Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

RE: A NEW FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT FORMAL MOTION: was RE: SUO: Re: SUO Ballot with 2 Questions




Eric,

>Even if this group could or should toss out those members that don't
>really believe in a single SUO, the relatively unified remaining group
>members (including myself) would not be able to let go of their pet
>content.  The content merging process would be a battle at every
>pair/group of competing axioms.

I think such a "battle" could actually be extremely 
productive.  Conversations about particular axioms is exactly what I would 
expect a more focused version of this group to be engaged in.  Even if 
agreement could not be reached, then we would have a far more concrete 
justification for particular, possibly incompatible theories.  If agreement 
were reached, then we'd have achieved a single standard.  No matter what, 
we'd still learn something.

Adam