CommentID~CommenterName~CommenterEmail~CommenterPhone~CommenterFax~CommenterCo~Clause~Subclause~Page~Line~CommentType~Comment~SuggestedRemedy~Response~CommentStatus~ResponseStatus
0~Jie, Liang~jliang@ieee.org~2144804105~~Texas Instruments~11~2~~~T~Section 11.2 (Packet Scheduling for Improving SCO Links) needs to be harmonized with Bluetooth 1.x Speech Improvement when schedules from both groups allow.~Depending on the progress/schedule of this LB, it may be possible to incorporate changes to harmonize with Bluetooth SIG. If it becomes feasible to do so, changes are recommended.~~X~O
0~Jie, Liang~jliang@ieee.org~2144804105~~Texas Instruments~12~~~~T~Section 12 (Adaptive Frequency Hopping) needs to be harmonized with Bluetooth Coexistence group work when schedules from both groups allow.~When the schedule for this LB allows, AFH section should be harmonized with Bluetooth SIG.~~X~O
0~Jie, Liang~jliang@ieee.org~2144804105~~Texas Instruments~05~3, 4~~~T~Need to consider the impact of equalizer for the coexistence PHY model simulation.~Suggest adding multipath results in the simulated and analytical results.~~X~O
0~Jie, Liang~jliang@ieee.org~2144804105~~Texas Instruments~00~~~~T~Some of the simulation curves only cover BER down to somewhere between 10-2 and 10-3. Should use BER of at lease 10-4 as the threshold for more useful results, because a BER of 10-2 to 10-3 will yield too high a Packet error rate for pactical usage.~Rerun simulation to extend the results to more BERs. ~~X~O
0~Jie, Liang~jliang@ieee.org~2144804105~~Texas Instruments~06~~~~T~Should use BT hopping sequence instead of random sequence in MAC OpNet model~Change the hopping sequence in the MAC model to BT sequence~~X~O
0~Jie, Liang~jliang@ieee.org~2144804105~~Texas Instruments~10~4~~~~Take out Section 10.4: the method is only shown effective for 802.11b 1Mbit/s mode. The impact of equalizer is unknown. Cost of implementing an 802.15.1 receiver to just get the hopping sequence and timing is expensive and hardly feasible due to cost consideration.~Take this section out or ask more results to backup its performance: 2,5.5, 11mbps, with equalizer considered.~~X~O
0~Jie, Liang~jliang@ieee.org~2144804105~~Texas Instruments~00~~~~E~It would be nice to have source code for the PHY coexistence model as Appendix~Add if possible.~~X~O
0~Jie, Liang~jliang@ieee.org~2144804105~~Texas Instruments~00~~~~E~It would be nice to have the OPNET MAC model as appendix.~Add if possible.~~X~O
0~Jie, Liang~jliang@ieee.org~2144804105~~Texas Instruments~00~~~~E~lines after figure number, i.e. figure 34-~Correct the typos.~~X~O
