SUO: Appeal of IEEE-SA BoG Directive (Revised Feb 13, 2002)
ATTN Lowell Johnson, Chair, CS Standards Activity Board:
1. Reference:
a. Message from Rona Gertz, Manager, IEEE-SA Governance, advising of
motion at IEEE-SA BoG November meeting (date not specified). (Attach 1)
b. Dorsey and Whitney Legal opinion, Nov 7, 2001. (Attach 2) (This
is a version I typed up from a paper copy, as I was never provided a digital
copy.)
c. Email message to Bob Spiller from Lyle Smith, 13 Sep 2001,
containing original message from Bob Spillers, Aug 13, 2001. (Attach 3)
d. Email message to James Schoening from Lyle Smith, Sep 14, 2001,
containing his original guidance, 13 Sep 2001. (Attach 4)
e. Legal opinion from Benedict O'Mahoney, Vice President,
Administration and Legal Affairs, Teknowledge Corp., Jan 15, 2002.
2. Background: The issue at hand is whether a vote by an IEEE Computer
Society working group should follow Robert's Rules of Order (as directed by
the CS Standards Activity Board P&Ps) or a higher level P&P, bylaw, or law,
as advised Lyle Smith, IEEE Parliamentarian, endorsed by Dorsey and Whitney
legal opinion, directed by IEEE-SA BoG directive, and forwarded by Chair,
Computer Society Standards Activity Board (SAB). In Aug 2001, The SUO WG
conducted a vote on whether to commence work on a starter document (named
SUMO). It passed 17-16, with 9 abstentions. I, as Chair, declared that the
motion passed. Bob Spillers, a voting member, challenged the vote on many
issues and sent numerous questions to Lyle Smith. (See Attach 3). I also
sent Mr. Smith some questions (See Attach 4). None of these questions asked
whether the way I had counted the votes was correct, though Mr. Smith
responded to me (Attach 4) that the vote had failed because of the method of
calculating a majority. Bob Spillers took this message from Mr. Smith and
pressed this issue with various IEEE individuals (messages not available).
The issue finally made its way to the IEEE-SA BOG meeting in November, which
passed the motion directing that the vote be retaken (Attach 1). I received
this via email from Rona Gertz; however, Lowell Johnson CS SAB Chair,
informed me by telephone that I should consider that it came down through
the SAB.
3. As Chair, P1600.1 Standard Upper Ontology WG, I respectfully appeal the
SAB's forwarding of the directive of the IEEE-SA BoG, for the following
three separate and distinct reasons, any one of which, I believe, will cause
the SAB to return the directive to the IEEE-SA BoG for reconsideration.
Basis #1: The Dorsey and Whitney legal opinion, upon which the
IEEE-SA BoG directive was based, failed to recognize a material fact, that
the Computer Society Standards Activities Board Policies and Procedures
direct working groups to follow Roberts Rules of Order (RRO). It states,
"The participants in our call also noted that no voting rules for Standards
working groups are specified in the IEEE Bylaws or the IEEE-SA Standards
Board Bylaws or Operations Manuals," which infers they believed no lower
level P&Ps addressed voting at the WG level. The SAB clearly cites RRO,
which covers voting quite clearly, and following RRO is the common practice
of CS WGs (when votes are needed.) The Teknowledge legal opinion (Attach 5)
presents a very thorough case for why CS working groups should follow RRO,
as required by the CS SAB P&Ps. The letter from Dorsey and Whitney refers
to some conference calls and the emails from Mr. Smith, but makes little or
no attempt to back up its position, as legal opinions should do. Dorsey and
Whitney should review the Teknolwedge legal opinion and agree or refute its
positions.
Resolution: Appeal will be withdrawn if the SAB returns the
directive to the IEEE-SA BoG for reconsideration.
Basis #2: The process used to arrive at the IEEE-SA BoG directive
violated the requirements of Openness and Due Process and amounted to an
informal appeals process. IEEE and the Computer Society have an appeals
process, but it was not followed for this matter. Lyle Smith offered
guidance (Attach 4) that the SUMO vote had not passed, and Bob Spillers
raised this issue with various individuals in IEEE. Mr. Spillers did not
submit an appeal, as he was advised he could. IEEE-SA BoG took up this
issue and acted on it as if it were an appeal, directing that the vote be
retaken. The agenda item for this matter was not announced, and the meeting
of the IEEE-SA BOG was not open. Stakeholders were not given the
opportunity to present their views.
Resolution: Appeal will be withdrawn if the SAB returns the directive to
the IEEE-SA BoG for reconsideration.
Basis #3: The directive requires that a new vote be taken, but is
not clear on what constitutes a majority. The IEEE-SA BoG motion refers to
the Dorsey and Whitney opinion, which refers to Lyle Smith's email. (Attach
4). It is not clear which law or bylaw should be followed or how to compute
a majority.
It is that clear abstentions would be counted, but are non-votes
also counted? In an email vote, is everyone considered present, since the
ballot was sent to everyone? For the SUMO vote, some non-voters did
acknowledge receipt of the ballot or were active on the listserv during this
period, but a few showed no sign of receipt.
IEEE Bylaws Section I-300, subsection 4 relating to Board of
Directors and Committee actions: "Unless otherwise provided in the
Certificate of Incorporation, the Constitution, these Bylaws, or the
Not-For-Profit Corporation Law of the State of New York, the vote of a
majority of the votes of the members present and entitled to vote, at the
time of the vote, provided a quorum is present, shall be the act of the
Board of Directors, any Committee thereof, or the Major Board, or any
committees of the forgoing."
Section 613 of the New York Not-for-Profit Corporation Law:
Sec. 613. Vote of members.
a) Except as otherwise required by
this chapter or by the certificate of incorporation or the by-laws as
permitted by this chapter, directors shall be elected by a plurality of
the votes cast at a meeting of members by the members entitled to vote in
the election.
b) Whenever any corporate action, other
than the election of directors, is to be taken under this chapter by vote of
the members, it shall, except as otherwise required by this chapter or by
the certificate of incorporation or by by-laws as permitted by this chapter,
be authorized by a majority of the votes cast at a meeting of members by the
members entitled to vote thereon.
c) Except as provided in paragraph (b),
any reference in this chapter to corporate action at a meeting of members by
"majority vote" or "two-thirds vote" shall require the action to be taken by
such proportion of the votes cast at such meeting, provided that the
affirmative votes cast in favor of any such action shall be at least equal
to the quorum. Blank votes or abstentions shall not be counted in the
number of votes cast.
The Dorsey and Whitney opinion stated: "Mr. Smith advised
Messrs. Spillers and Schoening that the motion failed because the
affirmative votes did not constitute a majority (i.e., 22) of the total
number of the ballots cast." [This would mean non-votes are not counted. ]
I apologize for this confusion, but clear voting rules for an
email-based WG can't be derived from these documents. It is not possible to
conduct a vote without clear voting rules.
Resolution: Appeal will be withdrawn, if either:
a. SAB returns the directive to the IEEE-SA BoG for
clarification of voting rules.
b. Clear voting rules can be interpreted from the IEEE-SA
BoG directive and its referenced documents.
Respectfully Submitted:
JAMES R. SCHOENING
Chair, IEEE P1600.1 Standard Upper Ontology Working Group
begin 600 Attach 1 - IEEE-SA BoG Directive.txt
M1G)O;3H@<BYG97)T>D!I965E+F]R9PT*4V5N=#H@36]N9&%Y+"!$96-E;6)E
M<B`Q,"P@,C`P,2`Q,CHP.2!030T*5&\Z(%-C:&]E;FEN9RP@2F%M97,@4B!#
M14-/32!$0U-#-$D-"D-C.B!*=61Y($=O<FUA;B`H12UM86EL*3L@)VPN9V%R
M9VEU;&]`:65E92YO<F<G#0I3=6)J96-T.B!293H@3F5E9"!R97-P;VYS92!4
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M:6]N#0IR96=A<F1I;F<@4#$V,#`N,3H-"@T*5&AE<F4@=V%S(&$@;6]T:6]N
M(&%N9"!S96-O;F0@8GD@1&5N;FES($)O9'-O;B!A;F0@1&]N($QO=6=H<GD@
M87,@9F]L;&]W<SH-"@T*5&AE($E%144M4T$@0D]'(&-O;G-I9&5R960@=&AE
M(&EN<75I<FEE<R!O9B!T:&4@245%12`Q-C`P+C$@=V]R:VEN9R!G<F]U<`T*
M86YD('1H92!O<&EN:6]N(&]F(#<@3F]V96UB97(@,C`P,2!O9F9E<F5D(&)Y
M($1O<G-E>2!A;F0@5VAI=&YE>2!A;F0-"F-O;F-U<G,@=VET:"!A;F0@<F5A
M9F9I<FUS('1H92!O<&EN:6]N('-T871E9"X@(%1H97)E9F]R92P@=&AE($E%
M144M4T$@0D]'#0ID:7)E8W1S('1H92!)145%+5-!(%-T86YD87)D<R!";V%R
M9"!T;R!I;F9O<FT@=&AE(%`Q-C`P+C$@=V]R:VEN9R!G<F]U<`T*=&AA="!I
M="!I<R!R97%U:7)E9"!T;R!R92UB86QL;W0@:71S(&EN:71I86P@9&5L:6)E
M<F%T:6]N+"!B87-E9"!O;B!T:&4-"G)E<75I<F5M96YT<R!O=71L:6YE9"!I
M;B!T:&4@869O<F5M96YT:6]N960@;&5T=&5R+@T*#0I&=7)T:&5R+"!T:&4@
M245%12U302!"3T<@96YC;W5R86=E<R!T:&4@245%12U302!3=&%N9&%R9',@
M0F]A<F0@=&\@:6YS=')U8W0-"G1H92!)145%(%`Q-C`P+C$@=V]R:VEN9R!G
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M144@4W1A;F1A<F1S($%C=&EV:71I97,-"G(N9V5R='I`:65E92YO<F<-"BLQ
M(#<S,B`U-C(@,S@P."`H<&AO;F4I.R`K,2`W,S(@-38R(#$U-S$@*&9A>"D-
M"DE%144@4W1A;F1A<F1S('=E8B!S:71E.FAT='`Z+R]S=&%N9&%R9',N:65E
M92YO<F<O#0H-"@T*("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(E-C:&]E;FEN9RP@2F%M97,@4B!#14-/32`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@($1#
M4T,T22(@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@5&\Z("`@("`B
M)VPN9V%R9VEU;&]`:65E92YO<F<G(B`\;"YG87)G:75L;T!I965E+F]R9SXL
M("`@(`T*("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`\2F%M97,N4V-H;V5N:6YG0&UA
M:6PQ+FUO;FUO=71H("`@("`@("`B2G5D>2!';W)M86X@*$4M;6%I;"DB(#QJ
M+F=O<FUA;D!I965E+F]R9SXL(")2;VYA($=E<G1Z("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@+F%R;7DN;6EL/B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@*$4M;6%I;"DB(#QR+F=E<G1Z0&EE964N;W)G/B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@8V,Z("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(`T*
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`Q,B\P-R\R,#`Q(#`Y.C,T($%-("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@(%-U8FIE8W0Z("`@("!.965D(')E<W!O;G-E(%1/1$%9
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(`T*#0H-"@T*
M#0I,:6YD82P@2G5D>2P@86YD(%)O;F$L#0H-"B`@("`@("`@("`@07,@=&AI
M<R!H87,@9')A9V=E9"!O;B!S:6YC92!!=6<L('!L96%S92!C;'5E(&UE(&EN
M(%1/1$%9(&]N#0IW:&%T)W,-"F=O:6YG(&]N+@T*#0I*:6T@4V-H;V5N:6YG
M#0H-"@T*#0HM+2TM+4]R:6=I;F%L($UE<W-A9V4M+2TM+0T*1G)O;3H@;"YG
M87)G:75L;T!I965E+F]R9R!;;6%I;'1O.FPN9V%R9VEU;&]`:65E92YO<F==
M#0I396YT.B!-;VYD87DL($1E8V5M8F5R(#`S+"`R,#`Q(#$P.C0U($%-#0I4
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M86YE+"!03R!";W@@,3,S,0T*4&ES8V%T87=A>2P@3DH@(#`X.#4U+3$S,S$@
M55-!#0HK,2`W,S(@-38R(#,X,#$@<&AO;F4-"BLQ(#<S,B`U-C(@,34W,2!F
M87@-"FAT='`Z+R]S=&%N9&%R9',N:65E92YO<F<O#0HM+2TM+2!&;W)W87)D
M960@8GD@3&EN9&$@1V%R9VEU;&\O4U1$4R]35$%&1B]54R])145%(&]N(#$R
M+S`S+S`Q(#$Q.C`S($%-#0HM+2TM+0T*#0H-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@2G5D:71H($=O<FUA;@T*#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(%1O.B`@("`@3&EN9&$-"D=A<F=I=6QO+U-41%,O
M4U1!1D8O55,O245%14!)145%#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(#$R+S`S
M+S`Q(#`Y.C`V("`@("`@(&-C.@T*#0H@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@($%-
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(%-U8FIE8W0Z#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*
M4&QE87-E(&=E="!T:&ES('1O($II;2!38VAO96YI;F<N(%1H86YK<RX-"DIU
M9'D-"BTM+2TM($9O<G=A<F1E9"!B>2!*=61I=&@@1V]R;6%N+U-41%,O4U1!
