Status: This ballot is closed and complete as of 11 September 2003. The draft will not be submitted for Sponsor Ballot because the P802.16d amendment PAR was replaced by the P802.16-REVd revision PAR. The draft resulting from the ballot will be used as the basis of draft P802.16-REVd/D1, to be subject to Working Group Letter Ballot #13.
IEEE 802.16 Working Group Recirculation Ballot #11b: Announcement {CLOSED; see comment database 802.16-03/18r12 (final, including comment resolutions and editor's notes)}
Question: To accept resolutions of comments from Working Group Recirculation Ballot #11a, as recorded in IEEE 802.16-03/18r8, and to forward, for IEEE 802 LMSC Sponsor Ballot, IEEE P802.16d/D3-2003.
Closing date: 1 September 2003 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 10 August 2003
Ballot Submission Form
Recirc Ballot #1a Call for Reply Comments: 7-16 July 2003
IEEE 802.16 Working Group Recirculation Ballot #11a: Announcement {CLOSED; see comment database 802.16-03/18r7}
Question: To accept resolutions of comments from Working Group Letter Ballot #11, as recorded in IEEE 802.16-03/18r3, and to forward, for IEEE 802 LMSC Sponsor Ballot, IEEE P802.16d/D2-2003.Letter Ballot #11 Call for Reply Comments: 5-9 May 2003 {CLOSED; see comment database 802.16-03/18r1}
Closing date: 4 July 2003 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 4 June 2003
Ballot Submission Form
IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #11: Announcement {CLOSED; see comment database 802.16-03/18}
Question: To forward IEEE P802.16d/D1-2003 for LMSC Sponsor Ballot.
Closing date: 1 May 2003 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 1 April 2003
Ballot Submission Form
| Report Date | Approve | Dis | Votes |
Approval
Ratio |
Approval Ratio
Condition Met (>75%) |
Abstain | Ballots | Members |
Return
Ratio |
Return Ratio
Condition Met (>=50%) |
Return
Shortfall |
Approval |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
2003/09/01
(RB #11b: Final) |
49
|
6
|
55
|
89.1%
|
Yes
|
3
|
58
|
70
|
82.9%
|
Yes
|
0
|
Yes*
|
|
2003/07/05
(RB #11a: Final) |
44 | 11 | 55 |
80.0%
|
Yes | 3 | 58 | 70 | 82.9% | Yes | 0 | Yes* |
|
2003/05/05
(LB #11: Final) |
42 | 12 | 54 | 77.8% | Yes | 3 | 57 | 70 | 81.4% | Yes | 0 | Yes* |
| Name\Family | Name\Given | Vote: Letter Ballot #11 (Final) |
Vote: Recirc Ballot #11a
|
Vote: Recirc Ballot #11b
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agrawal | Aditya | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Antonello | Gordon | Approve, Comments |
Approve, Comments
|
Approve, Comments
|
| Arefi | Reza | - |
|
|
| Arrakoski | Jori | Approve, Comments |
|
|
| Audeh | Malik | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Avivi | Eli | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Banister | Brian | - |
|
|
| Benyamin- Seeyar | Anader | - |
Approve, No Comments
|
|
| Buskila | Baruch | - |
|
|
|
Castelow
|
David
|
|
|
Comments only
|
| Chang | Dean | Approve, No Comments |
Disapprove
|
|
| Chayat | Naftali | Disapprove |
|
Approve, No Comments
|
| Chayer | Rémi | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Dick | Stephen | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Edmonston | Brian | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Eidson | Brian | Approve, Comments* |
Approve, Comments
|
|
| Eilts | Henry | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Eklund | Carl | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Fan | John | - |
|
|
| Freedman | Avraham | Disapprove |
Approve, No Comments
|
|
| Garrison | G. Jack | Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise |
|
|
| Goldhammer | Marianna | Approve, Comments |
|
|
| Hadad | Zion | Disapprove |
|
|
| Husson | David | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Joo | Panyuh | Approve, No Comments |
|
Disapprove
|
| Kaitz | Tal | Disapprove |
Disapprove
|
Approve, Comments
|
| Kelly | Phil | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Kelman | Ofer | Approve, No Comments |
Approve, Comments
|
|
| Kiernan | Brian | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Kitroser | Itzik | Disapprove |
Disapprove
|
Disapprove
|
| Klerer | Mark | - |
|
|
| Kolze | Thomas | Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise |
|
|
| Kuo | Chun-Ming | - |
|
|
| Labs | Jonathan | Disapprove |
|
Approve, No Comments
|
| Lee | Seung-Hwan | - |
|
|
| Leiba | Yigal | Disapprove |
Disapprove
|
Approve, Comments
|
| Li | Lingjie | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Liebetreu | John | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Lindh | Lars | Approve, No Comments | Approve, Comments |
|
| Lou | Hui-Ling | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Lycklama | Heinz | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Marks | Roger | Approve, Comments |
Approve, Comments
|
|
| McKown | Russell | Approve, No Comments |
Approve, Comments
|
Approve, Comments
|
| Middleton | Andrew | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Mody | Apurva | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Mollenauer | James | - |
|
|
| Murias | Ronald | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Nelson | Robert | Approve, Comments |
Approve, Comments
|
Approve, Comments
|
| Reible | Stanley | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Robinson | Gene | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Roman | Vincentzio | - |
|
|
| Sarajedini | Amir | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Schwartz | Randall | - |
|
|
| Segal | Yossi | Disapprove |
Disapprove
|
Disapprove
|
| Selea | Radu | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Simkins | James | - |
|
|
| Stanwood | Kenneth | Approve, Comments |
Approve, Comments
|
|
| Struhsaker | Paul | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Taylor | Shawn | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Thomson | William | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Trinkwon | David | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Ullmann | Rainer | Disapprove |
|
Approve, No Comments
|
| van Waes | Nico | Disapprove |
Disapprove
|
|
| Verbin | Eyal | Disapprove |
Approve, Comments
|
Approve, Comments
|
| Wang | Arthur | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Wang | Lei | Approve, No Comments |
|
Approve, Comments
|
| Wang | Stanley | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Ward | Robert | - |
|
|
| Whitehead | Philip | Approve, No Comments |
|
|
| Wilson | Joanne | Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise |
|
|
| Yanover | Vladimir | Disapprove |
Disapprove
|
Approve, Comments
|