Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Motion M0061.02 : YES



I vote YES on Motion RevisedFlavorsText.

A few comments though:

As Hossam Fahmy already mentioned, the overview is a bit too restrictive. For instance, it precludes a function to receive and return intervals corresponding to a given flavor, yet internally use a flavor better suited for its computations.

The last paragraph of 7.5.4 is a bit restrictive too. It might well happen that two different implementations are just incomparable. I am thinking in particular of elementary functions; which one of two implementations is the most accurate presumably depends on the input domain (values close to zero, large values, etc) due to their having different argument reduction.

Best regards,

Guillaume