M1D8O55,O245%12!O;B`Q,B\P,R\P,2`P.3HP-B!!30T*+2TM+2T-"@T*1&5L
M:79E<GD@1F%I;'5R92!297!O<G0-"@T*(%EO=7(-"B!D;V-U;65N=#H-"@T*
M('=A<R!N;W0@("`@($IA;65S+E-C:&]E;FEN9T!M86EL,2YM;VYM;W5T:`T*
M(&1E;&EV97)E9`T*('1O.@T*#0H@8F5C875S93H@("`@-34P($AO<W0@=6YK
M;F]W;@T*#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*5VAA="!S:&]U;&0@>6]U(&1O/PT*#0H@("!9
M;W4@8V%N(')E<V5N9"!T:&4@=6YD96QI=F5R86)L92!D;V-U;65N="!T;R!T
M:&4@<F5C:7!I96YT<R!L:7-T960@86)O=F4-"B`@(&)Y(&-H;V]S:6YG('1H
M92!297-E;F0@8G5T=&]N(&]R('1H92!297-E;F0@8V]M;6%N9"!O;B!T:&4@
M06-T:6]N<R!M96YU+@T*#0H@("!/;F-E('EO=2!H879E(')E<V5N="!T:&4@
M9&]C=6UE;G0@>6]U(&UA>2!D96QE=&4@=&AI<R!$96QI=F5R>2!&86EL=7)E
M#0H@("!297!O<G0N#0H-"B`@($EF(')E<V5N9&EN9R!T:&4@9&]C=6UE;G0@
M:7,@;F]T('-U8V-E<W-F=6P@>6]U('=I;&P@<F5C96EV92!A(&YE=PT*("`@
M9F%I;'5R92!R97!O<G0N#0H-"B`@(%5N;&5S<R!Y;W4@<F5C96EV92!O=&AE
M<B!$96QI=F5R>2!&86EL=7)E(%)E<&]R=',L('1H92!D;V-U;65N="!W87,-
M"B`@('-U8V-E<W-F=6QL>2!D96QI=F5R960@=&\@86QL(&]T:&5R(')E8VEP
M:65N=',N#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*("`@0G5Z>B]54R])145%#0H-"@T*#0H-"B`@
M?"`@("`@5&\Z("!*86UE<RY38VAO96YI;F=`;6%I;#$N;6]N;6]U=&@-"@T*
M#0H-"B`@?"`@("`@8V,Z#0H-"@T*#0H@("`@("!$871E.B`@,#@Z-#@Z,#8@
M04T@5&]D87D-"@T*#0H-"@T*("`@4W5B:F5C=#H-"@T*#0H-"@T*#0I$96%R
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M8V]M;75N8V%T:6]N+@T*0F5S="!R96=A<F1S+`T*2G5D>0T*#0H-"@T*#0H-
%"@T*#0H=
`
end
begin 600 Attach 2 - Dorsey & Whitney Opinion.txt
M5&AE(&9O;&QO=VEN9R!I<R!A('1Y<&5D+75P('9E<G-I;VX@;V8@82!P87!E
M<B!C;W!Y(&]F('1H92!$;W)S97D@86YD(`T*5VAI=&YE>2!L96=A;"!O<&EN
M:6]N+@T*(`T*2F%M97,@4V-H;V5N:6YG#0I#:&%I<BP@245%12!0,38P,"XQ
M(%-53R!71PT*#0H]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]
M/3T]/3T]/3T]#0H-"@T*1$]24T59("8@5TA)5$Y%62!,3%`-"C(U,"!087)K
M($%V96YU90T*3F5W(%EO<FLL($Y9(#$P,3<W#0I496QE<&AO;F4Z("@R,3(I
M-#$U+3DR,#`-"D9A>#H@*#(Q,BD@.34S+3<R,#$-"G=W=RYD;W)S97EL87<N
M8V]M#0H-"E)/0D525"!*+B!$5UE%4B!*4BX-"B@R,3(I(#0Q-2TY,C$X#0ID
M=WEE<BYR;V)E<G1`9&]R<V5Y;&%W+F-O;0T*#0I.;W9E;6)E<B`W+"`R,#`Q
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M144@=&\@365S<W)S+B!2;V)E<G0@4W!I;&QE<G,@86YD(`T*2F%M97,@4V-H
M;V5N:6YG(&EN(&-O;FYE8W1I;VX@=VET:"!A;B!E+6UA:6P@8F%L;&]T(&-O
M;F1U8W1E9"!B>2!T:&4@#0I0,38P,"XQ(%-T86YD87)D(%5P<&5R($]N=&]L
M;V=Y(%=O<FMI;F<@1W)O=7`@*'1H92`B5V]R:VEN9R!'<F]U<"(I('1O(`T*
M9&5T97)M:6YE('=H971H97(@82!D;V-U;65N="!S:&]U;&0@8F5C;VUE(&$@
M8F%S92!D;V-U;65N="X@(`T*4W!E8VEF:6-A;&QY+"!W92!U;F1E<G-T86YD
M('1H870@-#(@92UM86EL(&)A;&QO=',@=V5R92!R96-E:79E9"`-"FEN8VQU
M9&EN9R`Y(&%B<W1E;G1I;VYS+"`Q-R!A9F9I<FUA=&EV92!V;W1E<R!A;F0@
M,38@;F5G871I=F4@=F]T97,N("`-"DUR+B!3;6ET:"!A9'9I<V5D($UE<W-R
M<RX@4W!I;&QE<G,@86YD(%-C:&]E;FEN9R!T:&%T('1H92!M;W1I;VX@9F%I
M;&5D(`T*8F5C875S92!T:&4@869F:7)M871I=F4@=F]T97,@9&ED(&YO="!C
M;VYS=&ET=71E(&$@;6%J;W)I='D@*&DN92XL(#(R*2`-"F]F('1H92!T;W1A
M;"!N=6UB97(@;V8@=&AE(&)A;&QO=',@8V%S="X@(%1H97)E('=A<R!N;R!N
M965D('1O(&1E=&5R;6EN92`-"G=H971H97(@82!Q=6]R=6T@=V%S('!R97-E
M;G0@<VEN8V4@=&AE(&UO=&EO;B!F86EL960N(`T*#0H)4F5C96YT;'DL($D@
M<&%R=&EC:7!A=&5D('=I=&@@>6]U(&EN(&$@=&5L97!H;VYE(&-O;F9E<F5N
M8V4@=VAI8V@@#0II;F-L=61E9"!-<BX@4VUI=&@L($5R:6,@2&5R>B`H1&ER
M96-T;W(@16UE<FET=7,@;V8@245%12!A;F0@<&%S="`-"E!A<FQI86UE;G1A
M<FEA;B!O9B!)145%*2P@5&AO;6%S(%=E='1A8V@@*'!A<G1N97(@:6X@=&AE
M(&9I<FT@;V8@0V]H96X@)B`-"D=R:7-B97DL('=H:6-H(&%C="!A<R!S<&5C
M:6%L(&-O=6YS96P@=&\@=&AE($E%144@4W1A;F1A<F1S(`T*07-S;V-I871I
M;VXI+"!-87)C;R!-:6=L:6%R;R`H,C`P,2!0<F5S:61E;G0L($E%144@4W1A
M;F1A<F1S(`T*07-S;V-I871I;VXI(&%N9"!O=&AE<B!M96UB97)S(&]F('1H
M92!)145%(%-T86YD87)D<R!!8W1I=FET:65S('-T869F+B`@#0I);B!R979I
M97=I;F<@=&AI<R!M871T97(L('1H92!P87)T:6-I<&%N=',@:6X@=&AE('1E
M;&5P:&]N92!C;VYF97)E;F-E(`T*=6YA;FEM;W5S;'D@8V]N8VQU9&4@=&AA
M="!T:&4@861V:6-E(&=I=F5N(&)Y($UR+B!3;6ET:"!T;R!-97-S<G,N(`T*
M4V-H;V5N:6YG(&%N9"!3<&EL;&5R<R!W87,@8V]R<F5C="X-"@T*"51H92!P
M87)T:6-I<&%N=',@:6X@=&AE('1E;&5P:&]N92!C;VYF97)E;F-E(')E=FEE
M=V5D(%-E8W1I;VX@-S`X(`T*;V8@=&AE($YE=R!9;W)K($YO="UF;W(M4')O
M9FET($-O<G!O<F%T:6]N($QA=R!R96=A<F1I;F<@86-T:6]N<R!B>2!T:&4@
M#0IB;V%R9"!O9B!D:7)E8W1O<G,[($E%144@0GEL87<@22TS,#$N-R!R96=A
M<F1I;F<@=&AE(&UA;FYE<B!I;B!W:&EC:"`-"F%C=&EO;B!M87D@8F4@=&%K
M96X@8GD@=&AE($E%144@0F]A<F0@;V8@1&ER96-T;W)S(&%N9"!C;VUM:71T
M965S.R!)145%(`T*0GEL87<@22TS,#$N,3$@<F5G87)D:6YG('1H92!U<V4@
M;V8@4F]B97)T)W,@4G5L97,@;V8@3W)D97(@8GD@=&AE(`T*=F%R:6]U<R!O
M<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!U;FET<R!O9B!T:&4@245%12!I;B!T:&4@86)S96YC
M92!O9B!O=&AE<B`-"F%P<&QI8V%B;&4@<G5L97,@;V8@<')O8V5D=7)E.R!A
M;F0@4F]B97)T)W,@4G5L97,@;V8@3W)D97(@<F5G87)D:6YG(`T*8F%S97,@
M9F]R(&1E=&5R;6EN:6YG(&$@=F]T:6YG(')E<W5L="X@(%1H92!P87)T:6-I
M<&%N=',@:6X@;W5R(&-A;&P@#0IA;'-O(&YO=&5D('1H870@;F\@=F]T:6YG
M(')U;&5S(&9O<B!3=&%N9&%R9',@=V]R:VEN9R!G<F]U<',@87)E(`T*<W!E
M8VEF:65D(&EN('1H92!)145%($)Y;&%W<R!O<B!T:&4@245%12U302!3=&%N
M9&%R9',@0F]A<F0@0GEL87=S(&]R(`T*3W!E<F%T:6]N<R!-86YU86QS+@T*
M#0H)5&AE(&1E=&5R;6EN871I;VX@8V]M;75N:6-A=&5D('1O($UE<W-R<RX@
M4V-H;V5N:6YG(&%N9"!3<&EL;&5R<R`-"G=A<R!M861E(&9O<B!S979E<F%L
M(')E87-O;G,N("!&:7)S="P@=&AE($-O<G!O<F%T92!';W9E<FYA;F-E($]F
M9FEC92!O9B`-"DE%144@:&%S(&-O;G-I<W1E;G1L>2!A9'9I<V5D(&]R9V%N
M:7IA=&EO;F%L('5N:71S(&]F($E%144@=&AA="P@:6X@#0IO<F1E<B!T;R!T
M86ME(&%C=&EO;B!O;B!A(&UA='1E<BP@82!Q=6]R=6T@;75S="!B92!P<F5S
M96YT(&%N9"!T:&4@#0IA9F9I<FUA=&EV92!V;W1E(&]F(&$@;6%J;W)I='D@
M;V8@=&AE(&UE;6)E<G,@;V8@=&AE(')U;&EN9R!B;V1Y('!R97-E;G0@#0IA
M="!T:&4@=&EM92!O9B!T:&4@=F]T92!M=7-T(&)E(&]B=&%I;F5D+B`@4V5C
M;VYD+"!T:&4@0V]R<&]R871E(`T*1V]V97)N86YC92!/9F9I8V4@:&%S(&-O
M;G-I<W1E;G1L>2!A9'9I<V5D('1H92!O<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!U;FET<R!O
M9B`-"DE%144@=&AA="`B8F5S="!C;W)P;W)A=&4@<')A8W1I8V5S(B!S=6=G
M97-T(&9O;&QO=VEN9R!T:&4@=F]T:6YG(&%N9"`-"F]T:&5R(')U;&5S(&]F
M('!R;V-E9'5R92!A<'!L:6-A8FQE('1O('1H92!)145%($)O87)D(&]F($1I
M<F5C=&]R<R!W:&5N(`T*;W1H97(@<G5L97,@;V8@<')O8V5D=7)E(&%R92!N
M;W0@<W!E8VEF:65D+B`@5&AI<F0L(&EF(&$@;6%J;W)I='D@;V8@=&AE(`T*
M8F%L;&]T<R!R96-E:79E9"!W97)E(&YO="!R97%U:7)E9"!I;B!O<F1E<B!F
M;W(@86-T:6]N('1O(&)E('1A:V5N(&)Y(`T*=&AE(%=O<FMI;F<@1W)O=7`L
M(&%N(&%B<W5R9"!R97-U;'0@;6EG:'0@8F4@;V)T86EN960N("!&;W(@97AA
M;7!L92P@#0IA<W-U;64@-#(@8F%L;&]T<R!W97)E(')E8V5I=F5D('=I=&@@
M-#$@86)S=&5N=&EO;G,@86YD(&]N;'D@,2`-"F%F9FER;6%T:79E('9O=&4N
M("!)9B!O;FQY(&$@;6%J;W)I='D@;V8@=&AE(&)A;&QO=',@86-T=6%L;'D@
M8V%S="`-"BAE>&-L=61I;F<@86)S=&5N=&EO;G,I('=E<F4@8V]U;G1E9"P@
M=&AE(&1O8W5M96YT(&EN('%U97-T:6]N('=O=6QD(`T*:&%V92!B96-O;64@
M82!B87-E(&1O8W5M96YT('=I=&@@;VYL>2!A('-I;F=L92!V;W1E(&-A<W0@
M:6X@:71S(&9A=F]R+B`@#0I&:6YA;&QY+"!I9B!V;W1I;F<@<')O8V5D=7)E
M<R!D:69F97)E;G0@9G)O;2!T:&]S92!R96-O;6UE;F1E9"!A<F4@=&\@8F4@
M#0IU<V5D(&)Y('1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P("AO<B!O=&AE<B!W;W)K:6YG
M(&=R;W5P<R!W:71H:6X@=&AE(%-T86YD87)D<R`-"D%S<V]C:6%T:6]N*2P@
M=&AE($E%144@0F]A<F0@;V8@1&ER96-T;W)S('-H;W5L9"!T86ME(&%C=&EO
M;B!T;R`-"FEN=&5R<')E="!T:&4@;&%W(&%N9"!T:&4@245%12!">6QA=W,@
M<V\@87,@=&\@<&5R;6ET('1H92!U<V4@;V8@<W5C:"`-"F1I9F9E<F5N="!V
M;W1I;F<@<')O8V5D=7)E<RX-"@T*"4EN('-H;W)T+"!W92!B96QI979E('1H
M870@=&AE($E%144@0F]A<F0@;V8@1&ER96-T;W)S('5L=&EM871E;'D@#0IM
M=7-T(&%P<')O=F4@=VAE=&AE<B!A;B!E>&-E<'1I;VX@<VAO=6QD(&)E(&UA
M9&4@=&\@=&AE(')U;&5S(&]F(`T*<')O8V5D=7)E<R!W:&EC:"!H879E(&)E
M96X@8V]N<VES=&5N=&QY(')E8V]M;65N9&5D('1O('1H92`-"F]R9V%N:7IA
M=&EO;F%L('5N:71S(&]F($E%144N("!!9F9E8W1E9"!P87)T:65S(&%R92P@
M;V8@8V]U<G-E+"!F<F5E('1O(`T*87!P96%L('1H92!R=6QI;F<@;V8@=&AE
M($-O<G!O<F%T92!';W9E<FYA;F-E($]F9FEC92!O9B!)145%('1O('1H92!)
