T:6]N
M(#8Q,R!O9B!T:&4@3F5W(%EO<FL@3F]T+69O<BU0<F]F:70@#0I#;W)P;W)A
M=&EO;B!,87<@=VAI8V@@<W1A=&5S('1H870Z#0H@(`E396,N(#8Q,RX@(%9O
M=&4@;V8@;65M8F5R<RX-"F$I"45X8V5P="`@87,@;W1H97)W:7-E(')E<75I
M<F5D(&)Y('1H:7,@8VAA<'1E<B!O<B!B>2!T:&4@8V5R=&EF:6-A=&4@#0IO
M9B!I;F-O<G!O<F%T:6]N(&]R('1H92!B>2UL87=S(&%S('!E<FUI='1E9"!B
M>2`@=&AI<R!C:&%P=&5R+"`@#0ID:7)E8W1O<G,@('-H86QL(&)E(&5L96-T
M960@8GD@82!P;'5R86QI='D@;V8@=&AE('9O=&5S(&-A<W0@870@82`-"FUE
M971I;F<@;V8@;65M8F5R<R!B>2!T:&4@;65M8F5R<R!E;G1I=&QE9"!T;R`@
M=F]T92`@:6X@=&AE(`T*96QE8W1I;VXN#0IB*0E7:&5N979E<B!A;GD@8V]R
M<&]R871E(&%C=&EO;BP@;W1H97(@=&AA;B!T:&4@96QE8W1I;VX@;V8@#0ID
M:7)E8W1O<G,L(&ES('1O(&)E('1A:V5N('5N9&5R('1H:7,@8VAA<'1E<B!B
M>2!V;W1E(&]F('1H92`-"FUE;6)E<G,L(&ET('-H86QL+"!E>&-E<'0@87,@
M;W1H97)W:7-E(')E<75I<F5D(&)Y('1H:7,@8VAA<'1E<B!O<B`-"F)Y('1H
M92!C97)T:69I8V%T92!O9B!I;F-O<G!O<F%T:6]N(&]R(&)Y(&)Y+6QA=W,@
M87,@<&5R;6ET=&5D(&)Y(`T*=&AI<R!C:&%P=&5R+"!B92!A=71H;W)I>F5D
M(&)Y(&$@;6%J;W)I='D@;V8@=&AE('9O=&5S(&-A<W0@870@82`-"FUE971I
M;F<@;V8@;65M8F5R<R!B>2!T:&4@;65M8F5R<R!E;G1I=&QE9"!T;R!V;W1E
M('1H97)E;VXN#0IC*0E%>&-E<'0@87,@<')O=FED960@:6X@<&%R86=R87!H
M("AB*2P@86YY(')E9F5R96YC92!I;B!T:&ES(&-H87!T97(@#0IT;R!C;W)P
M;W)A=&4@86-T:6]N(&%T(&$@;65E=&EN9R!O9B!M96UB97)S(&)Y(")M86IO
M<FET>2!V;W1E(B`-"F]R(")T=V\M=&AI<F1S('9O=&4B('-H86QL(')E<75I
M<F4@=&AE(&%C=&EO;B!T;R!B92!T86ME;B!B>2!S=6-H(`T*<')O<&]R=&EO
M;B!O9B!T:&4@=F]T97,@8V%S="!A="!S=6-H(&UE971I;F<L('!R;W9I9&5D
M('1H870@=&AE(`T*869F:7)M871I=F4@=F]T97,@8V%S="!I;B!F879O<B!O
M9B!A;GD@<W5C:"!A8W1I;VX@<VAA;&P@8F4@870@;&5A<W0@#0IE<75A;"!T
M;R!T:&4@<75O<G5M+B`@($)L86YK('9O=&5S(&]R(&%B<W1E;G1I;VYS('-H
M86QL(&YO="!B92`-"F-O=6YT960@:6X@=&AE(&YU;6)E<B!O9B!V;W1E<R!C
M87-T+@T*#0I3=6)S96-T:6]N(%-E8W1I;VX@8RD@<')O=FED97,@=&AE(&-R
M:71I8V%L(&1I9F9E<F5N8V4@9G)O;2!2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E
M<B!O;B!T:&4@#0ID969I;FET:6]N(&]F('=H870@8V]N<W1I='5T97,@82!M
M86IO<FET>2X@($AA=FEN9R!S=V%M('5P<W1R96%M(&9R;VT@=&AE($UI;F]R
M($)O87)D(`T*9&]C=6UE;G1S('1H870@9&ER96-T('1H92!3<&]N<V]R(&%N
M9"!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(&EN('1H92!C;VYD=6-T(&]F('1H96ER(&)U<VEN
