Dr. Everett O. (Buzz) Rigsbee
Boeing - SSG
PO Box 3707, M/S: 7M-FM
Seattle, WA 98124-2207
(425) 865-2443 Fx: (425) 865-6721
----- Original Message -----
May 24, 2003 9:51 AM
[802SEC] +++SEC MOTION+++ Motion: Authorize Forwarding of the 802.11g draft to
At 09:31 PM 5/21/03 -0400, Paul Nikolich wrote:
is a 15 day SEC email ballot to make a determination by an SEC motion to
authorize forwarding 802.11g Draft 8.2 to RevCom.
by Stuart J. Kerry
by Bob Heile
ballot opens on Wednesday May 21st, 2003 10PM ET and closes Thursday June 5th,
2003 10PM ET.
direct your responses to the SEC reflector with a CC directly to me (firstname.lastname@example.org).
SUPPORTING INFORMATION / DOCUMENTATION Below:
LAST SPONSOR BALLOT RESULTS:
P802.11g/D8.2 2nd IEEE Recirculation Ballot which Closed 2003-05-14, and
obtained a 95% approval.
ballot has met the 75% returned ballot requirement.
eligible people in this ballot group.
negative votes with comments
negative votes without comments
votes received = 80% returned
75% affirmation requirement is being met.
votes with comments
votes = 95% affirmative
RESULTS OF TASK GROUP G AND 802.11 WG MOTIONS at DALLAS
802.11 session (May 2003):
to Forward IEEE 802.11g Draft 8.2 to the IEEE 802 SEC and to RevCom for Final
Group G: 26 / 0 / 0
WG: 102 / 0 / 2
SUMMARY OF REMAINING VOTERS ISSUES:
Attached is a summary of status of the three "no" voters (O'Farrell,
Moreton, Gilb) and the one new "yes" with comments voter (Monteban).
Tim O'Farrell, Supergold
Tim voted NO on the first Sponsor Ballot, i.e. Draft 6.1 of IEEE 802.11g.
We have not been able to contact him sense. E-mails were sent on both
recirculation ballots requesting his response. At the April 2003 session
of 802.11g, multiple attempts were made to contact Tim to no avail. On
the first recirculation ballot, Tim provided five comments. One comments
was editorial, and it was accepted. The other four comments were
technical. Tim had two comments related to removing optional
functionality, which were both rejected. Tim also had two comments
related to ACR which were both rejected.
Summary for Tim O'Farrell
Voted "No" on first sponsor ballot
Has not voted on last of the recirculation ballots
Attempts at contact have failed
Mike Moreton, Synad
Mike voted NO WITH COMMENTS on Draft 8.2. All of Mike comments were
editorial. Mike currently maintains his NO vote based on previously
Summary for Mike Moreton
Voted "No" on Draft 8.2 based on previously submitted
Submitted no new technical comments on Draft 8.2
Submitted 7 editorial comments
All editorial comments were rejected
James Gilb, Appairent
James also voted NO WITH COMMENTS on Draft 8.2. All of James comments
have previously been circulated. James maintains his NO vote base on
previously circulated comments.
Summary for James Gilb
Voted "No" on Draft 8.2
Submitted 14 technical and editorial comments on Draft 8.2
None of the technical comments are new
All comments were rejected
Leo Monteban, Agere
Leo voted YES WITH COMMENTS on Draft 8.2. Leo submitted two editorial
comments. Both editorial comments were found to be non-substantive by
IEEE 802.11 Task Group G, thus both were rejected.
Summary for Leo Monteban
Cast a "Yes" vote with two comments
Both comments were editorial
Both comments were rejected
Comment Resolutions are included in Doc#: 11-03-381 rev.7 as posted to the
802.11 web site, which contains all the comments from the recirculation of
Draft 8.2. . A copy of which is attached for you convenience. The
document also contains Tim O'Farrell's comment from the first sponsor ballot
and Mike Moreton's and James Gilb's comments from the first ballot.
there were no new no votes or comments and no subsequent change was made to the
802.11g Draft 8.2, this ballot is concluded and D8.2 and supporting
documentation will be forwarded to RevCom for action at the upcoming meeting in
IEEE 802.11 WLANs WG
McKay Drive, M/S 48A SJ,
Jose, CA 95131-1706,
States of America.
: +1 (408) 474-7356
+1 (408) 474-7247
+1 (408) 348-3171
Chair, IEEE 802.15 Working Group on Wireless Personal
**************** NOTICE ****************
The information contained in this e-mail message and
any attachments may be complete garbage. Unauthorized use, disclosure, or
copying is strictly up to you. If you received this message
in error, please send it to the right person.