M145%(`T*0F]A<F0@;V8@1&ER96-T;W)S+@T*#0H)1FEN86QL>2P@>6]U(&%L
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M97,@86YD(&%D9')E<W-E<R`-"F]F(&ET<R!C;VYT<FEB=71O<G,@=VAO(&=I
M=F4@;6]R92!T:&%N(&$@<W!E8VEF:6,@86UO=6YT(&EN(&ET<R!A;FYU86P@
M#0II;F9O<FUA=&EO;B!R971U<FXL('-U8V@@:6YF;W)M871I;VX@:7,@;F]T
M(&%V86EL86)L92!T;R!T:&4@9V5N97)A;"`-"G!U8FQI8RX-"@T*"4D@=')U
M<W0@=&AA="!T:&ES(&ES(')E<W!O;G-I=F4@=&\@>6]U<B!R97%U97-T<RX-
M"@T*"0D)"0E697)Y(%1R=6QY('EO=7)S+`T*#0H)"0D)"5)O8F5R="!*+B!$
C=WEE<B!*<BX@#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*+B`-"@T*#0H-"@T*#0H=
`
end
begin 600 Attach 3 - Msg from Lyle Smith to Bob Spillers.txt
M1G)O;3H@;"YM+G-M:71H0&EE964N;W)G#0I396YT.B!4:'5R<V1A>2P@4V5P
M=&5M8F5R(#$S+"`R,#`Q(#DZ-#`@04T-"E1O.B!S:WED;V=`<&]S=&]F9FEC
M92YP86-B96QL+FYE=`T*0V,Z(%-C:&]E;FEN9RP@2F%M97,@4B!#14-/32!$
M0U-#-$D[(&HN9V]R;6%N0&EE964N;W)G.PT*<RYT871I;F5R0&EE964N;W)G
M.R!E+FAE<GI`:65E92YO<F<[(&1W>65R+G)O8F5R=$!D;W)S97EL87<N8V]M
M#0I3=6)J96-T.B!1=65S=&EO;G,@<F5G87)D:6YG(%)O8F5R=',@4G5L97,@
M;V8@3W)D97(-"@T*#0I-<BX@4W!I;&QE<G,L#0H-"EEO=7(@<75E<W1I;VYS
M(&AA=F4@8F5E;B!R979I97=E9"!B>2!T:&4@0F]A<F0@4&%R;&EA;65N=&%R
M:6%N+"!,96=A;`T*0V]U;G-E;"!A;F0@1&ER96-T;W(@16UE<FET=7,@=VAO
M(&%C="!A<R!A('1E86T@86YY(&%N<W=E<B!Q=65S=&EO;G,@;V8-"G1H:7,@
M;F%T=7)E(&%S('=E;&P@87,@=&AO<V4@<F5L871E9"!T;R!A;&P@1V]V97)N
M86YC92!)<W-U97,@;VX@8F5H86QF(&]F#0IT:&4@0F]A<F0N#0H-"E)O8F5R
M="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F($]R9&5R("`@87)E('-P96-I9FEE9"!I;B!T:&4@245%
M12!">6QA=W,@=&\@8F4@=7-E9"!B>0T*(BXN+BYO<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!U
M;FET<R!O9B!)145%('5N;&5S<R!O=&AE<B!R=6QE<R!O9B!P<F]C961U<F4@
M<W!E8VEF:65D#0IB>2!.62!.;W0M#0IF;W(M4')O9FET($-O<G!O<F%T:6]N
M($QA=RXN+BXN971C+B(@5&AU<RP@4F]B97)T)W,@4G5L97,@87)E('-U8F]R
M9&EN871E9`T*:6X@=&AE(&AI97)A<F-H>0T*;V8@<G5L97,@=&\@3ED@;&%W
M+"!)145%($-E<G1I9FEC871E(&]F($EN8V]R<&]R871I;VXL($-O;G-T:71U
M=&EO;BP-"D)Y;&%W<RP@4F5S;VQU=&EO;G,@;V8@=&AE#0I";V%R9"!O9B!$
M:7)E8W1O<G,L(%!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!0<F]C961U<F5S+"!A;F0@4')A8W1I
M8V5S+B`@5&AE<F4@=V%S('-O;64-"F1I<V-U<W-I;VX@<F5G87)D:6YG('5S
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M8FQE#0IF;W(@<F5V:65W+@T*#0H@($9R;VTZ("`@(%)O8F5R="!'<F%Y<V]N
M(%-P:6QL97)S(#QS:WED;V=`<&]S=&]F9FEC92YP86-B96QL+FYE=#X-"CX@
M("`@("`@("`@(%1O.B`@("`@($QY;&4@4VUI=&@@/&QY;&4N<VUI=&A`:65E
M92YO<F<^#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!3=6)J96-T.B!1=65S=&EO;G,@<F5G87)D
M:6YG(%)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F($]R9&5R#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!$871E
M.B`@("!-;VXL(#$S($%U9R`R,#`Q(#`T.C,R.C(T("TP-#`P#0H^#0H^("`@
M("`@("`@("!,>6QE+`T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@22!H879E('1R:65D('1O(&ES
M;VQA=&4@=&AE<V4@<75E<W1I;VYS('1O(&ES<W5E<R!O9@T*/B`@("`@("`@
M("`@<&%R;&EA;65N=&%R>0T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@<')O8V5D=7)E(&)A<V5D
M(&]N('1H92!L871E<W0@=F5R<VEO;B!O9B!2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9@T*
M3W)D97(-"CX@("`@("`@("`@("A2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<B!.
M97=L>2!2979I<V5D(#$P=&@@161I=&EO;B!P=6)L:7-H960-"F)Y#0H^("`@
M("`@("`@("!097)S975S#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!0=6)L:7-H:6YG($-A;6)R
M:61G92P@36%S<RX@3V-T;V)E<B`R,#`P*2X-"CX-"CX@("`@("`@("`@("@Q
M*2`@36%Y('1H92!C:&%I<B!M86ME(&$@;6]T:6]N/PT*/B`@("`@("`@("`@
M06YS=V5R/B!.;W0@=VAI;&4@<VET=&EN9R!I;B!T:&4@0VAA:7(N($AE(&UA
M>2!R96QI;G%U:7-H('1H90T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@0VAA:7(L(&%N9"!T:&5N
M(&UA:V4@82!M;W1I;VXN#0H^#0H^("`@("`@("`@("`H,BD@($UA>2!T:&4@
M8VAA:7(@<&%R=&EC:7!A=&4@:6X@9&5B871E/PT*/B`@("`@("`@("`@06YS
M=V5R+B!.;W0@=VAI;&4@<VET=&EN9R!I;B!T:&4@0VAA:7(N(%-E92!A;G-W
M97(@=&\@,2D-"CX-"CX@("`@("`@("`@("@S*2`@268@=&AE(&-H86ER(&1O
M97,@;6%K92!A(&UO=&EO;B!M=7-T(&AE('-T97`@87-I9&4@87,-"F-H86ER
M#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!A;F0-"CX@("`@("`@("`@('!A<W,@=&AE(&=A=F5L
M('1O(&%N(&%C=&EN9R!C:&%I<C\-"CX@("`@("`@("`@($%N<W=E<BX@665S
M+"!S964@,2D@86YD(#(I(&%B;W9E#0H^#0H^("`@("`@("`@("`H-"D@($UA
M>2!T:&4@8VAA:7(@*'=H:6QE(&%C=&EN9R!A<R!C:&%I<BD@=F]T90T*/B`@
M("`@("`@("`@06YS=V5R+B!4:&4@0VAA:7(@;6%Y('9O=&4@:6X@8V5R=&%I
M;B!C:7)C=6US=&%N8V5S+B!);B!T:&4-"CX@("`@("`@("`@(&%B<V5N8V4@
M;V8@:&EG:&5R(&QE=F5L(')U;&5S+"!S=6-H(&%S(&)Y;&%W<RP@<&]L:6-I
M97,L(&]R#0IE=F5N('!R86-T:6-E<RP@=&AE($-H86ER#0H^("`@("`@;6%Y
M('9O=&4@=VAE;F5V97(@:&ES('9O=&4@8V%N(&%F9F5C="!T:&4@;W5T8V]M
M92TM+71H870@:7,L('1O#0IM86ME+"!B<F5A:RP-"CX@("`@("!O<B!C875S
M92!A('1I92!V;W1E+@T*#0H^("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@*&$I(&]N(&$@
M;6]T:6]N#0H^("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("AB*2!T;R!B<F5A:R!A('1I
M90T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("AC*2!T;R!C<F5A=&4@82!T:64-"B`@
M("`@("`@("`@(%1H92!)145%($-O;G-T:71U=&EO;B!S<&5C:69I97,@0VAA
M:7(@=F]T97,@9F]R('1H92!#:&%I<B!O9@T*=&AE($)O87)D(&]F($1I<F5C
M=&]R<R!A;F0@=&AE($-H86ER#0H@("`@("`@("`@("!O9B!T:&4@07-S96UB
M;'DL(&)U="!N;W0@:6X@9V5N97)A;"P@86YD('1H97)E9F]R92!2;V)E<G1S
M#0I2=6QE<R!W;VQD(&%P<&QY+"!A<R!E>'!L86EN960@86)O=F4N#0H^#0H^
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("AD*2!T;R!B<F5A:R!A('1I92!A9G1E<B!V
M;W1I;F<@=&\@8W)E871E(&$@=&EE#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!!;G-W97(N(%1H
M92!#:&%I<B!C86YN;W0@=F]T92!T=VEC92P@=&AA="!I<R!T;R!C<F5A=&4@
M82!T:64L#0IA;F0-"CX@("`@("`@("`@('1H96X@82!S96-O;F0@=&EM92!T
M;R!B<F5A:R!A('1I90T*/@T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@*#4I("!-87D@=&AE('!E
M<G-O;B!A8W1I;F<@87,@8VAA:7(@=F]T92!O;B!A(&UO=&EO;B!W:&EL90T*
M86-T:6YG#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!A<PT*/B`@("`@("`@("`@8VAA:7(_#0H^
M("`@("`@("`@("!!;G-W97(N(%1H:7,@;&]O:W,@;&EK92!Q=65S=&EO;B`T
M*&$I+B!)<R!T:&ES('%U97-T:6]N(&UE86YT#0IT;PT*/B`@("`@("`@("`@
M8F4@9&EF9F5R96YT/PT*/@T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@*#8I("!7:&%T(&ES('1H
M92!S:7IE("AP97)C96YT*2!O9B!A('%U;W)U;2`H87-S=6UI;F<@;F\-"CX@
M("`@("`@("`@('!A<FQI86UE;G1A<GD-"CX@("`@("`@("`@('!R;V-E9'5R
M97,@+2!E+F<N(&)Y;&%W<R`M(&]T:&5R('1H86X@4E)/*0T*/B`@("`@("`@
M("`@06YS=V5R+B!!(&UA:F]R:71Y(&]F('9O=&EN9R!M96UB97)S+"`H4W!E
M8VEF:65D(&EN($YY(%-T871U=&4-"F%N9"!)145%($)Y;&%W<RDN#0H^#0H^
M("`@("`@("`@("`@($ES(&$@<75O<G5M(')E<75I<F5D('1O('!A<W,@82!M
M;W1I;VX_#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!!;G-W97(N(%EE<RP@=6YL97-S(&$@<75O
M<G5M(&AA9"!B965N(&5S=&%B;&ES:&5D+"!S;VUE(&UE;6)E<G,-"CX@("`@
M("`@("`@(&AA=F4@;&5F="P@86YD(&YO8F]D>2!H87,@<75E<W1I;VYE9"!W
M:&5T:&5R(&$@<75O<G5M('-T:6QL#0IE>&ES=',@270-"CX@("`@("`@("`@
M:7,@=&AE;B!P<F5S=6UE9"!T;R!E>&ES="X-"CX-"CX@("`@("`@("`@("@X
M*2`@36%Y('1H92!C:&%I<B!D96-L87)E('1H870@82!Q=6]R=6T@:7,@=6YN
M96-E<W-A<GD_#0H^("`@("`@("`@("!!;G-W97(N($Y/#0H^#0H^("`@("`@
M("`@("`Y*2`@36%Y('1H92!R=6QE<R!O;B!V;W1I;F<@;W(@<75O<G5M<R!B
M92!C:&%N9V5D('=I=&AO=70-"CX-"CX@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@*&$I
M(&$@=F]T90T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`H8BD@82!Q=6]R=6T-"CX@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@*&,I(&$@='=O('1H:7)D<R!V;W1E(&EN(&9A
M=F]R(&]F('1H92!C:&%N9V4H<RD-"CX@("`@("`@("`@($%N<W=E<BX@3F\L
M(&YO+"!A;F0@;F\N($$@<75O<G5M(&ES(&5S=&%B;&ES:&5D(&)Y(&QA=RP@
M;W(@8GD-"CX@("`@("`@("`@($-E<G1I9FEC871E(&]F($EN8V]R<&]R871I
