Dear all,
I updated the comment spreadsheet on D06 reflecting the discussion at the Tuesday TG3a session.
https://mentor.ieee.org/802.19/dcn/26/19-26-0057-02-003a-proposed-comments-assignment-and-resolutions-for-p802-19-3a-d06.xlsx
The result of comment assignment is as follows:
----
I updated the comment spreadsheet on D06 reflecting the discussion at the Tuesday TG3a session.
https://mentor.ieee.org/802.19/dcn/26/19-26-0057-02-003a-proposed-comments-assignment-and-resolutions-for-p802-19-3a-d06.xlsx
The result of comment assignment is as follows:
----
Benjamin A. Rolfe: I-1, I-6, I-38, I-206, I-207, I-208, I-210, I-211, I-213, I-214, I-216, I-217, I-218, I-221, I-223
Jianlin Guo: I-9, I-10, I-18, I-42, I-212, I-215, I-222
Yukimasa Nagai: I-11, I-31
Joerg Robert: I-30, I-209
Takenori Sumi: I-36
Yukimasa Nagai and Jianlin Guo: I-5, I-32, I-33
Yukimasa Nagai and Benjamin A. Rolfe: I-13
Jianlin Guo and Takenori Sumi: I-22, I-24
Benjamin A. Rolfe and Joerg Robert: I-23
Kazuto Yano: The others
----
Best regards,
Kazuto
Jianlin Guo: I-9, I-10, I-18, I-42, I-212, I-215, I-222
Yukimasa Nagai: I-11, I-31
Joerg Robert: I-30, I-209
Takenori Sumi: I-36
Yukimasa Nagai and Jianlin Guo: I-5, I-32, I-33
Yukimasa Nagai and Benjamin A. Rolfe: I-13
Jianlin Guo and Takenori Sumi: I-22, I-24
Benjamin A. Rolfe and Joerg Robert: I-23
Kazuto Yano: The others
----
Best regards,
Kazuto
2026年11月10日(火) 19:12 Kazuto Yano <kzyano@xxxxxxxx>:
Dear all,
I merged Ben's proposed resolutions and mine as in 19-26/0057r1 for easy comparison. Ben's resolutions are incorporated into Column X.
https://mentor.ieee.org/802.19/dcn/26/19-26-0057-01-003a-proposed-comments-assignment-and-resolutions-for-p802-19-3a-d06.xlsx
Best regards,
Kazuto2026年11月10日(火) 17:35 Benjamin Rolfe <ben@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>:Sorry, I forgot the link (or even document #)
From: Benjamin Rolfe on behalf of Benjamin Rolfe <ben@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Sent: Tuesday, November 10, 2026 12:34 AM
To: stds-802-19@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx <stds-802-19@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: Comment resolution contribution for 19.3aHi all,I've prepared a contribution to start the discussion. I have identified some comments I think we can resolve easily and suggested proposed resolutions to discuss. In some cases I made a guess who might have the answers. Look at the "Notes" column for my proposals.
Note a few are really "accepted" but I didn't think the comment might not be completely clear. To be safe I suggest i these cases we are explicit in the disposition detail as to what is being done. Also I scanned editorials too, but I think we should rely on our technical editors to deal with that instead, so you can filter out editorials.
Thanks allBen
To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-19 list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-19&A=1
