Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: NaI's as decorated empty sets



John Pryce schrieb:
On 9 Sep 2009, at 15:18, Arnold Neumaier wrote:
John Pryce schrieb:
I seem to be suffering mental exhaustion with all the ideas flying round, so I would appreciate a summary of the interval Newton method (esp. the multivariate case) showing how and where both the interval and the decoration are needed. It sounds as if it falls into the category I named B3 in my email of 8th Sept.

If F is continuous on X and F(X) in X then the intersection of F(X)
and X contains a zero of X. Clearly, both the interval and the decoration are needed here.
Why? One needs either F(X), or the knowledge that F may not be (defined and continuous) on X, but not both at once. That is, if "possiblyUndefined" is raised you don't need F(X) so you can overwrite it with a value that denotes "possiblyUndefined". This seems like my case B1, not B3.

I see that I didn't give a complete enough statement.

If possiblyUndefined or possiblyDiscontinuous are raised, you don't
have existence but you still know that any solution lies in Y, an information that is useful when Y is narrower than X.


Arnold Neumaier