M;VXL#0H^("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(&]R(&EN('1H92!)145%($)Y
M;&%W<PT*/@T*/B`@("`@("!)<R!A(&UO=&EO;B!P97)M:71T960@*&EN(&]R
M9&5R/RD@=&AA="!C;VYT86EN<R!W:71H:6X@:71S96QF#0H^("`@("`@("`@
M("!C:&%N9V5S('1O('1H92!E>&ES=&EN9R!P<F]C961U<F5S(&]N('=H870@
M:7,@<F5Q=6ER960@9F]R('1H90T*/B`@("`@("`@("`@;6]T:6]N('1O#0H^
M("`@("`@("`@("!P87-S("T@92YG+B!D96-L87)E(&$@<75O<G5M('5N;F5C
M97-S87)Y/PT*/B`@("`@("`@("`@06YS=V5R+B!.;RP@82!Q=6]R=6T@:7,@
M86QW87ES(&YE961E9"X-"CX-"CX@("`@("`@("`@(%1H86YK('EO=2X-"CX-
M"CX@("`@("`@("`@($)O8B!3<&EL;&5R<PT*#0I,>6QE($TN(%-M:71H#0I3
M=&%F9B!$:7)E8W1O<B`M($-O<G!O<F%T92!!8W1I=FET:65S#0HW,S(@.3@Q
)+3,T-#<-"@T*
`
end
begin 600 Attach 4 - Msg from Lyle Smith to James Schoening.txt
M1G)O;3H@;"YM+G-M:71H0&EE964N;W)G#0I396YT.B!&<FED87DL(%-E<'1E
M;6)E<B`Q-"P@,C`P,2`Y.C`U(%!-#0I4;SH@4V-H;V5N:6YG+"!*86UE<R!2
M($-%0T]-($1#4T,T20T*0V,Z(&1W>65R+G)O8F5R=$!D;W)S97EL87<N8V]M
M.R!E+FAE<GI`:65E92YO<F<[(&HN9V]R;6%N0&EE964N;W)G.PT*<RYT871I
M;F5R0&EE964N;W)G#0I3=6)J96-T.B!213H@4F5Q=65S="!F;W(@4G5L97,@
M861V:6-E+@T*#0H-"DII;2P-"@T*3V8@8V]U<G-E('1H97D@9&ED+B`@5V4@
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M('1H92!S86UE(&-O;G-I<W1E;G0@=V%Y+B`@5&AE($E%144@0F]A<F0@86YD
M(&ET<R!#;VUM:71T965S(&%L<V\-"FUU<W0@9F]L;&]W('1H97-E(&%N9"!E
M=F5N(&UO<F4@<F5S=')I8W1I=F4@<G5L97,N("!792!H879E('!R;W9I9&5D
M#0IA9&1I=&EO;F%L(&9L97AI8FEL:71Y(&9O<B!T:&4@4W1A;F1A<F1S(%=O
M<FMI;F<@1W)O=7!S+B!)(&%M('1R>6EN9R!T;PT*:V5E<"!T:&%T(&%D9&5D
M(&9L97AI8FEL:71Y(&EN('1A8W0@<V\@=V4@9&\@;F]T('=I;F0@=7`@:6X@
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M92!Q=65S=&EO;G,@:&%V92!B965N(&%N<W=E<F5D+B`@268-"G1H:7,@9V]E
M<R!B97EO;F<@82!S:6UP;&4@<F5S<&]N<V4@=&\@=F5R:69Y(&%G<F5E;65N
M="!T:&5N(&9U<G1H97(-"F-O;G-I9&5R871I;VX@;75S="!B92!G:79E;BX-
M"@T*#0H-"DQY;&4@32X@4VUI=&@-"E-T869F($1I<F5C=&]R("T@0V]R<&]R
M871E($%C=&EV:71I97,-"C<S,B`Y.#$M,S0T-PT*#0H-"B`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@(E-C:&]E;FEN9RP@
M2F%M97,@4B!#14-/32`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@1$-30S1)(B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@5&\Z("`@("`B)VPN;2YS;6ET:$!I965E+F]R9R<B(#QL+FTN<VUI
M=&A`:65E92YO<F<^("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@/$IA;65S+E-C
M:&]E;FEN9T!M86EL,2YM;VYM;W5T:"`@("`@("`@8V,Z("`@("`B4W5S86X@
M5&%T:6YE<B`H12UM86EL*2(@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@+F%R;7DN;6EL/B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@/',N=&%T:6YE<D!I965E+F]R9SX@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@4W5B:F5C=#H@("`@
M(%)%.B!297%U97-T(&9O<B!2=6QE<R!A9'9I8V4N("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@,#DO,30O,C`P,2`P-CHU,R!032`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-
M"B`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@
M("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`@("`-"@T*#0H-"@T*3'EL92P-"@T*("`@
M("`@("`@("!0;&5A<V4@86-K;F]W;&5D9V4@<F5C96EP="!O9B!T:&ES(&UE
M<W-A9V4N#0H-"B`@("`@("`@("`@4F5G87)D:6YG('EO=7(@<F5S<&]N<V4@
M;VX@=&AE("=M86IO<FET>2<@:7-S=64L($D@:&%V92!N;R!D;W5B=`T*>6]U
M#0IT86QK960@=&\@37(N($AE<GH@86YD($UR+B!$=WEE<BP@8G5T(&1I9"!T
M:&5Y(&%C='5A;&QY(&-O;F-U<B!W:71H('EO=7(-"G)U;&EN9RP@86YD('=A
M<R!T:&ES('9E<F)A;&QY(&]R(&EN('=R:71I;F<O96UA:6PN($D@:&%V92!W
M<FET=&5N('1O('1H96T-"F)U="!H879E(&YO="!R96-E:79E9"!A(')E<W!O
M;G-E+B`@1&ED(&%N>6]N92!F<F]M('1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@1&5P87)T;65N
M=`T*8V]N8W5R+B!))V0@;&EK92!T;R!T86QK('1O('1H96T@86QS;RX-"@T*
M("`@("`@("`@("!9;W4@:&%V92!T;VQD(&UE(&%B;W5T('1H:7,@3ED@;&%W
M+B`@0V]U;&0@>6]U('%U;W1E(&UE('1H90T*86-T=6%L#0IP87-S86=E+B`@
M0V%N('EO=2!E>'!L86EN('=H>2!T:&ES(&%P<&QI97,@=&\@245%12=S(#@P
M,"L@<W1A;F1A<F1S('=O<FMI;F<-"F=R;W5P<S\-"@T*("`@("`@("`@("!)
M<VXG="!T:&5R92!A(&QE9V%L('!R:6YC:7!L92!T:&%T('-A>7,@=&AA="!I
M9B!E=F5R>6]N92!F;VQL;W=S#0IA#0IG:79E;B!L87<@86YD(&EG;F]R97,@
M86YO=&AE<BP@:70G<R!/2R!T;R!C;VYT:6YU92!T;R!I9VYO<F4@:70_("!)
M(')E<75E<W0-"F$@;&5G86P@;W!I;FEO;B!O;B!T:&%T+@T*#0H@("`@("`@
M("`@($%L<V\L($D@86T@;F]T('%U:6-K('1O(&-O;7!L86EN+"!B=70@22!N
M965D(&UU8V@@9F%S=&5R#0IR97-P;VYS90T*=&EM92X-"@T*2FEM(%-C:&]E
M;FEN9PT*0VAA:7(L(%`Q-C`P+C$@4U5/(%='#0H-"@T*#0H-"BTM+2TM3W)I
M9VEN86P@365S<V%G92TM+2TM#0I&<F]M.B!L+FTN<VUI=&A`:65E92YO<F<@
M6VUA:6QT;SIL+FTN<VUI=&A`:65E92YO<F==#0I396YT.B!4:'5R<V1A>2P@
M4V5P=&5M8F5R(#$S+"`R,#`Q(#DZ,SD@04T-"E1O.B!*86UE<RY38VAO96YI
M;F=`;6%I;#$N;6]N;6]U=&@N87)M>2YM:6P-"D-C.B!S:WED;V=`<&]S=&]F
M9FEC92YP86-B96QL+FYE=#L@:BYG;W)M86Y`:65E92YO<F<[#0IS+G1A=&EN
M97)`:65E92YO<F<[(&4N:&5R>D!I965E+F]R9SL@9'=Y97(N<F]B97)T0&1O
M<G-E>6QA=RYC;VT-"E-U8FIE8W0Z(%)E<75E<W0@9F]R(%)U;&5S(&%D=FEC
M92X-"@T*#0I-<BX@(%-C:&]E;FEN9RP-"@T*#0H-"@T*#0I)(&AA=F4@<F5V
M:65W960@>6]U<B!Q=65S=&EO;G,@=VET:"!)145%($QE9V%L(&-O=6YS96P@
M4F]B97)T($1W>65R(&]F#0I$;W)S97D@)B!7:&ET;F5Y+"!A;F0@1&ER96-T
M;W(@16UE<FET=7,@17)I8R!(97)Z('=H;R!I<R!C;VUM:7-S:6]N960@8GD-
M"G1H92!)145%(%!R97-I9&5N="!T;R!B92!T:&4@;&EA<V]N('=I=&@@9V]V
M97)N86YC92!A;F0@;&5G86P@:7-S=65S+@T*1F]L;&]W:6YG(&EN8VQU9&5D
M(&EN('EO=7(@;W)I9VEN86P@=&5X="!I;B!R960@87)E(&]U<B!A;G-W97)S
M+@T*#0H-"DEN(&%D9&ET:6]N+"!R96=A<F1I;F<@>6]U<B!R=6QI;F<@=&AA
M="!T:&4@=V]R:VEN9R!G<F]U<"!I<R!A;B!A<W-E;6)L>2P-"G=E(&9I;F0@
M=&AA="!U;F1E<B!.97<@66]R:R!,87<@86X@07-S96UB;'D@:7,@82!M965T
M:6YG(&]F('1H92!M96UB97)S#0IC86QL960@9F]R('-P96-I9FEC(')E87-O
M;G,L(&%N9"!M=7-T(&)E(&-O;7!R:7-E9"!O9B!M96UB97)S+B`@4VEN8V4-
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M"@T*#0I,>6QE(%-M:71H#0H-"@T*#0H-"@T*/B!,>6QE+`T*/@T*/B`@("`@
M("!)('5N9&5R<W1A;F0@>6]U(&-A;B!H96QP(&UE('=I=&@@<V]M92!R=6QE
M<RX@($D@8VAA:7(@4#$V,#`N,0T*/B!3=&%N9&%R9"!5<'!E<B!/;G1O;&]G
M>2`H4U5/*2!71RP@:'1T<#HO+W-U;RYI965E+F]R9RX@($AE<F4@87)E('1H
M90T*<V%L:65N=`T*/B!F86-T<R!A;F0@<&]S=&EN9W,N#0H^#0H^("`@(&$N
M(%-53R!71R!C;VYD=6-T960@86X@96UA:6P@8F%L;&]T(&]F('=H971H97(@
M82!D;V-U;65N="!S:&]U;&0-"F)E8V]M92!A#0H^(&)A<V4@9&]C=6UE;G0N
M("!4:&4@8F%L;&]T('=A<R!O<&5N(&9O<B`S+7=E96MS+B!)="!P87-S960@
M,3<M,38L('=I=&@@.0T*/B!!0E-404E.4RX-"@T*#0I!;G-W97(Z("!.97<@
M66]R:R!.;W0M9F]R+5!R;V9I="!,87<@86YD('1H92!)145%($)Y;&%W<R!S
M=&%T92!T:&%T('1O('!A<W,-"F$@;6]T:6]N#0IR97%U:7)E<R!A(&UA:F]R
M:71Y(&]F('1H;W-E('!R97-E;G0L(&%N9"!N;W0@82!M86IO<FET>2!O9B!T
M:&]S92!P<F5S96YT#0IA;F0@=F]T:6YG+B`@268@-#(@=F]T:6YG(&UE;6)E
M<G,@=V5R92!I;G9O;'9E9"P@=&AE;B!A(&UA:F]R:71Y(&]F(#(R+B!W87,-
M"@T*<F5Q=6ER960@9F]R('!A<W-A9V4@;V8@=&AE(&UO=&EO;BP@86YD('1H
M97)E9F]R92!T:&4@;6]T:6]N(&9A:6QE9"X-"CX-"CX@("`@8BX@22!A;FYO
M=6YC960@=&AE(')E<W5L=',@;VX@075G(#$V=&@L('1H96X@='=O('!E;W!L
M92`H=VAO(&AA9"!V;W1E9`T*#0IT;PT*/B!!0E-404E.*2!S86ED('1H97D@
M=V%N=&5D('1O(&-H86YG92!T:&5I<B!V;W1E<R!T;R!.3RX-"@T*#0I!;G-W
M97(Z(%EO=2!D;R!N;W0@<V%Y(&5X86-T;'D@=VAA="!W87,@86YN;W5N8V5D
M+"!B=70@:70@<VAO=6QD(&AA=F4@8F5E;@T*=&AA="!T:&4-"G9O=&4@9F%I
M;&5D+"!D=64@=&\@82!L86-K(&]F(&$@;6%J;W)I='DN#0H^#0H^("`@(&,N
M($)O8B!3<&EL;&5R<RP@82!354\@=F]T:6YG(&UE;6)E<BP@;6%D92!A(&UO
M=&EO;B!T;R!R96-O;G-I9&5R+B`@270-"@T*/B!A<G)I=F5D(&%T(#$R.C`W
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M12!";V%R9"!O9@T*1&ER96-T;W)S('-H;W5L9`T*8VQA<FEF>2!W:&%T('1H
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M(%)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S+`T*#0IW92!B96QI979E('1H870@82!C97)T86EN
M(&%M;W5N="!O9B!F;&5X:6)I;&ET>2!S:&]U;&0@8F4@=7-E9"!I;B!A;B!E
M9F9O<G0-"@T*=&\@86-H:79E(&%N(&5Q=6%T:6)L92!R97-U;'0N/@T*#0H-
M"CX@("`@9"X@0F]B(%-P:6QL97)S(&]R:6=I;F%L;'D@=F]T960@3D\N("!)
