[802.3_YANG] Comparing MIB, YANG Ethernet statistics against clause 30.

[Robert Wilton <rwilton@xxxxxxxxx>]

Hi,

I put a spreadsheet together to compare the various Ethernet related 
counters that I propose being modeled in YANG, and how they relate back 
to the various MIBs and clause 30, using some of the knowledge already 
in 802.3.1.

In pulling this together, I think that this highlights some counters 
that I propose modelling in YANG (and have modeled in various MIBs) that 
are not defined in clause 30 and I think that we should consider adding 
them:

The counters that don't appear to be defined in clause 30 are:
 Row 17: In PFC frames (used in  ETHERLIKE MIB dot3HCInPFCFrames)
 Row 18: Out PFC frames (used in ETHERLIKE MIB dot3HCOutPFCFrames)
 Row 19: Total Octets received (good & bad) (used in RMON MIB 
etherStatsOctets)
 Row 25: Frames dropped as being too short. (combined value of two RMON 
MIB counters (etherStatsUndersizePkts + etherStatsFragments))

Perhaps we could discuss whether it would be appropriate to add them on 
Monday?

Thanks,
Rob

Attachment: 802.3_YANG_Relationships.xlsx
Description: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet