IEEE 802.16 Recirculation Ballot #4a: Voting Report

Final results (finalized 2002-03-15), updated to include changes through comment resolution of Session #18.

Dates: 8-25 February 2002

See also:

• Confirmation Ballot #4b voting report
• comment report (Document IEEE 802.16-02/01r13) [open in Commentary]
• Call for Reply Comments
• Announcement of Working Group Recirculation Ballot #4a on P802.16/D2
• Letter Ballot #4 voting report
• Task Group a

Summary

Ballot Details (Modified following comment resolution.)

Name\Family	Name\Given	Vote in Ballot #4	Vote in Recirc #4a (default is LB#4 vote)
Agrawal	Aditya	Approve, No Comments
An	Song	Approve, No Comments
Antonello	Gordon	Disapprove	Approve, Comments
Arefi	Reza	Approve, No Comments
Ariyavisitakul	S. Lek	Approve, No Comments
Arrakoski	Jori	Disapprove	Disapprove
Arunachalam	Arun	Decline
Audeh	Malik	Approve, Comments	Approve, Comments
Avera	Drayt	Decline
Avivi	Eli	Approve, No Comments
Baragar	Ian	Approve, No Comments
Baugh	C.R. (Rick)	Decline
Belfiore	Carlos	Decline
Benyamin-Seeyar	Anader	Approve, Comments	Approve, Comments
Brennan	James	Abstain for Lack of Time
Bushue	Carl	Approve, No Comments**
Buskila	Baruch	Approve, No Comments
Caso	Gregory	Decline
Chang	Yuankai	Approve, No Comments
Chang	Dean	Approve, No Comments
Chauncey	David	Approve, No Comments
Chayat	Naftali	Approve, No Comments	Disapprove
Chayer	Rémi	Approve, No Comments	Approve, Comments
Coles	Ronald	Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Condie	Mary	Decline
Cornelius	James	Abstain for Lack of Time
Costa	José	Approve, Comments
Donahue	Michael	Approve, No Comments
Dotan	Amos	Approve, No Comments
Durand	Roger	Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Edmonston	Brian	Approve, No Comments
Eidson	Brian	Disapprove	Approve, Comments*
Eilts	Henry	Approve, No Comments
Eklund	Carl	Disapprove	Approve, Comments
El-Damhougy	Hesham	Decline
Erceg	Vinko	Decline
Fishel	George	Decline
Florea	Adrian	Decline
Foster	Robert	Decline
Freedman	Avraham	Approve, Comments	Approve, Comments
Garrett	Andrew	Approve, No Comments
Garrison	G. Jack	Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Gieschen	Brian	Disapprove	Disapprove
Goldhammer	Marianna	Approve, No Comments	Disapprove
Guillemette	Phil	Decline
Hadad	Zion	Approve, No Comments
Hakim	Joseph	Approve, Comments
Halachmi	Baruch	Decline
Hamilton	Michael	Abstain for Lack of Time
Harteneck	Moritz	Approve, Comments
Hatim	Baya	Approve, No Comments
Hebron	Yoav	Approve, No Comments
Heise	Bob	Decline
Hosur	Srinath	Approve, No Comments
Hum	Coleman	Approve, No Comments
Hunter	Wayne	Decline
Husson	David	Approve, Comments
Jackson	Du Wayne	Approve, Comments
Jacobsen	Eric	Disapprove	Disapprove
Jamali	Hamadi	Approve, No Comments
Joo	Panyuh	Decline	Disapprove
Jorgensen	Jacob	Approve, No Comments
Kaitz	Tal	Disapprove	Approve, Comments*
Kang	Inchul	Abstain for Lack of Time
Kasslin	Mika	Disapprove	Approve, Comments*
Kelly	Phil	Approve, No Comments
Kelman	Ofer	Approve, No Comments
Kiernan	Brian	Approve, No Comments
Kim	John	Decline
Kitroser	Itzik	Approve, Comments	Approve, Comments
Klein	Allan	Decline
Klein	Jay	Approve, No Comments
Kolze	Thomas	Disapprove
Kostas	Demosthenes	Decline
Krinock	Jerome	Disapprove	Approve, Comments*
Krishnamoorthy	Rajeev	Decline
Kwak	Byung-Jae	Decline
Labs	Jonathan	Approve, No Comments	Approve, Comments
Langley	John	Approve, No Comments	Approve, Comments
Lee	Chin-Chen	Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Leiba	Yigal	Approve, Comments*	Approve, Comments
Leng	Minfei	Decline
Levinson	Moshe	Approve, No Comments
Lewis	Barry	Decline
Licardie	Sergio	Decline
Liebetreu	John	Approve, No Comments
Lindh	Lars	Disapprove	Disapprove
Lo	Titus	Decline
Lou	Hui-Ling	Approve, Comments
Lu	Willie	Decline
Lycklama	Heinz	Disapprove
Malkemes	Robert	Decline
Marin	J. Scott	Disapprove	Approve, No Comments
Markarian	Garik	Approve, No Comments
Marks	Roger	Disapprove	Approve, Comments
McCallister	Ronald	Abstain for Lack of Time
McGregor	Andy	Decline
McKown	Russell	Approve, No Comments
Mehta	Sushil	Decline
Meyer	Ronald	Approve, No Comments
Middleton	Andrew	Approve, No Comments
Mitlin	Vlad	Decline
Mody	Apurva	Approve, Comments	Disapprove
Moghe	Sanjay	Decline
Mollenauer	James	Decline
Monk	Anton	Decline
Murias	Ronald	Disapprove	Approve, No Comments
Music	Wayne	Decline
Myers	William	Decline
Nadeau	Jim	Decline
Nelson	Bob	Disapprove	Approve, Comments
Olszewski	Kim	Approve, No Comments
Padan	Uzi	Approve, No Comments
Paff	Mike	Disapprove	Approve, No Comments
Patel	Manish	Decline
Peirce	Kenneth	Approve, Comments
Ponnuswamy	Subbu	Disapprove	Approve, Comments*
Quilez	Vicente	Decline
Rafie	Manouchehr	Decline
Ran	Moshe	Approve, Comments
Regev	Einan	Decline
Reible	Stanley	Approve, No Comments
Resheff	Guy	Decline
Rhodes	Valentine	Decline
Robinson	Gene	Approve, No Comments
Roehr	Walt	Approve, Comments
Sarajedini	Amir	Approve, Comments
Sarca	Octavian	Decline
Sari	Hikmet	Approve, Comments
Satapathy	Durga	Approve, No Comments
Sater	Glen	Decline
Scaringi	Vito	Decline
Scarpa	Carl	Approve, No Comments
Schwartz	Randall	Approve, No Comments
Segal	Yossi	Approve, Comments
Selea	Radu	Decline
Seller	Olivier	Approve, No Comments
Shahar	Menashe	Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Shan	Tie-Jun	Decline
Shani	David	Decline
Shenhav	Chaim	Approve, No Comments
Shirali	Chet	Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Simkins	James	Approve, No Comments
Singh	Manoneet	Disapprove	Approve, No Comments
Singleton	Ken	Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Smith	Steven	Decline
Son	Jung Je	Decline	Approve, No Comments
Sonander	Sean	Approve, No Comments
Stamatelos	George	Decline
Stambaugh	Karl	Abstain for Lack of Time
Stanwood	Kenneth	Approve, Comments
Stewart	Michael	Approve, Comments*
Struhsaker	Paul	Disapprove	Approve, Comments
Sydor	John	Approve, No Comments
Taylor	Shawn	Disapprove	Disapprove
Tellado	Jose	Decline
Thompson	Paul	Decline
Tiram-Regev	Ayelet	Approve, No Comments
Trinkwon	David	Disapprove
van Waes	Nico	Disapprove	Disapprove
Varma	Subir	Disapprove	Approve, No Comments
Wachira	Muya	Decline
Wang	Arthur	Abstain for Lack of Time
Wang	Lei	Disapprove	Disapprove
Wang	Chao-Chun	Decline
Wang	Stanley	Approve, No Comments
Ward	Robert	Decline	Abstain for Lack of Time
Watkins	Larry	Approve, No Comments**
Whitehead	Philip	Approve, No Comments
Whiting	Robert	Approve, No Comments
Williams	David	Decline
Wise	Curt	Decline
Yanover	Vladimir	Approve, Comments	Disapprove
Ye	Huanchun	Approve, No Comments
Zeng	Chaoming	Decline
Zhang	Wenhan	Approve, No Comments
Zuniga	Juan Carlos	Approve, No Comments
Zyskowski	Paul	Decline

*Changed from "Disapprove"
**Changed from "Decline"

Nonmember comments