M<R!H92!P97)M:71T960@=&\@;6%K92!A(&UO=&EO;@T*#0IT;PT*/B!R96-O
M;G-I9&5R/R`@268@;F]T+"!D;V5S('1H:7,@<V5T=&QE<R!T:&4@;6%T=&5R
M/R`@2&4@8VQA:6US(&AE(&-A;B!I9@T*4U5/#0H^(&ES(&-O;G-I9&5R960@
M82`G4W1A;F1I;F<@0V]M;6ET=&5E+"<@8G5T(&EN9&EC871E<R!H92!C86XG
M="!I9B!354\@:7,@86X-"@T*/B!!<W-E;6)L>2X@(%=H96X@22!F;W5N9"!H
M:7,@;6]T:6]N(&]U="!O9B!O<F1E<BP@22!A<W-E<G1E9"!354\@=V%S(&%N
M#0H^($%S<V5M8FQY+@T*#0H-"D%N<W=E<CH@665S+"!S:6YC92!H92!W87,@
M86-T=6%L;'D@82!M96UB97(@;V8@=&AE('!R979A:6QI;F<L(&]R(&EN('1H
M:7,-"F-A<V4@=&AE#0IL;W-I;F<@<VED92X-"CX-"CX@("`@(&8N($AE('1H
M96X@87!P96%L960@;7D@<G5L:6YG('1O('1H92!354\@;65M8F5R<VAI<"!A
M;F0@:70@=V%S#0IS96-O;F1E9`T*/B!B>2!,964@075S<&ET>BX@0V%N(&AE
M(&%P<&5A;"!S;VUE=&AI;F<@;&EK92!T:&ES/PT*#0H-"D%N<W=E<CH@665S
M+"!A;GD@;65M8F5R(&]F(&$@8V]M;6ET=&5E(&UA>2!A<'!E86P@82!R=6QI
M;F<@;V8@=&AE($-H86ER+@T*#0H-"@T*#0H-"CX@66]U<B!T:6UE;'D@9W5I
M9&%N8V4@=V]U;&0@8F4@;6]S="!A<'!R96-I871E9"X-"CX-"CX@2FEM(%-C
M:&]E;FEN9PT*/B`W,S(M-3,R+34X,3(-"CX-"@T*#0H-"@T*#0I,>6QE($TN
M(%-M:71H#0I3=&%F9B!$:7)E8W1O<B`M($-O<G!O<F%T92!!8W1I=FET:65S
6#0HW,S(@.3@Q+3,T-#<-"@T*#0H-"@==
`
end
begin 600 Attach 5 - Teknowledge Legal Opinion.txt
M#0H-"@T*#0I*86YU87)Y(#$U+"`R,#`R#0H-"@T*#0I!9&%M(%!E87-E#0I4
M96MN;W=L961G92!#;W)P;W)A=&EO;@T*,3@Q,"!%;6)A<F-A9&5R;R!2;V%D
M#0I086QO($%L=&\L($-!("`Y-#,P,PT*#0I213H@($UE;6]R86YD=6T@;VX@
M245%12!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(%9O=&4-"@T*1&5A<B!!9&%M.@T*#0I4:&4@
M<75E<W1I;VX@<')E<V5N=&5D(&ES('=H971H97(@82!V;W1E('1A:V5N(&EN
M(&-O;FYE8W1I;VX@=VET:"!A;B!E+6UA:6P@8F%L;&]T(`T*8V]N9'5C=&5D
M(&)Y('1H92!0,38P,"XQ(%-T86YD87)D(%5P<&5R($]N=&]L;V=Y(%=O<FMI
M;F<@1W)O=7`@*'1H92`B5V]R:VEN9R`-"D=R;W5P(BD@=&\@9&5T97)M:6YE
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M<"!F<F]M('1H92`-"G-U<&5R:6]R(&5N=&ET:65S('=I=&AI;B!T:&4@245%
M12!A;F0@=6QT:6UA=&5L>2!T:&4@4W1A=&4@;V8@3F5W(%EO<FLN("`-"@T*
M0F]T=&]M(%5P#0H-"E1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(')E<&]R=',@=&\@0V]M
M<'5T97(@4V]C:65T>2`O(%-T86YD87)D<R!#;V]R9&EN871I;F<@0V]M;6ET
M=&5E(`T**'1H92`B4W!O;G-O<B(I+B`@5&AE(%-P;VYS;W(@<F5P;W)T<R!T
M;R!T:&4@4W1A;F1A<F1S($%C=&EV:71Y($)O87)D(&]F('1H92!)145%(`T*
M0V]M<'5T97(@4V]C:65T>2`H=&AE(")-:6YO<B!";V%R9"(I+B`@5&AE($UI
M;F]R($)O87)D(')E<&]R=',@=&\@=&AE($-O;7!U=&5R(`T*4V]C:65T>2!"
M;V%R9"!O9B!';W9E<FYO<G,@*'1H92`B4V]C:65T>2(I+B`@5&AE(%-O8VEE
M='D@<F5P;W)T<R!T;R!T:&4@4W1A;F1A<F1S(`T*07-S;V-I871I;VX@*'1H
M92`B36%J;W(@0F]A<F0B*2X@(%1H92!-86IO<B!";V%R9"!R97!O<G1S('1O
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M97,L('=H:6-H(`T*<')O=FED97,@82!P<F]V:7-I;VX@<')E8V5D96YC92!O
M9B!D;V-U;65N=',@=&\@=7-E9"!I;B!T:&4@:6YT97)P<F5T871I;VX@;V8@
M<')O=FES:6]N<R`-"F%N9"!T:&4@<F5S;VQU=&EO;B!O9B!C;VYF;&EC=',@
M8F5T=V5E;B!I;F-O;G-I<W1E;G0@<')O=FES:6]N<RX@(%1H92!P<F5C961E
M;F-E(&]F(`T*9&]C=6UE;G1S('=I;&P@<')O=FED92!T:&4@<F]A9&UA<"!F
M;W(@=&AE(')E=FEE=R!A="!H86YD+@T*#0I3<&5C:69I8V%L;'DL('1H92!3
M=&%N9&%R9',@06-T:79I=&EE<R!";V%R9"!0;VQI8VEE<R!A;F0@4')O8V5D
M=7)E<RP@4V5C=&EO;B`R('!R;W9I9&5S.B`-"DEN('1H92!E=F5N="!O9B!I
M;F-O;G-I<W1E;F-I97,@8F5T=V5E;B!T=V\@;W(@;6]R92!O9B!T:&4@86)O
M=F4@9&]C=6UE;G1S+"!T:&4@#0ID;V-U;65N="`H:6YD:6-A=&5D(&)Y(&5A
M<FQI97(@87!P96%R86YC92!O;B!T:&4@9F]L;&]W:6YG(&QI<W0I('-H86QL
M('1A:V4@#0IP<F5C961E;F-E.@T*,2X)245%12!">6QA=W,-"C(N"4E%144@
M4W1A;F1A<F1S($%S<V]C:6%T:6]N($)Y;&%W<PT*,RX)245%12!3=&%N9&%R
M9',@07-S;V-I871I;VX@3W!E<F%T:6]N<R!-86YU86P-"C0N"4E%144M4T$@
M4W1A;F1A<F1S($)O87)D($)Y;&%W<PT*-2X)245%12!0;VQI8VEE<R!A;F0@
M4')O8V5D=7)E<R!-86YU86PL(%-E8W1I;VX@.`T*-BX)245%12!";V%R9"!O
M9B!$:7)E8W1O<G,@4F5S;VQU=&EO;G,-"C<N"4E%144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S
M($)O87)D(&]F($]P97)A=&EO;G,@36%N=6%L#0HX+@E)145%($-3($-O;G-T
M:71U=&EO;B!A;F0@0GEL87=S#0HY+@E)145%($-3(%!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!0
M<F]C961U<F5S+"!396-T:6]N(#$Q#0HQ,"X)245%12!";V%R9"!O9B!';W9E
M<FYO<G,@4F5S;VQU=&EO;G,-"C$Q+@E)145%($-3(%-!0B!0)E`-"C$R+@E2
M;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<@T*,3,N"5-P;VYS;W(@4&]L:6-I97,@
M86YD(%!R;V-E9'5R97,-"C$T+@E7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(&]R(%-T=61Y($=R
M;W5P(%!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!0<F]C961U<F5S#0H-"DEN('1H92!I;G-T86YT
M('-I='5A=&EO;BP@<V5V97)A;"!A9&1I=&EO;F%L(&ET96US(&%R92!A<'!L
M:6-A8FQE('1H870@87)E(&YO="!L:7-T960L(&%N9"`-"G-E=F5R86P@;&ES
M=&5D(&ET96US(&%R92!I;F%P<&QI8V%B;&4N("`@1F]R(&EN<W1A;F-E+"!T
M:&4@245%12!">6QA=W,@<F5C96EV92!T:&5I<B`-"F%U=&AO<FET>2!F<F]M
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M<R!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R`H:71E;2`-"C$S*2!I;B!T:&ES(&-A<V4@<F5F
M97)S('1O($-O;7!U=&5R(%-O8VEE='D@4&]L:6-I97,@86YD(%!R;V-E9'5R
M97,L(&%N9"!T;R!T:&4@97AT96YT('1H870@#0IT:&5Y(')E9F5R96YC92!3
M96-T:6]N(#$Q+"!A<F4@<F5D=6YD86YT('=I=&@@:71E;2`Y+B`@0V]N<V5Q
M=65N=&QY+"!S:6YC92!T:&ES(&%N86QY<VES(`T*;VYL>2!R969E<G,@=&\@
M=&AE(')E;&5V86YT(%-E8W1I;VX@,3$L(&ET96T@,3,@=VEL;"!B92!D96QE
M=&5D(&%N9"!I=&5M(#D@=VEL;"!R971A:6X@:71S(`T*;W)D97(@;V8@<')E
M8V5D96YC92X@($%D9&ET:6]N86QL>2P@;F\@245%12!";V%R9"!O9B!';W9E
M<FYO<G,@4F5S;VQU=&EO;G,@;W(@245%12`-"D)O87)D(&]F($1I<F5C=&]R
M<R!297-O;'5T:6]N<R!P97)T86EN('1O('1H92!I<W-U92!A="!H86YD+"!A
M;F0@8V]N<V5Q=65N=&QY('=I;&P@;F]T(&)E(`T*:6YC;'5D960@:6X@=&AI
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M,"X)245%12!#4R!0;VQI8VEE<R!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<RP@4V5C=&EO;B`Q
M,0T*,3$N"4E%144@0U,@4T%"(%`F4`T*,3(N"5)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F
M($]R9&5R#0H-"E-O+"!W;W)K:6YG(&9R;VT@=&AE(&)O='1O;2!U<"P@=V4@
M;&]O:R!A="!2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<BX@(%)O8F5R="=S(%)U
M;&5S(&]F(`T*3W)D97(@8V]N=&%I;G,@<')O=FES:6]N<R!T:&%T(&1E=&5R
M;6EN92!H;W<@=&\@9&5T97)M:6YE('=H870@8V]N<W1I='5T97,@82!M86IO
M<FET>2`-"G9O=&4N("!#;VYS97%U96YT;'DL(&)Y('1H92!A=71H;W)I='D@
M9W)A;G1E9"!I;B!T:&4@245%12!#4R!304(@4"90+"!T:&ES('!R;W9I<VEO
M;B`-"G=O=6QD('!R979A:6PN#0H-"DYE>'0L('=E(&QO;VL@870@=&AE($E%
M144@0U,@4T%"(%`F4"!T;R!D971E<FUI;F4@:68@=&AE<F4@:7,@86YY=&AI
M;F<@8V]N=')A9&EC=&]R>2X-"E-E8W1I;VX@,2XQ('-T871E<R!T:&4@<'5R
M<&]S92!O9B!T:&4@4T%".@T*(E-T86YD87)D<R!D979E;&]P;65N="!A8W1I
M=FET:65S(&EN('1H92!)145%($-3(&%R92!T:&4@<F5S<&]N<VEB:6QI='D@
M;V8@=&AE(`T*4T%"(&%N9"!C;VUP;'D@=VET:"!T:&4@<&]L:6-I97,@86YD
M('!R;V-E9'5R97,@;V8@=&AE(&1O8W5M96YT<R!L:7-T960@8F5L;W<N("`-
M"D%D9&ET:6]N86P@<&]L:6-I97,@86YD('!R;V-E9'5R97,L('=H96X@;F5C
M97-S87)Y+"!A<F4@9&5F:6YE9"!I;B!T:&ES(`T*9&]C=6UE;G0N(@T*#0I#
M;VYS97%U96YT;'DL(&)Y('1H92!A=71H;W)I='D@;V8@=&AE($-O;7!U=&5R
M(%-O8VEE='DL('1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@06-T:79I='D@0F]A<F0@:7,@#0IC
M:&%R9V5D('=I=&@@=&AE(')E<W!O;G-I8FEL:71Y(&]F(&5N<W5R:6YG('1H
M870@=&AE(%=O<FMI;F<@1W)O=7`@9F]L;&]W<RP@86UO;F<@;W1H97(@#0II
M=&5M<RP@86YD(&YO='=I=&AS=&%N9&EN9R!A;GD@9&ER96-T:6]N('1O('1H
M92!C;VYT<F%R>2!I;B!A(&1O8W5M96YT(&]F(&AI9VAE<B`-"G!R96-E9&5N
M8V4L(%)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F($]R9&5R(&EN(&ET<R!D979E;&]P;65N
M="!O9B!T:&4@9')A9G0@<W1A;F1A<F0N#0H-"E1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@0V]M
M;6ET=&5E($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R!A<F4@;W5T;&EN
M960@:6X@4V5C=&EO;B`T(&%S(`T*9F]L;&]W<SH-"C0N,"!#4R!3=&%N9&%R
M9',@0V]M;6ET=&5E($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<PT*-"XQ