M97-S(&%T(`T*:&%N9"P@=&AR;W5G:"!T:&4@4V]C:65T>2P@36%J;W(@0F]A
M<F0@86YD($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!D;V-U;65N=',L('1H92!Q=65S=&EO;B!A
M="`-"FAA;F0@:7,@=VAE=&AE<B!T:&ES('!R;W9I<VEO;B!F;&]W<R!D;W=N
M<W1R96%M('1O('1H92!E>'1E;G0@=&AA="!I="!C;VYT<F]L<R!A;F0@9&ER
M96-T<R`-"G1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(&EN('1H92!C;VYD=6-T(&]F(&ET
M<R!B=7-I;F5S<RX@(`T*#0I&;W)M('1H92!C;VYT97AT(&]F('1H92!!<G1I
M8VQE(#8@;V8@=&AE($YE=R!9;W)K($YO="UF;W(M4')O9FET($-O<G!O<F%T
M:6]N($-O9&4L(&ET(&ES(`T*8VQE87(@=&AA="!T:&5S92!P<F]V:7-I;VYS
M(&%P<&QY('-O;&5L>2!T;R!T:&4@8V]R<&]R871E(&=O=F5R;F%N8V4@;V8@
M=&AE($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;BP@#0IA;F0@;F]T('1O('1H92!B=7-I;F5S<R!C
M;VYD=6-T(&]F(&ET<R!/<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!U;FET<RP@=VAI8V@@07)T
M:6-L92!)+"!S=6)S96-T:6]N(#0@#0ID969I;F5S(&%S(&9O;&QO=W,Z("`-
M"B)#;VYD=6-T:6YG(&]F(&%C=&EV:71I97,B(&]F(&$@8V]R<&]R871I;VX@
M;65A;G,@=&AE(&]P97)A=&EO;G,@9F]R('1H92!C;VYD=6-T(`T*;V8@=VAI
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M(&UU<W0@8F4@;65T(&EN(&]R9&5R(`T*9F]R($UE;6)E<G,@=&\@969F96-T
M(&-H86YG97,@=&\@=&AE(&)Y;&%W<R!O<B!C;W)P;W)A=&4@<W1R=6-T=7)E
M(&]F('1H92!/<F=A;FEZ871I;VXN("`-"E-P96-I9FEC86QL>2P@07)T:6-L
M92`V(&%D9')E<W-E<R!A9&]P=&EO;B!A;F0@;6]D:69I8V%T:6]N(&]F(&)Y
M;&%W<RP@86YN=6%L(&UE971I;F=S+"`-"F%N9"!S<&5C:6%L(&UE971I;F=S
M(&9O<B!T:&4@96QE8W1I;VX@;V8@9&ER96-T;W)S+"!A;&P@8VQE87)L>2!A
M<F5A<R!O9B!#;W)P;W)A=&4@#0I';W9E<FYA;F-E+@T*#0I4;W`@1&]W;@T*
M#0I&<F]M(&$@=&]P+61O=VX@<&5R<W!E8W1I=F4L('1H92!)145%($-O;G-T
M:71U=&EO;B!A;F0@0GEL87=S(')E9F5R96YC92!A;F0@<V5R=F4@=&\@#0IE
M<W1A8FQI<V@@=&AE($E%144@=6YD97(@=&AE(&%U=&AO<FET>2!O9B!T:&4@
M3F5W(%EO<FL@3F]T+69O<BU0<F]F:70@0V]R<&]R871I;VX@3&%W+B`@#0I)
M;B!S;R!D;VEN9RP@=&AE($E%144@:&%S(&]B;&EG871E9"!I='-E;&8@=&\@
M8V]N9'5C="!I=',@0V]R<&]R871E($=O=F5R;F%N8V4@=6YD97(@=&AE(`T*
M<W1R:6-T=7)E<R!O9B!T:&4@3F5W(%EO<FL@3F]T+69O<BU0<F]F:70@0V]R
M<&]R871I;VX@3&%W+"!I;F-L=61I;F<@=&AE(&UA;FYE<B!I;B`-"G=H:6-H
M(&ET(&-A;&-U;&%T97,@82!M86IO<FET>2!V;W1E+@T*#0I4:&4@245%12!"
M>6QA=W,@<')O=FED92!A(&9R86UE=V]R:R!F;W(@=&AE(&=O=F5R;F%N8V4@
M;V8@<W5B<V5Q=65N="!)145%(`T*;W)G86YI>F%T:6]N86P@=6YI=',@=VAI
M8V@@<W1A=&5S('1H870@=&AE('-T<FEC='5R97,@;V8@=&AE($YE=R!9;W)K
M($YO="UF;W(M4')O9FET(`T*0V]R<&]R871I;VX@3&%W+"!)145%($-O;G-T
M:71U=&EO;BP@86YD($E%144@0GEL87=S('=I;&P@9FQO=R!D;W=N('1O('1H
M92`-"FEM<&QE;65N=&%T:6]N(&]F('1H92!C;VYS=&ET=71I;VYA;"!P<F]V
M:7-I;VYS+"!B=70@=&AA="!2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<B!W:6QL
M(&)E(`T*=7-E9"!I;B!T:&4@8V]N9'5C="!O9B!B=7-I;F5S<RX-"@T*5&AE
M($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!D;V-U;65N=',@97-S96YT:6%L;'D@9FQO=R!D;W=N
M('1H:7,@;6]D96P@=&AR;W5G:"!T:&4@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0L(`T*4V]C:65T
M>2P@86YD($UI;F]R($)O87)D(&1O8W5M96YT<R!A=71H;W)I>FEN9R!T:&4@
M:6YF97)I;W(@96YT:71I97,@8F5L;W<@=&AE;2!W:&EL92`-"G!A<W-I;F<@
M=&AR;W5G:"!C;VYS=&ET=71I;VYA;"!S=')I8W1U<F5S(&%N9"!A=71H;W)I
M>FEN9R!T:&4@8V]N9'5C="!O9B!S<&5C:69I8R!B=7-I;F5S<RX-"@T*0V]N
M<V5Q=65N=&QY+"!W:&5N('=E(&%R<FEV92!A="!T:&4@:7-S=64@870@:&%N
M9"P@=V4@;75S="!C;VYF<F]N="!T:&4@<75E<W1I;VX@;V8@#0IW:&5T:&5R
M('1H92!D979E;&]P;65N="!O9B!A(&1R869T('-T86YD87)D(&)Y(&$@5V]R
M:VEN9R!'<F]U<"!I<R!A(&-O;G-T:71U=&EO;F%L(&%C="`-"F]F(&-O<G!O
M<F%T92!G;W9E<FYA;F-E(&]R('1H92!C;VYD=6-T(&]F('1H92!B=7-I;F5S
M<R!F;W(@=VAI8V@@:70@=V%S(&9O<FUE9"X@($EF(&ET(&ES(&$@#0IC;VYS
M=&ET=71I;VYA;"!A8W0@;V8@8V]R<&]R871E(&=O=F5R;F%N8V4L('1H96X@
M=&AE(&1E9FEN:71I;VX@;V8@;6%J;W)I='D@;75S="!B92`-"FEN=&5R<')E
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M(&1I<F5C=&5D(&)Y('1H92!)145%($-3(%-!0B!0)E`N("`-"E1H870@=&AE
