CommentID~CommenterName~CommenterEmail~CommenterPhone~CommenterFax~CommenterCo~Clause~Subclause~Page~Line~CommentType~Comment~SuggestedRemedy~Response~CommentStatus~ResponseStatus
0~Kandala, Srinivas~srini@sharplabs.com~(360) 817-7512~(360) 907-7318~Sharp Laboratories of America, Inc.~01~2~2~21~E~IEEE 802.11b is mis-spelled as 802.119~Correct~~X~O
0~Kandala, Srinivas~srini@sharplabs.com~(360) 817-7512~(360) 907-7318~Sharp Laboratories of America, Inc.~04~1~6~28~TR~Given that a modification of PCF (called HCF) would most certainly exist in the future, I think the co-existence mechanism should cover that as well~Provide a mechanism that addresses co-existence in PCF and HCF~~X~O
0~Kandala, Srinivas~srini@sharplabs.com~(360) 817-7512~(360) 907-7318~Sharp Laboratories of America, Inc.~04~1.2~7~38~E~Misspelled "an" as "in"~Correct~~X~O
0~Kandala, Srinivas~srini@sharplabs.com~(360) 817-7512~(360) 907-7318~Sharp Laboratories of America, Inc.~05~3.3~13~~E~It is not clear how the spectrum factor values have been derived. An informative reference would be useful to the reader.~Provide an informative reference~~X~O
0~Kandala, Srinivas~srini@sharplabs.com~(360) 817-7512~(360) 907-7318~Sharp Laboratories of America, Inc.~10~~40~~E~It is not clear from the text if PTA is another technique or part of AWMA. Both of them appear to have the requirement of WLAN/802.11 and WPAN/802.15.1 are collocated. Also, is there a reason to distinguish between WLAN and 802.11 as well as WPAN and 802.15.1~Clarify~~X~O
0~Kandala, Srinivas~srini@sharplabs.com~(360) 817-7512~(360) 907-7318~Sharp Laboratories of America, Inc.~10~2~~~TR~It appears to me that the AWMA technique can be easily extended to PCF/HCF.~Make it so.~~X~O
0~Kandala, Srinivas~srini@sharplabs.com~(360) 817-7512~(360) 907-7318~Sharp Laboratories of America, Inc.~10~3.5~55~~TR~Table 24, third column (PCF(as CF-pollable STA)): This condition here seems rather artificial. If a STA gets a poll and has a WLAN MPDU to send, would it be still denied access? Am I not understanding this correctly?~Clarify. If my understanding is correct, remove this restriction.~~X~O
0~Kandala, Srinivas~srini@sharplabs.com~(360) 817-7512~(360) 907-7318~Sharp Laboratories of America, Inc.~10~2~~~TR~As the recommendation suggests additions of the Information elements, this needs to be added into 802.11 standard so that non-802.15.2 devices can still be conformant~Work with 802.11 group to make that addition.~~X~O