M($]V97)V:65W#0I4:&4@245%12!S=&%N9&%R9',@9&5V96QO<&UE;G0@<')O
M8V5S<R!I;F-L=61E<R!T=V\@=F]L=6YT965R(&=R;W5P<SH@(`T*82!3<&]N
M<V]R+"!W:&\@<W5P97)V:7-E<R!A;&P@<&AA<V5S(&]F('1H92!D979E;&]P
M;65N="!A;F0@;6%I;G1E;F%N8V4@#0IO9B!A('-T86YD87)D+"!A;F0@82!S
M=&%N9&%R9',@9&5V96QO<&EN9R!C;VUM:71T964@<W5C:"!A<R!A(%='(&]R
M(%-'+"`-"G=H:6-H(&ES(')E<W!O;G-I8FQE('1O('1H92!3<&]N<V]R+"!A
M;F0@=VAI8V@@9&5V96QO<',@=&AE(&1R869T(`T*<W1A;F1A<F0N("!!(&1R
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M97)S:&EP+@T*#0I4:&5R969O<F4L('5N9&5R('1H92!)145%(%-!0B!0)E`L
M('1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(&%N9"!T:&4@4W!O;G-O<B!A<F4@9&ER96-T
M960@=&\@#0IF;VQL;W<@4F]B97)T)W,@4G5L97,@;V8@3W)D97(L('=I=&@@
M=&AE('!R;W9I<V\@=&AA="!A('%U;W)U;2!S:&%L;"!C;VYS:7-T(&]F(&]N
M92UH86QF(`T*;V8@=&AE('9O=&EN9R!M96UB97)S:&EP+@T*#0I4:&4@4W1A
M;F1A<F1S($%C=&EV:71I97,@0F]A<F0@<F5F97)E;F-E<R!I=',@875T:&]R
M:71Y('1O('-O(&1I<F5C="!I;B!396-T:6]N(#4@;V8@=&AE(`T*245%12!3
M04(@4"90.@T*-2XR("!297-P;VYS:6)I;&ET:65S(&]F('1H92!304(-"D%S
M(&5S=&%B;&ES:&5D(&EN(%-E8W1I;VX@,2!O9B!!<G1I8VQE(%A)(&]F('1H
M92!)145%($-3($-O;G-T:71U=&EO;B!A;F0@#0I">6QA=W,@6U)E9BX@-ETL
M('1H92!304(@:7,@<F5S<&]N<VEB;&4@9F]R.B`@<F5C;VUM96YD:6YG('1O
M('1H92!#4R`-"D)O87)D(&]F($=O=F5R;F]R<R!A;&P@<&]L:6-I97,@86YD
M('!R86-T:6-E<R!W:71H(')E<W!E8W0@=&\@<W1A;F1A<F1S.R`-"F]V97)S
M:6=H="!R97-P;VYS:6)I;&ET>2!F;W(@86QL('-T86YD87)D<R!A8W1I=FET
M:65S('1O(&%S<W5R92!C;VYF;W)M86YC92`-"G1O(&%P<')O=F5D('!O;&EC
M:65S(&%N9"!P<F]C961U<F5S.R!A;F0@=&\@<')O=FED92!G=6ED86YC92!A
M;F0@#0IR97-O;'5T:6]N(&]F(&ES<W5E<R!I;B!A<F5A<R!N;W0@<W!E8VEF
M:6-A;&QY(&-O=F5R960@8GD@=&AE('!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"`-"G!R;V-E9'5R
M97,N("`-"@T*4W!E8VEF:6-A;&QY+"!W:71H(')E9V%R9"!T;R!3<&]N<V]R
M<SH-"C8N,2`@4W!O;G-O<B!38V]P90T*16%C:"!3<&]N<V]R('-H86QL(&AA
M=F4@82!S8V]P92!A<'!R;W9E9"!B>2!T:&4@4T%"+@T*-BXR(%-T86YD87)D
M<R!$979E;&]P;65N="!0<F]C97-S(%M);F9O<FUA=&EV95T-"E1H92!3=&%N
M9&%R9',@1&5V96QO<&UE;G0@4')O8V5S<R!S:&]U;&0@;F]R;6%L;'D@8V]N
M<VES="!O9CH@(&]P=&EO;F%L(`T*4T<@;W!E<F%T:6]N(&YO="!T;R!E>&-E
M960@<VEX("@V*2!M;VYT:',[(%!!4B!A<'!R;W9A;"!B>2!T:&4@4W!O;G-O
M<CL@#0I005(@87!P<F]V86P@8GD@=&AE($E%15-".R!71R!D979E;&]P;65N
M="!O9B!A(&1R869T('-T86YD87)D.R`-"F%P<')O=F%L('1O(&)A;&QO="!B
M>2!T:&4@4W!O;G-O<CL@<F5C:7)C=6QA=&EO;B]N96=A=&EV92!B86QL;W0@
M<F5S;VQU=&EO;B`-"F)Y('1H92!71R!A<R!N96-E<W-A<GD[(%)E=D-O;2!S
M=6)M:7-S:6]N(&%P<')O=F%L(&)Y('1H92!3<&]N<V]R.R`-"F%N9"!S=&%N
M9&%R9"!A<'!R;W9A;"!B>2!T:&4@245%15-"+@T*#0I4:&4@;VYL>2!D:7)E
M8W0@<F5F97)E;F-E('1O(%=O<FMI;F<@1W)O=7`@4')O8V5D=7)E<R!A<F4@
M9F]U;F0@:6X@4V5C=&EO;B`W+"!A;F0@;VYL>2`-"G!E<G1A:6X@=&\@=&AE
M(&9A8W0@=&AA="!T:&4@0VAA:7(L(&%N9"!6:6-E+4-H86ER(&]F(%=O<FMI
M;F<@1W)O=7!S('-H86QL(&)E($E%144@;W(@#0I#4RUA9F9I;&EA=&4@;65M
M8F5R<RX-"@T*26X@9F]L;&]W:6YG('1H92!R;V%D;6%P(&QA:60@;W5T(&EN
M('1H92!)145%($-3(%-!0B!0)E`L('=E(&YE>'0@;&]O:R!A="!396-T:6]N
M(#$Q(`T*;V8@=&AE($E%144@0U,@4&]L:6-I97,@86YD(%!R;V-E9'5R97,N
M("!4:&ES('-E8W1I;VX@;W5T;&EN97,@=&AE('!R;V-E9'5R97,@8GD@=VAI
M8V@@#0ID<F%F="!S=&%N9&%R9',@9&5V96QO<&5D('=I=&AI;B!T:&4@0V]M
M<'5T97(@4V]C:65T>2!A<F4@<W5B;6ET=&5D('1O('1H92!)145%(`T*4W1A
M;F1A<F1S($)O87)D+"!I;B!O<F1E<B!T;R!B92!A<'!R;W9E9"P@861O<'1E
M9"!A;F0@<'5B;&ES:&5D(&%S($E%144@4W1A;F1A<F1S+B`@#0I4:&ES(%-E
M8W1I;VX@9G5R=&AE<B!S=&%T97,@=&AA="!A<R!F87(@87,@=&AE(')E;&%T
M:6]N<VAI<"!O9B!T:&4@0V]M<'5T97(@4V]C:65T>2!T;R!)145%(`T*4W1A
M;F1A<F1S($)O87)D(&ES(&-O;F-E<FYE9"P@=&AE('!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!P
M<F]C961U<F5S(&]F(%-E8W1I;VX@,3$@87,@97-T86)L:7-H960@8GD@#0IT
M:&4@4T%"(&]P97)A=&4@=VET:&EN('1H92!S8V]P92!O9B!T:&4@245%12!"
M>6QA=W,N#0H-"E1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@06-T:79I=&EE<R!";V%R9"!C;&%I
M;2!O9B!A=71H;W)I='D@:6X@4V5C=&EO;B`U(&]F('1H92!)145%(%-!0B!0
M)E`@:7,@#0IC;VYF:7)M960@:6X@07)T:6-L92!8(&]F('1H92!#;VUP=71E
M<B!3;V-I971Y($)Y;&%W<R!W:&EC:"!T:&%T.@T*(E1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@
M06-T:79I=&EE<R!";V%R9"!S:&%L;"!F;W)M=6QA=&4@=&AE('!O;&EC:65S
M(&%N9"!P<F%C=&EC97,@=VET:"`-"G)E<W!E8W0@=&\@<W1A;F1A<F1S+"!A
M;F0@;6]N:71O<B!A;&P@<W1A;F1A<F1S(&%C=&EV:71I97,@=&\@87-S=7)E
M(&-O;F9O<FUA;F-E('1O(`T*87!P<F]V960@<&]L:6-I97,@86YD('!R86-T
M:6-E<RXB#0H-"E1H92!#;VUP=71E<B!3;V-I971Y(&ET<V5L9B!I<R!O<F=A
M;FEZ960@=VET:&EN('1H92!)145%+"!A;F0@:7,@;V)L:6=A=&5D('5N9&5R
M($%R=&EC;&4@#0I)22P@4V5C=&EO;B!O9B!T:&4@0V]M<'5T97(@4V]C:65T
M>2!#;VYS=&ET=71I;VX@=&\@;W!E<F%T92!W:71H:6X@=&AE($E%144@8V]N
M<W1I='5T:6]N(`T*86YD(&)Y;&%W<R!A;F0@=VET:&EN('-U8V@@;W1H97(@
M<&]L:6-I97,@86YD('!R;V-E9'5R97,@=&AA="!A<F4@875T:&]R:7IE9"!U
M;F1E<B!T:&5S92`-"F1O8W5M96YT<RX-"@T*2&%V:6YG(&5S=&%B;&ES:&5D
M('1H92!O<&5R871I;F<@<')O=&]C;VQS(&%T('1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P
M+"!3<&]N<V]R+"!-:6YO<B!";V%R9"`-"F%N9"!3;V-I971Y(&QE=F5L<RP@
M=V4@;6]V92!U<"!T;R!T:&4@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0@;&5V96PL('=H;W-E(&-O
M;G1R;VQL:6YG(&1O8W5M96YT<R`-"F%R92!T:&4@245%12!3=&%N9&%R9',@
M07-S;V-I871I;VX@0GEL87=S+"!)145%(%-T86YD87)D<R!!<W-O8VEA=&EO
M;B!/<&5R871I;VYS(`T*36%N=6%L+"!)145%+5-!(%-T86YD87)D<R!";V%R
M9"!">6QA=W,L(&%N9"!)145%+5-!(%-T86YD87)D<R!";V%R9"!O9B`-"D]P
M97)A=&EO;G,@36%N=6%L+B`@5V4@=VEL;"!A;'-O('1A:V4@82!B<FEE9B!D
M971O=7(@=&\@=&AE(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!L979E;"!W:71H($E%144@#0I0
M;VQI8VEE<R!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R!-86YU86PL(%-E8W1I;VX@.`T*#0I)
M145%+5-!(%-T86YD87)D<R!";V%R9"!O9B!/<&5R871I;VYS($UA;G5A;"!S
M=&%T97,@:6X@4V5C=&EO;B`Q+C(@=&AA="!T:&4@#0IO<F=A;FEZ871I;VX@
M86YD(&)A<VEC('!R;V-E9'5R97,@;V8@=&AE($E%144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S
M($)O87)D(&%R92!C;W9E<F5D(&)Y('1H92`-"DE%144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S
M($)O87)D($)Y;&%W<RP@86YD('1H870@=&AE('!R;W9I<VEO;G,@;V8@=&AE
M($E%144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S(`T*0F]A<F0@;V8@3W!E<F%T:6]N<R!-86YU
M86P@<W5P<&QE;65N="!T:&4@<')O=FES:6]N<R!O9B!T:&4@245%12U302!3
M=&%N9&%R9',@0F]A<F0@#0I">6QA=W,L('=H:6-H('-H86QL(&)E('1H92!P
M<F5V86EL:6YG(&1O8W5M96YT(&EN('1H92!E=F5N="!O9B!C;VYF;&EC="X@
M($QI:V4@=&AE(`T*4V]C:65T>2P@36EN;W(@0F]A<F0L(%-P;VYS;W(L(&%N
M9"!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(&)E;&]W(&ET+"!T:&4@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0@:7,@
M#0ID:7)E8W1E9"!T;R!C;VYD=6-T(&)U<VEN97-S(&EN(&%C8V]R9&%N8V4@
M=VET:"!2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<BX@(`T*#0I396-T:6]N(#4@
M;V8@=&AE($E%144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S($)O87)D(&]F($]P97)A=&EO;G,@
M36%N=6%L(&1I<F5C=',@=&AE(%-P;VYS;W(@=&\@#0IO<&5R871E(&EN(&%C
M8V]R9&%N8V4@=VET:"!A('=R:71T96X@<V5T(&]F('!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!P
M<F]C961U<F5S('=H:6-H(&1O(&YO="!C;VYF;&EC="`-"G=I=&@@=&AE($E%
M144M4T$@4W1A;F1A<F1S($)O87)D($]P97)A=&EO;G,@36%N=6%L+B`@26X@
M=&AE(&-A<V4@;V8@82!3<&]N<V]R('1H870@:7,@82`-"F-O;6UI='1E92!O
M9B!A;B!)145%(%-O8VEE='DL('1H92!3;V-I971Y(&UA>2!D979E;&]P(&$@
M8V]M;6]N('-E="!O9B!0("8@4"!F;W(@#0IS=&%N9&%R9',@9&5V96QO<&UE
M;G0@=&AA="!I<R!A<'!L:6-A8FQE('1O(&%L;"!3<&]N<V]R<R!I;B!T:&%T
M(%-O8VEE='DN("!);B!T:&4@:6YS=&%N="`-"F-A<V4L('1H92!3<&]N<V]R
M(&ES('1H92!#;VUP=71E<B!3;V-I971Y("\@4W1A;F1A<F1S($-O;W)D:6YA
M=&EN9R!#;VUM:71T964@;W!E<F%T:6YG(`T*=6YD97(@=&AE($UI;F]R($)O
