[STDS-802-16] Comment on C802.16e-05/404r1

[JaeWeon Cho <jaeweon.cho@samsung.com>]

Phillip,

 

I have just one comment on your reply comment (to #8025) in 404r1.

 

#8025, Remedy 16. (i.e. replacing the equation in line 15-18, page 426)

I don’t agree with this proposed change.

             The number of clusters (i.e. Nclusters) is ‘120’ in Cor1, but it varies with FFT sizes in 16e.

             So, the current equation in 16e/D11 cannot be replaced with that in Cor1/D5.

             If the remedy 16 in 404r1 is just for better looking of the equation,

         ‘120’ shall be replaced with ‘Ncluster’ in the equation and

‘All SC indicator = 0’ with ‘Use All AC Indicator = 0’ (typo in Cor1.)

 

I agree with the other reply comments in 404r1.

 

Thank you.

Jaeweon.