| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
I support John’s suggestion below (and made at the December 4 patcom
meeting)
I understand it can be an administrative chore to capture comments and
disposition of comments on documents under development by a committee ... For
example John makes good points below about comments made at
meetings. It is my opinion in the case of developing documents
related to the patent policy the transparency benefits outweigh whatever
additional administrative effort is required. Plus given the availability
to IEEE of the comment and disposition tools employed during the
development of the patent policy itself, increased use of these tools for
other relevant documents might even facilitate the work.
At the very minimum I urge that the PP-DIALOG@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
be used to make available and to seek comments on relevant documents under
consideration by the patcom well in advance of formal patcom
meetings
George T.
Willingmyre
President GTW Associates From: Kolakowski, John
(Nokia - US/Herndon) I’m
directing this message to David Law, as I’m assuming he remains the Chair of
PatCom because I haven’t heard of any organizational changes that might be
occurring for 2016. I’d like
to repeat my suggestion made at the December PatCom meeting that PatCom
undertake a formal written comment process for the proposed new FAQs that were
on the agenda for the December meeting (and that now appear likely to be on the
agenda for the March meeting). As there is no recordation of comments made
orally at the actual meetings, it would be appreciated by Nokia if our opinions
and suggestions -- if we have any -- could be preserved via some formal
process. Moreover, as the larger set of FAQs previously was opened up for
a formal written comment process, it would be inconsistent to not do the same
for the new additions. Thank
you for considering this request and good New Year wishes to
all, John
Kolakowski Nokia
Networks From: EXT Dave Ringle [mailto:d.ringle@xxxxxxxx] The 4 December 2015 PatCom draft meeting minutes are
available at http://standards.ieee.org/about/sasb/patcom/1215patmins.pdf ****************************************************************** |