M87)D(&%N9"!3;V-I971Y(%!O;&EC:65S(&%N9"!0<F]C961U<F5S+@T*#0I"
M969O<F4@;6]V:6YG(&]N('1O('1H92!R96UA:6YI;F<@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0@
M9&]C=6UE;G1S+"!W92!A<F4@9&ER96-T960@8GD@=&AE(`T*<')E8V5D96YC
M92!O9B!D;V-U;65N=',@=&\@<F5V:65W(&%N($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!D;V-U
M;65N="P@<W!E8VEF:6-A;&QY(%-E8W1I;VX@."!O9B`-"G1H92!)145%(%!O
M;&EC>2!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R!-86YU86PN("!4:&ES('!R;W9I<VEO;B!P
M<F]V:61E<R!T:&%T(')E<W!O;G-I8FEL:71Y(&9O<B`-"G1H92!S=&%N9&%R
M9&EZ871I;VX@86-T:79I=&EE<R!O9B!)145%(&ES(&%S<VEG;F5D(&)Y('1H
M92!";V%R9"!O9B!$:7)E8W1O<G,@=&\@=&AE(`T*4W1A;F1A<F1S($%S<V]C
M:6%T:6]N+"!O<B!W:&%T('=E(&%R92!R969E<G)I;F<@=&\@87,@=&AE($UA
M:F]R($)O87)D+B`@4W!E8VEF:6-A;&QY+"!T:&4@#0I3=&%N9&%R9',@07-S
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M=&EO;G,@;6%N=6%L<R!O9B!I=',@<W5B<VED:6%R>2!B;V%R9',@86YD(`T*
M8V]M;6ET=&5E<RXB#0H-"D1E=&%I;&5D('!R;V-E9'5R97,@87)E(&9U<G1H
M97(@;W5T;&EN960@:6X@4V5C=&EO;B`X+C0Z#0HB1&5T86EL960@<')O8V5D
M=7)E<R!A;F0@<F5Q=6ER96UE;G1S(&9O<B!S=&%N9&%R9',@86-T:79I=&EE
M<R!W:71H:6X@=&AE($E%144@#0IA<F4@<V5T(&9O<G1H(&EN('1H92!)145%
M(%-T86YD87)D<R!!<W-O8VEA=&EO;B!B>6QA=W,@86YD(&]P97)A=&EO;G,@
M;6%N=6%L<R`-"F%N9"!T:&4@8GEL87=S(&%N9"!O<&5R871I;VYS(&UA;G5A
M;',@;V8@:71S('-U8G-I9&EA<GD@8F]A<F1S(&%N9"`-"F-O;6UI='1E97.%
M(@T*#0I2971U<FYI;F<@=&\@=&AE($UA:F]R($)O87)D(&1O8W5M96YT<RP@
M=&AE(%-!(%-T86YD87)D<R!";V%R9"!">6QA=W,@9&]N)W0@<')O=FED92`-
M"F%N>2!P87)T:6-U;&%R(&1I<F5C=&EO;B!T;R!T:&4@:7-S=64@870@:&%N
M9"P@;W1H97(@=&AA;B!C;&%I;6EN9R!T:&5I<B!A=71H;W)I='D@=6YD97(@
M#0IS96-T:6]N(%,M-#`Q(&]F('1H92!)145%($)Y;&%W<RX-"@T*5&AE(%-T
M86YD87)D<R!!<W-O8VEA=&EO;B!/<&5R871I;VYS($UA;G5A;"!A<W-E<G1S
M('1H870@=&AE(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!A;F0@8F%S:6,@#0IP;VQI8VEE<R!O
M9B!T:&4@245%12!3=&%N9&%R9',@07-S;V-I871I;VX@87)E(&-O=F5R960@
M8GD@=&AE($E%144@4W1A;F1A<F1S(`T*07-S;V-I871I;VX@0GEL87=S+"!A
M;F0@=&AA="!T:&4@4W1A;F1A<F1S($%S<V]C:6%T:6]N($]P97)A=&EO;G,@
M36%N=6%L('-U<'!L96UE;G1S(`T*=&AE('!R;W9I<VEO;G,@;V8@=&AE($E%
M144@4W1A;F1A<F1S($%S<V]C:6%T:6]N($)Y;&%W<RP@=VAI8V@@:7,@=&AE
M(&=O=F5R;FEN9R`-"F1O8W5M96YT(&EN('1H92!E=F5N="!O9B!C;VYF;&EC
M="X@($QI:V4@=&AE(%-O8VEE='DL($UI;F]R($)O87)D+"!3<&]N<V]R+"!A
M;F0@5V]R:VEN9R`-"D=R;W5P(&)E;&]W(&ET+"!T:&4@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0@
M:7,@86=A:6X@9&ER96-T960@=&\@8V]N9'5C="!B=7-I;F5S<R!I;B!A8V-O
M<F1A;F-E('=I=&@@#0I2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<B!U;F1E<B!3
M96-T:6]N(#0N,RX@(`T*#0I4:&4@9FEN86P@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0@9&]C=6UE
M;G0L('1H92!3=&%N9&%R9',@07-S;V-I871I;VX@0GEL87=S+"!C;&%I;7,@
M:71S(&%U=&AO<FET>2`-"F9R;VT@245%12!">6QA=R!)+3,P-"XV(&%N9"!E
M<W1A8FQI<VAE<R!T:&%T('1H92!)145%(%-T86YD87)D<R!!<W-O8VEA=&EO
M;B!S:&%L;"!B92`-"F1I<F5C=&5D(&)Y(&$@0F]A<F0@;V8@1V]V97)N;W)S
M+"!W:&\@<VAA;&P@8F4@<F5S<&]N<VEB;&4@9F]R(&5S=&%B;&ES:&EN9R!P
M;VQI8WD@86YD(`T*8V]N9'5C="!S=&%N9&%R9',M<F5L871E9"!A8W1I=FET
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M:6]N($DM,3`W(&1E9FEN97,@86X@#0I)145%(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;F%L('5N
M:70@:7,@82!S=6)S970@;V8@=&AE(&5N=&ER92!)145%(&UE;6)E<G-H:7`@
M=&AA="!H87,@8F5E;B!F;W)M960@#0IT;R!C87)R>2!O=70@<&%R=&EC=6QA
M<B!E9'5C871I;VYA;"P@9V5O9W)A<&AI8RP@<')O9F5S<VEO;F%L+"!T96-H
M;FEC86PL(&]R(&]T:&5R(`T*87!P<F]P<FEA=&4@86-T:79I=&EE<R!O9B!I
M;G1E<F5S="!A;F0@<V5R=FEC92!T;R!T:&]S92!W:&\@87)E(&UE;6)E<G,@
M;V8@=&AA="`-"F]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;F%L('5N:70@87,@<&5R;6ET=&5D(&)Y
M(&QA=RX-"@T*4V5C=&EO;B!)+3,P,"P@<W5B<V5C=&EO;B`S(&]F('1H92!)
M145%($)Y;&%W<R!C;W9E<FEN9R!';W9E<FYA;F-E(&%N9"!087)L:6%M96YT
M87)Y(`T*4')O8V5D=7)E<R!S=&%T97,@=&AA=#H@(`T*(DEM<&QE;65N=&%T
M:6]N(&]F('1H92!C;VYS=&ET=71I;VYA;"!P<F]V:7-I;VYS(&)Y('-P96-I
M9FEC(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;F%L('5N:71S(`T*86YD('1H96ER('!O;&EC:65S
M+"!I<R!C;VYT86EN960@:6X@=&AE<V4@245%12!">6QA=W,L('=H:6-H(&%R
M92!A<'!R;W9E9"!A;F0@#0IA;65N9&5D(&)Y('1H92!)145%($)O87)D(&]F
M($1I<F5C=&]R<RX@(%1H92!)145%(%!O;&EC>2!A;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R`-
M"DUA;G5A;"!C;VYT86EN<R!M;W)E(&1E=&%I;&5D('-T871E;65N=',@;V8@
M<W!E8VEF:6,@<&]L:6-I97,L(&]B:F5C=&EV97,@86YD(`T*<')O8V5D=7)E
M<R!W:&EC:"!M87D@8F4@87!P<F]V960@;VYL>2!B>2!T:&4@245%12!";V%R
M9"!O9B!$:7)E8W1O<G,N#0H-"E)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F($]R9&5R("AL
M871E<W0@<F5V:7-I;VXI('-H86QL(&)E('5S960@=&\@8V]N9'5C="!B=7-I
M;F5S<R!A="`-"FUE971I;F=S(&]F('1H92!)145%($)O87)D(&]F($1I<F5C
M=&]R<RP@17AE8W5T:79E($-O;6UI='1E92P@36%J;W(@0F]A<F1S+"`-"E-T
M86YD:6YG($-O;6UI='1E97,@86YD(&]T:&5R(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;F%L('5N
M:71S(&]F('1H92!)145%('5N;&5S<R!O=&AE<B`-"G)U;&5S(&]F('!R;V-E
M9'5R92!A<F4@<W!E8VEF:65D(&EN('1H92!.;W0M1F]R+5!R;V9I="!#;W)P
M;W)A=&EO;B!,87<@;V8@=&AE(`T*4W1A=&4@;V8@3F5W(%EO<FLL('1H92!)
M145%($-E<G1I9FEC871E(&]F($EN8V]R<&]R871I;VXL('1H92!)145%($-O
M;G-T:71U=&EO;BP@#0IT:&5S92!">6QA=W,L('1H92!)145%(%!O;&EC>2!A
M;F0@4')O8V5D=7)E<R!-86YU86PL(')E<V]L=71I;VYS(&]F('1H92!)145%
M(`T*0F]A<F0@;V8@1&ER96-T;W)S+"!O<B!T:&4@87!P;&EC86)L92!G;W9E
M<FYI;F<@9&]C=6UE;G1S(&]F('1H;W-E(&]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;F%L(`T*=6YI
M=',@<')O=FED960@<W5C:"!O<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!D;V-U;65N=',@87)E
M(&YO="!I;B!C;VYF;&EC="!W:71H(&%N>2!O9B!T:&4@#0IF;W)E9V]I;F<N
M(@T*#0I!9G1E<B!H879I;F<@<W=A;2!U<'-T<F5A;2!T:')O=6=H('1H92!-
M:6YO<B!";V%R9"P@4V]C:65T>2P@86YD($UA:F]R($)O87)D(`T*9&]C=6UE
M;G1S+"!W92!H879E(')E86-H960@82!P<F]V:7-I;VX@=&AA="!S<&5C:69I
M97,@=VAE;B!T:&4@=7-E(&]F(%)O8F5R="=S(%)U;&5S(&]F(`T*3W)D97(@
M<VAA;&P@;F]T(&)E('5S960@=&\@8V]N9'5C="!B=7-I;F5S<R!A="!A;B!O
M<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!U;FET(&]F('1H92!)145%+"!T:&%T(`T*8F5I;F<@
M=VAE;B!O=&AE<B!R=6QE<R!O9B!P<F]C961U<F4@87)E('-P96-I9FEE9"!I
M;B!T:&4@9&]C=6UE;G1S(')E9F5R96YC960@:6X@=&AE(`T*<')E8V5D96YC
M92!O9B!D;V-U;65N=',@;&ES="X@($AA=FEN9R!F;W5N9"!N;R!S=6-H(&1I
M<F5C=&EV92!S;R!F87(L('=E(&YE960@=&\@#0IC;VYT:6YU92!T:')O=6=H
M('1H92!R96UA:6YI;F<@245%12!">6QA=W,L($E%144@0V]N<W1I='5T:6]N
M(&%N9"!.97<@66]R:R!.;W0M9F]R+0T*4')O9FET($-O<G!O<F%T:6]N($QA
M=RX-"@T*3F]T('!A<G1I8W5L87)L>2!H96QP9G5L(&%T('1H:7,@<&]I;G0@
M:7,@4V5C=&EO;B!)+3,P,"P@<W5B<V5C=&EO;B`T(')E9V%R9&EN9R!T:&4@
M86-T:6]N(&]F(`T*=&AE($)O87)D(&]F($1I<F5C=&]R<R!A;F0@0V]M;6ET
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M;V8@=&AE(&UE;6)E<G,@<')E<V5N="`-"F%N9"!E;G1I=&QE9"!T;R!V;W1E
M+"!A="!T:&4@=&EM92!O9B!T:&4@=F]T92P@<')O=FED960@82!Q=6]R=6T@
M:7,@<')E<V5N="P@<VAA;&P@#0IB92!T:&4@86-T(&]F('1H92!";V%R9"!O
M9B!$:7)E8W1O<G,L(&%N>2!#;VUM:71T964@=&AE<F5O9BP@;W(@=&AE($UA
M:F]R(`T*0F]A<F0L(&]R(&%N>2!C;VUM:71T965S(&]F('1H92!F;W)G;VEN
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M=&EO;B!O<B!.97<@66]R:R!.;W0M9F]R+5!R;V9I="!#;W)P;W)A=&EO;B`-
M"DQA=RX-"@T*5&AE(')E;6%I;FEN9R!/<F=A;FEZ871I;VX@9&]C=6UE;G0L
M('1H92!)145%($-O;G-T:71U=&EO;BP@:6X@07)T:6-L92!)+"!396,N(#,L
M('-T871E<R`-"G1H870@=&AE($E%144@<VAA;&P@8V%R<GD@;W5T(&ET<R!G
M96YE<F%L(&%D;6EN:7-T<F%T:79E(&9U;F-T:6]N<R!I;B!A8V-O<F1A;F-E
M('=I=&@@=&AE(`T*3F5W(%EO<FL@3F]T+49O<BU0<F]F:70@0V]R<&]R871I
M;VX@3&%W+"!A;F0@:6X@07)T:6-L92!)22P@4V5C=&EO;B`Q(&5S=&%B;&ES
M:&5S('1H870@#0IT:&4@245%12!">6QA=W,@<VAA;&P@8F4@97-T86)L:7-H
M960@9F]R('1H92!P=7)P;W-E<R!O9B!G;W9E<FYI;F<@=&AE(&]P97)A=&EO
M;G,@86YD(`T*861M:6YI<W1R871I;VX@;V8@=&AE($E%144N#0H-"E1H:7,@
M8G)I;F=S('5S('1O(&$@<F5V:65W(&]F('1H92!R96QE=F%N="!396-T:6]N
M(#8Q,R!O9B!T:&4@3F5W(%EO<FL@3F]T+69O<BU0<F]F:70@#0I#;W)P;W)A
M=&EO;B!,87<@=VAI8V@@<W1A=&5S('1H870Z#0H@(`E396,N(#8Q,RX@(%9O
M=&4@;V8@;65M8F5R<RX-"F$I"45X8V5P="`@87,@;W1H97)W:7-E(')E<75I
M<F5D(&)Y('1H:7,@8VAA<'1E<B!O<B!B>2!T:&4@8V5R=&EF:6-A=&4@#0IO
M9B!I;F-O<G!O<F%T:6]N(&]R('1H92!B>2UL87=S(&%S('!E<FUI='1E9"!B
M>2`@=&AI<R!C:&%P=&5R+"`@#0ID:7)E8W1O<G,@('-H86QL(&)E(&5L96-T
M960@8GD@82!P;'5R86QI='D@;V8@=&AE('9O=&5S(&-A<W0@870@82`-"FUE
M971I;F<@;V8@;65M8F5R<R!B>2!T:&4@;65M8F5R<R!E;G1I=&QE9"!T;R`@
M=F]T92`@:6X@=&AE(`T*96QE8W1I;VXN#0IB*0E7:&5N979E<B!A;GD@8V]R
M<&]R871E(&%C=&EO;BP@;W1H97(@=&AA;B!T:&4@96QE8W1I;VX@;V8@#0ID
M:7)E8W1O<G,L(&ES('1O(&)E('1A:V5N('5N9&5R('1H:7,@8VAA<'1E<B!B
M>2!V;W1E(&]F('1H92`-"FUE;6)E<G,L(&ET('-H86QL+"!E>&-E<'0@87,@
M;W1H97)W:7-E(')E<75I<F5D(&)Y('1H:7,@8VAA<'1E<B!O<B`-"F)Y('1H
M92!C97)T:69I8V%T92!O9B!I;F-O<G!O<F%T:6]N(&]R(&)Y(&)Y+6QA=W,@
M87,@<&5R;6ET=&5D(&)Y(`T*=&AI<R!C:&%P=&5R+"!B92!A=71H;W)I>F5D
M(&)Y(&$@;6%J;W)I='D@;V8@=&AE('9O=&5S(&-A<W0@870@82`-"FUE971I
M;F<@;V8@;65M8F5R<R!B>2!T:&4@;65M8F5R<R!E;G1I=&QE9"!T;R!V;W1E
M('1H97)E;VXN#0IC*0E%>&-E<'0@87,@<')O=FED960@:6X@<&%R86=R87!H
M("AB*2P@86YY(')E9F5R96YC92!I;B!T:&ES(&-H87!T97(@#0IT;R!C;W)P
M;W)A=&4@86-T:6]N(&%T(&$@;65E=&EN9R!O9B!M96UB97)S(&)Y(")M86IO
M<FET>2!V;W1E(B`-"F]R(")T=V\M=&AI<F1S('9O=&4B('-H86QL(')E<75I
M<F4@=&AE(&%C=&EO;B!T;R!B92!T86ME;B!B>2!S=6-H(`T*<')O<&]R=&EO
M;B!O9B!T:&4@=F]T97,@8V%S="!A="!S=6-H(&UE971I;F<L('!R;W9I9&5D
M('1H870@=&AE(`T*869F:7)M871I=F4@=F]T97,@8V%S="!I;B!F879O<B!O
M9B!A;GD@<W5C:"!A8W1I;VX@<VAA;&P@8F4@870@;&5A<W0@#0IE<75A;"!T
M;R!T:&4@<75O<G5M+B`@($)L86YK('9O=&5S(&]R(&%B<W1E;G1I;VYS('-H
M86QL(&YO="!B92`-"F-O=6YT960@:6X@=&AE(&YU;6)E<B!O9B!V;W1E<R!C
M87-T+@T*#0I3=6)S96-T:6]N(%-E8W1I;VX@8RD@<')O=FED97,@=&AE(&-R
M:71I8V%L(&1I9F9E<F5N8V4@9G)O;2!2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E
M<B!O;B!T:&4@#0ID969I;FET:6]N(&]F('=H870@8V]N<W1I='5T97,@82!M
M86IO<FET>2X@($AA=FEN9R!S=V%M('5P<W1R96%M(&9R;VT@=&AE($UI;F]R
M($)O87)D(`T*9&]C=6UE;G1S('1H870@9&ER96-T('1H92!3<&]N<V]R(&%N
M9"!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(&EN('1H92!C;VYD=6-T(&]F('1H96ER(&)U<VEN
M97-S(&%T(`T*:&%N9"P@=&AR;W5G:"!T:&4@4V]C:65T>2P@36%J;W(@0F]A
M<F0@86YD($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!D;V-U;65N=',L('1H92!Q=65S=&EO;B!A
M="`-"FAA;F0@:7,@=VAE=&AE<B!T:&ES('!R;W9I<VEO;B!F;&]W<R!D;W=N
M<W1R96%M('1O('1H92!E>'1E;G0@=&AA="!I="!C;VYT<F]L<R!A;F0@9&ER
M96-T<R`-"G1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P(&EN('1H92!C;VYD=6-T(&]F(&ET
M<R!B=7-I;F5S<RX@(`T*#0I&;W)M('1H92!C;VYT97AT(&]F('1H92!!<G1I
M8VQE(#8@;V8@=&AE($YE=R!9;W)K($YO="UF;W(M4')O9FET($-O<G!O<F%T
M:6]N($-O9&4L(&ET(&ES(`T*8VQE87(@=&AA="!T:&5S92!P<F]V:7-I;VYS
M(&%P<&QY('-O;&5L>2!T;R!T:&4@8V]R<&]R871E(&=O=F5R;F%N8V4@;V8@
M=&AE($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;BP@#0IA;F0@;F]T('1O('1H92!B=7-I;F5S<R!C
M;VYD=6-T(&]F(&ET<R!/<F=A;FEZ871I;VYA;"!U;FET<RP@=VAI8V@@07)T
M:6-L92!)+"!S=6)S96-T:6]N(#0@#0ID969I;F5S(&%S(&9O;&QO=W,Z("`-
M"B)#;VYD=6-T:6YG(&]F(&%C=&EV:71I97,B(&]F(&$@8V]R<&]R871I;VX@
M;65A;G,@=&AE(&]P97)A=&EO;G,@9F]R('1H92!C;VYD=6-T(`T*;V8@=VAI
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M(&UU<W0@8F4@;65T(&EN(&]R9&5R(`T*9F]R($UE;6)E<G,@=&\@969F96-T
M(&-H86YG97,@=&\@=&AE(&)Y;&%W<R!O<B!C;W)P;W)A=&4@<W1R=6-T=7)E
M(&]F('1H92!/<F=A;FEZ871I;VXN("`-"E-P96-I9FEC86QL>2P@07)T:6-L
M92`V(&%D9')E<W-E<R!A9&]P=&EO;B!A;F0@;6]D:69I8V%T:6]N(&]F(&)Y
M;&%W<RP@86YN=6%L(&UE971I;F=S+"`-"F%N9"!S<&5C:6%L(&UE971I;F=S
M(&9O<B!T:&4@96QE8W1I;VX@;V8@9&ER96-T;W)S+"!A;&P@8VQE87)L>2!A
M<F5A<R!O9B!#;W)P;W)A=&4@#0I';W9E<FYA;F-E+@T*#0I4;W`@1&]W;@T*
M#0I&<F]M(&$@=&]P+61O=VX@<&5R<W!E8W1I=F4L('1H92!)145%($-O;G-T
M:71U=&EO;B!A;F0@0GEL87=S(')E9F5R96YC92!A;F0@<V5R=F4@=&\@#0IE
M<W1A8FQI<V@@=&AE($E%144@=6YD97(@=&AE(&%U=&AO<FET>2!O9B!T:&4@
M3F5W(%EO<FL@3F]T+69O<BU0<F]F:70@0V]R<&]R871I;VX@3&%W+B`@#0I)
M;B!S;R!D;VEN9RP@=&AE($E%144@:&%S(&]B;&EG871E9"!I='-E;&8@=&\@
M8V]N9'5C="!I=',@0V]R<&]R871E($=O=F5R;F%N8V4@=6YD97(@=&AE(`T*
M<W1R:6-T=7)E<R!O9B!T:&4@3F5W(%EO<FL@3F]T+69O<BU0<F]F:70@0V]R
M<&]R871I;VX@3&%W+"!I;F-L=61I;F<@=&AE(&UA;FYE<B!I;B`-"G=H:6-H
M(&ET(&-A;&-U;&%T97,@82!M86IO<FET>2!V;W1E+@T*#0I4:&4@245%12!"
M>6QA=W,@<')O=FED92!A(&9R86UE=V]R:R!F;W(@=&AE(&=O=F5R;F%N8V4@
M;V8@<W5B<V5Q=65N="!)145%(`T*;W)G86YI>F%T:6]N86P@=6YI=',@=VAI
M8V@@<W1A=&5S('1H870@=&AE('-T<FEC='5R97,@;V8@=&AE($YE=R!9;W)K
M($YO="UF;W(M4')O9FET(`T*0V]R<&]R871I;VX@3&%W+"!)145%($-O;G-T
M:71U=&EO;BP@86YD($E%144@0GEL87=S('=I;&P@9FQO=R!D;W=N('1O('1H
M92`-"FEM<&QE;65N=&%T:6]N(&]F('1H92!C;VYS=&ET=71I;VYA;"!P<F]V
M:7-I;VYS+"!B=70@=&AA="!2;V)E<G0G<R!2=6QE<R!O9B!/<F1E<B!W:6QL
M(&)E(`T*=7-E9"!I;B!T:&4@8V]N9'5C="!O9B!B=7-I;F5S<RX-"@T*5&AE
M($]R9V%N:7IA=&EO;B!D;V-U;65N=',@97-S96YT:6%L;'D@9FQO=R!D;W=N
M('1H:7,@;6]D96P@=&AR;W5G:"!T:&4@36%J;W(@0F]A<F0L(`T*4V]C:65T
M>2P@86YD($UI;F]R($)O87)D(&1O8W5M96YT<R!A=71H;W)I>FEN9R!T:&4@
M:6YF97)I;W(@96YT:71I97,@8F5L;W<@=&AE;2!W:&EL92`-"G!A<W-I;F<@
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M:VEN9R!'<F]U<"!I<R!A(&-O;G-T:71U=&EO;F%L(&%C="`-"F]F(&-O<G!O
M<F%T92!G;W9E<FYA;F-E(&]R('1H92!C;VYD=6-T(&]F('1H92!B=7-I;F5S
M<R!F;W(@=VAI8V@@:70@=V%S(&9O<FUE9"X@($EF(&ET(&ES(&$@#0IC;VYS
M=&ET=71I;VYA;"!A8W0@;V8@8V]R<&]R871E(&=O=F5R;F%N8V4L('1H96X@
M=&AE(&1E9FEN:71I;VX@;V8@;6%J;W)I='D@;75S="!B92`-"FEN=&5R<')E
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M(&1I<F5C=&5D(&)Y('1H92!)145%($-3(%-!0B!0)E`N("`-"E1H870@=&AE
M(&1E=F5L;W!M96YT(&]F(&$@9')A9G0@<W1A;F1A<F0@:7,@=&AE(&-O;F1U
M8W0@;V8@=&AE(&)U<VEN97-S(&9O<B!W:&EC:"!I="!W87,@#0IF;W)M960@
M:7,@8VQE87(@9G)O;2!T:&4@9&ER96-T:79E<R!O9B!T:&4@245%12!#4R!3
M04(@4"90+B`@5&\@97)A<V4@86YY(&1O=6)T(&]N('1H:7,@#0IS8V]R92P@
M22!N;W1E('1H870@;W1H97(@:6YF97)I;W(@96YT:71I97,@;V8@=&AE($E%
M144L(&EN8VQU9&EN9R!T:&4@3&5A<FYI;F<@5&5C:&YO;&]G>2`-"E-T86YD
M87)D<R!#;VUM:71T964@4W!O;G-O<BP@<F5F97)E;F-E('1H92!U<V4@;V8@
M4F]B97)T)W,@4G5L97,@;V8@3W)D97(L(&%N9"`-"G-P96-I9FEC86QL>2!C
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M5%-#(%-T86YD87)D<R`-"D-O;6UI='1E97,@:7,@;6]R92!T:&%N(&]N92UH
M86QF("@^-3`E*2!997,@=F]T97,@;V8@=&AE('1O=&%L(%EE<R!A;F0@#0I.
M;R!V;W1E<R!C87-T+"!E>&-L=61I;F<@86)S=&5N=&EO;G,N#0I6;W1E<R!A
M<F4@<F5C;W)D960@87,@)UEE<R<[("=.;R<[("=!8G-T86EN)R!O<B`G3FEL
MEG)E='5R;B<N#0I&;W(@9&5T97)M:6YI;F<@;W5T8V]M97,@;VYL>2!997,@
M86YD($YO('9O=&5S(&%R92!U<V5D('1O(&1E=&5R;6EN92`-"G!E<F-E;G1A
M9V5S+@T*#0I#;VYC;'5S:6]N#0H-"D9O<B!T:&4@<F5A<V]N<R!E;G5M97)A
M=&5D(&EN('1H92!F;W)E9V]I;F<@86YA;'ES:7,L(&ET(&ES(&-L96%R('1H
M92!V;W1E('1A:V5N(&EN(`T*8V]N;F5C=&EO;B!W:71H(&%N(&4M;6%I;"!B
M86QL;W0@8V]N9'5C=&5D(&)Y('1H92!7;W)K:6YG($=R;W5P('1O(&1E=&5R
M;6EN92!W:&5T:&5R(`T*82!D;V-U;65N="!S:&]U;&0@8F5C;VUE(&$@8F%S
M92!D;V-U;65N="!S:&]U;&0@8F4@8V]N9'5C=&5D+"!A;F0@=&AE(&1E9FEN
M:71I;VX@;V8@#0IM86IO<FET>2!I;G1E<G!R971E9"P@=6YD97(@4F]B97)T
M)W,@4G5L97,@;V8@3W)D97(N#0H-"E-I;F-E<F5L>2P-"@T*#0I"96YE9&EC
M="!/)TUA:&]N97D-"E9I8V4@4')E<VED96YT+"!!9&UI;FES=')A=&EO;B!A
M;F0@3&5G86P@069F86ER<PT*365M;W)A;F1U;2!O;B`-"DE%144@5V]R:VEN
?9R!'<F]U<"!6;W1E#0I086=E(#$@;V8@.0T*#0H-"@==
`
end