M(&1E=F5L;W!M96YT(&]F(&$@9')A9G0@<W1A;F1A<F0@:7,@=&AE(&-O;F1U
M8W0@;V8@=&AE(&)U<VEN97-S(&9O<B!W:&EC:"!I="!W87,@#0IF;W)M960@
M:7,@8VQE87(@9G)O;2!T:&4@9&ER96-T:79E<R!O9B!T:&4@245%12!#4R!3
M04(@4"90+B`@5&\@97)A<V4@86YY(&1O=6)T(&]N('1H:7,@#0IS8V]R92P@
M22!N;W1E('1H870@;W1H97(@:6YF97)I;W(@96YT:71I97,@;V8@=&AE($E%
M144L(&EN8VQU9&EN9R!T:&4@3&5A<FYI;F<@5&5C:&YO;&]G>2`-"E-T86YD
M87)D<R!#;VUM:71T964@4W!O;G-O<BP@<F5F97)E;F-E('1H92!U<V4@;V8@
M4F]B97)T)W,@4G5L97,@;V8@3W)D97(L(&%N9"`-"G-P96-I9FEC86QL>2!C
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M5%-#(%-T86YD87)D<R`-"D-O;6UI='1E97,@:7,@;6]R92!T:&%N(&]N92UH
M86QF("@^-3`E*2!997,@=F]T97,@;V8@=&AE('1O=&%L(%EE<R!A;F0@#0I.
M;R!V;W1E<R!C87-T+"!E>&-L=61I;F<@86)S=&5N=&EO;G,N#0I6;W1E<R!A
M<F4@<F5C;W)D960@87,@)UEE<R<[("=.;R<[("=!8G-T86EN)R!O<B`G3FEL
MEG)E='5R;B<N#0I&;W(@9&5T97)M:6YI;F<@;W5T8V]M97,@;VYL>2!997,@
M86YD($YO('9O=&5S(&%R92!U<V5D('1O(&1E=&5R;6EN92`-"G!E<F-E;G1A
M9V5S+@T*#0I#;VYC;'5S:6]N#0H-"D9O<B!T:&4@<F5A<V]N<R!E;G5M97)A
M=&5D(&EN('1H92!F;W)E9V]I;F<@86YA;'ES:7,L(&ET(&ES(&-L96%R('1H
M92!V;W1E('1A:V5N(&EN(`T*8V]N;F5C=&EO;B!W:71H(&%N(&4M;6%I;"!B
M86QL;W0@8V]N9'5C=&5D(&)Y('1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P('1O(&1E=&5R
M;6EN92!W:&5T:&5R(`T*82!D;V-U;65N="!S:&]U;&0@8F5C;VUE(&$@8F%S
M92!D;V-U;65N="!S:&]U;&0@8F4@8V]N9'5C=&5D+"!A;F0@=&AE(&1E9FEN
M:71I;VX@;V8@#0IM86IO<FET>2!I;G1E<G!R971E9"P@=6YD97(@4F]B97)T
M)W,@4G5L97,@;V8@3W)D97(N#0H-"E-I;F-E<F5L>2P-"@T*#0I"96YE9&EC
M="!/)TUA:&]N97D-"E9I8V4@4')E<VED96YT+"!!9&UI;FES=')A=&EO;B!A
M;F0@3&5G86P@069F86ER<PT*365M;W)A;F1U;2!O;B`-"DE%144@5V]R:VEN
?9R!'<F]U<"!6;W1E#0I086=E(#$@;V8@.0T*#0H-"@==
`
end